OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท ยง8. Angular obstructions and the final contradiction

Lemma 8.3: Dense locally compatible rotating families exclude mixed parity, and almost-everywhere restrictions on opposite inner products force antipodal interface vectors

Valid four-cycle words contain a fifth-color state.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The four-cycle interface problem concerns five-color palettes sampled in six directions around a circle. Its words distinguish the fifth color from the two diagonal states of the four-cycle.

Write ๐•‹=โ„/(2ฯ€โ„ค)\mathbb T=\mathbb R/(2\pi\mathbb Z) for the circle of angles, ฮผ\mu for its normalized Haar measure, and et=eite_t=e^{it} for the unit direction at tt. The rotation RR is given by Rt=t+ฯ€/3Rt=t+\pi/3; its six offsets are jฯ€/3j\pi/3, for 0โ‰คj<60\leq j<6. Let mm be planar Lebesgue measure. A weak measurable kk-coloring is an almost-everywhere measurable map c:โ„‚โ†’Fin(k)c:\mathbb C\to\mathrm{Fin}(k) satisfying the unit-distance exclusion in (1): c(z)โ‰ c(z+et)for (mร—ฮผ)-almost every (z,t).c(z)\ne c(z+e_t) \qquad\text{for }(m\times\mu)\text{-almost every }(z,t).(1)โœฆ For the circle constructions, assume that cc is Borel measurable.

A set AโІโ„‚A\subseteq\mathbb C has density one at zz when the limit in (2) is one, with the ratios taken in the extended nonnegative reals: limrโ†“0m(AโˆฉBยฏ(z,r))m(Bยฏ(z,r))=1.\lim_{r\downarrow0} \frac{m(A\cap\overline B(z,r))}{m(\overline B(z,r))}=1.(2)โœฆ A typical color point zโˆˆโ„‚z\in\mathbb C of cc is a point at which the color class {y:c(y)=c(z)}\{y:c(y)=c(z)\} has density one. A typical circle sampling (y,r)(y,r) of cc, with yโˆˆโ„‚y\in\mathbb C and r>0r>0, is a pair for which y+rety+r e_t is a typical color point for ฮผ\mu-almost every tt.โœฆ

Traces and Palettes

Let E=L2(๐•‹,ฮผ;โ„)E=L^2(\mathbb T,\mu;\mathbb R), with functions identified almost everywhere.โœฆ The weak unit ball ๐’ฒ(E)\mathcal W(E) consists of the elements of the weak dual of EE whose strong dual representatives have norm at most one.โœฆ Write JfJf for the Riesz duality image of fโˆˆEf\in E, and val⁡(a)\operatorname{val}(a) for the Hilbert vector corresponding to aโˆˆ๐’ฒ(E)a\in\mathcal W(E) under the inverse Riesz identification. The weak unit ball embedding is the map fโ†ฆJff\mapsto Jf from the set of vectors fโˆˆEf\in E with โˆฅfโˆฅ2โ‰ค1\|f\|_2\leq1 to ๐’ฒ(E)\mathcal W(E). A weak trace vector is a family bโˆˆ๐’ฒ(E)Fin(k)b\in\mathcal W(E)^{\mathrm{Fin}(k)}; its color components are bival=val⁡(bi)โˆˆEb_i^{\mathrm{val}}=\operatorname{val}(b_i)\in E.

The circle color indicator fy,r,if_{y,r,i} and the circle sampling vector b(y,r)b(y,r) are defined by (3), where brackets denote the L2L^2 class: fy,r,i(t)=๐Ÿ{c(y+ret)=i},b(y,r)=(J[fy,r,i])iโˆˆFin(k).\begin{aligned} f_{y,r,i}(t)&=\mathbf1_{\{c(y+r e_t)=i\}},\\ b(y,r)&=\bigl(J[f_{y,r,i}]\bigr)_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}(k)}. \end{aligned}(3) The typical circle sample graph ๐’ฎc\mathcal S_c consists of the triples (y,r,b(y,r))(y,r,b(y,r)) with typical circle sampling (y,r)(y,r).โœฆ For a center xโˆˆโ„‚x\in\mathbb C, a circle trace bb at xx is a weak trace vector satisfying the closure condition in (4); the set of such traces is ๐’ฏx\mathcal T_x: ๐’ฏx={b:(x,1,b)โˆˆ๐’ฎcยฏ}.\mathcal T_x=\{b:(x,1,b)\in\overline{\mathcal S_c}\}.(4) The closure uses the weak topology on the vector components.

The positive trace set Ui(b)U_i(b) of a trace bโˆˆ๐’ฏxb\in\mathcal T_x consists of the angles where its color component is strictly positive.โœฆ Choose countable palette generators ๐’ขx,iโІ๐’ฏx\mathcal G_{x,i}\subseteq\mathcal T_x whose positive trace sets realize the essential union of the full family.โœฆ The palette color set Sx,iS_{x,i} and the angular palette Px(et)P_x(e_t) are defined in (5): Ui(b)={t:bival(t)>0},Sx,i=โ‹ƒbโˆˆ๐’ขx,iUi(b),Px(et)={i:tโˆˆSx,i}.U_i(b)=\{t:b_i^{\mathrm{val}}(t)>0\},\qquad S_{x,i}=\bigcup_{b\in\mathcal G_{x,i}}U_i(b),\qquad P_x(e_t)=\{i:t\in S_{x,i}\}.(5)

Four-cycle Words

Specialize to five labels Fin(5)={0,1,2,3,4}\mathrm{Fin}(5)=\{0,1,2,3,4\}, and write In=โ„ค/nโ„คI_n=\mathbb Z/n\mathbb Z for cyclic index sets. The four interface edges are the color pairs in (6): E0={0,1},E1={1,2},E2={2,3},E3={3,0}.E_0=\{0,1\},\quad E_1=\{1,2\},\quad E_2=\{2,3\},\quad E_3=\{3,0\}.(6)โœฆ For vectors viโˆˆโ„‚v_i\in\mathbb C, iโˆˆI4i\in I_4, their interface sign si(t)s_i(t) is ++ when โŸจet,viโŸฉ>0\langle e_t,v_i\rangle>0 and โˆ’- otherwise.โœฆ For a sign pattern sโˆˆ{+,โˆ’}I4s\in\{+,-\}^{I_4} and a sign ฯƒโˆˆ{+,โˆ’}\sigma\in\{+,-\}, the allowed color set Cฯƒ(s)C_\sigma(s) excludes the edges bearing sign ฯƒ\sigma.โœฆ A compatible palette pโІFin(5)p\subseteq\mathrm{Fin}(5) is a nonempty set of at most two colors meeting both allowed sets, as in (7): Cฯƒ(s)=Fin(5)\โ‹ƒi:si=ฯƒEi,1โ‰ค|p|โ‰ค2,pโˆฉC+(s)โ‰ โŒ€,pโˆฉCโˆ’(s)โ‰ โŒ€.\begin{aligned} C_\sigma(s)&=\mathrm{Fin}(5)\setminus \bigcup_{i:s_i=\sigma}E_i,\\ 1\leq|p|&\leq2,\qquad p\cap C_+(s)\ne\varnothing,\qquad p\cap C_-(s)\ne\varnothing. \end{aligned}(7)

Denote the three states 0,1,20,1,2 by X,D0,D1X,D_0,D_1, respectively. For a palette pโІFin(5)p\subseteq\mathrm{Fin}(5) and a sign pattern sโˆˆ{+,โˆ’}I4s\in\{+,-\}^{I_4}, the canonical palette state q(p)q(p) and the interface diagonal state ฮ”(s)\Delta(s) are states defined by (8); XX is the outsider state: q(p)={X,4โˆˆp,D0,4โˆ‰p,0โˆˆp,D1,4โˆ‰p,0โˆ‰p,ฮ”(s)={D1,s0=s1,D0,s0โ‰ s1.q(p)= \begin{cases} X,&4\in p,\\ D_0,&4\notin p,\ 0\in p,\\ D_1,&4\notin p,\ 0\notin p, \end{cases} \qquad \Delta(s)= \begin{cases} D_1,&s_0=s_1,\\ D_0,&s_0\ne s_1. \end{cases}(8) The angular palette state qx(t)q_x(t) and the six-position interface word w(t)w(t) are given by (9): qx(t)=q(Px(et)),wj(t)=qx(Rjt)(jโˆˆI6).q_x(t)=q(P_x(e_t)),\qquad w_j(t)=q_x(R^j t)\quad(j\in I_6).(9)

A six-position word w:I6โ†’{X,D0,D1}w:I_6\to\{X,D_0,D_1\} is valid when adjacent states differ and nonoutsider states at opposite positions agree.โœฆ Write ๐–ต(w)\mathsf V(w) for the condition in (10): ๐–ต(w):wjโ‰ wj+1(jโˆˆI6),wjโ‰ X,wj+3โ‰ Xโ‡’wj+3=wj(jโˆˆI6).\mathsf V(w):\quad w_j\ne w_{j+1}\quad(j\in I_6),\qquad w_j\ne X,\ w_{j+3}\ne X\ \Longrightarrow\ w_{j+3}=w_j \quad(j\in I_6).(10)โœฆ A six-position word w:I6โ†’{X,D0,D1}w:I_6\to\{X,D_0,D_1\} is mixed when it has outsider positions of both parities. An ordered pair (w,u)(w,u) of six-position words w,u:I6โ†’{X,D0,D1}w,u:I_6\to\{X,D_0,D_1\} is cross-compatible when every nonoutsider state of ww differs from the two neighboring states of uu.โœฆ These conditions are denoted by ๐–ฌ\mathsf M and ๐–ข\mathsf C in (11), using the representatives 0,โ€ฆ,50,\ldots,5 for parity: ๐–ฌ(w):โˆƒi,jโˆˆI6,wi=wj=X,iโ‰ขj(mod⁡2),๐–ข(w,u):wjโ‰ Xโ‡’uj+1โ‰ wj and ujโˆ’1โ‰ wj(jโˆˆI6).\begin{aligned} \mathsf M(w)&:\quad \exists i,j\in I_6,\quad w_i=w_j=X,\quad i\not\equiv j\pmod2,\\ \mathsf C(w,u)&:\quad w_j\ne X\ \Longrightarrow\ u_{j+1}\ne w_j\ \text{ and }\ u_{j-1}\ne w_j \quad(j\in I_6). \end{aligned}(11)

The boundary set BโІ๐•‹B\subseteq\mathbb T consists of directions perpendicular to at least one viv_i. For interface vectors viv_i, iโˆˆI4i\in I_4, a split direction tโˆˆ๐•‹t\in\mathbb T is an angle for which no opposite pair of interface vectors has two strictly positive inner products with ete_t. B={t:โˆƒiโˆˆI4,โŸจet,viโŸฉ=0},t is splitโ‡”for every iโˆˆI4,ยฌ(โŸจet,viโŸฉ>0 and โŸจet,vi+2โŸฉ>0).\begin{aligned} B&=\{t:\exists i\in I_4,\ \langle e_t,v_i\rangle=0\},\\ t\text{ is split}&\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \text{for every }i\in I_4,\quad \neg\bigl(\langle e_t,v_i\rangle>0 \text{ and }\langle e_t,v_{i+2}\rangle>0\bigr). \end{aligned}(12)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let w:I6โ†’{X,D0,D1}w:I_6\to\{X,D_0,D_1\} be a valid word. Then โˆƒjโˆˆI6,wj=X.\exists j\in I_6,\qquad w_j=X.(13)โœฆ If ww is also not mixed, then โˆƒpโˆˆ{0,1},jโ‰กp(mod⁡2)whenever wj=X.\exists p\in\{0,1\},\qquad j\equiv p\pmod2\quad\text{whenever }w_j=X.(14)โœฆ

Let GโІ๐•‹G\subseteq\mathbb T be dense and invariant under RR, and let w(t)w(t) be a family of words valid on GG. Suppose that wj(Rt)=wj+1(t)w_j(Rt)=w_{j+1}(t) for tโˆˆGt\in G and jโˆˆI6j\in I_6. Suppose also that some ฮต>0\varepsilon>0 makes (w(t),w(u))(w(t),w(u)) cross-compatible whenever t,uโˆˆGt,u\in G and d(t,u)<ฮตd(t,u)<\varepsilon, where dd is the circle metric. Then ยฌ๐–ฌ(w(t))(tโˆˆG).\neg\mathsf M(w(t))\qquad(t\in G).(15)โœฆ

Let cc be a Borel measurable weak five-coloring, let xโˆˆโ„‚x\in\mathbb C, and let viv_i, iโˆˆI4i\in I_4, be unit vectors. Assume that Px(et)P_x(e_t) is compatible with s(t)s(t) for ฮผ\mu-almost every tt. For the interface words of (9), โˆƒGโІ๐•‹,โˆƒฮต>0:G is dense,R(G)โІG,โŸจeRjt,viโŸฉโ‰ 0(tโˆˆG,jโˆˆI6,iโˆˆI4),wj(t)โ‰ Xโ‡’wj(t)=ฮ”(s(Rjt))(tโˆˆG,jโˆˆI6),๐–ต(w(t))(tโˆˆG),๐–ข(w(t),w(u))(t,uโˆˆG,d(t,u)<ฮต).\begin{gathered} \exists G\subseteq\mathbb T,\ \exists\varepsilon>0:\qquad G\text{ is dense},\qquad R(G)\subseteq G,\\ \langle e_{R^j t},v_i\rangle\ne0 \qquad(t\in G,\ j\in I_6,\ i\in I_4),\\ w_j(t)\ne X\ \Longrightarrow\ w_j(t)=\Delta(s(R^j t))\qquad(t\in G,\ j\in I_6),\\ \mathsf V(w(t))\qquad(t\in G),\\ \mathsf C(w(t),w(u)) \qquad(t,u\in G,\ d(t,u)<\varepsilon). \end{gathered}(16)โœฆ

Let viv_i, iโˆˆI4i\in I_4, be unit vectors, and assume that ฮผ\mu-almost every direction is split. Then vi+2=โˆ’vi(iโˆˆI4).v_{i+2}=-v_i\qquad(i\in I_4).(17)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: in the four-cycle setting, every six-position word w(t)w(t) on the fixed dense, conull, RR-invariant set GG contains XX, all its XX positions have the same parity, and every direction outside BB is split.

What Is Checked

The assertions (13) and (14) concern individual cyclic words, while (15) concerns a dense rotating family with local cross-compatibility. The interface assertion (16) uses angular palettes of a Borel measurable weak five-coloring; the antipodal assertion (17) uses four unit vectors.

For a Borel measurable kk-label coloring, the circle indicators in (3) satisfy (18) for every yโˆˆโ„‚y\in\mathbb C, rโˆˆโ„r\in\mathbb R and iโˆˆFin(k)i\in\mathrm{Fin}(k): fy,r,iโˆˆL2(๐•‹,ฮผ;โ„),โˆฅ[fy,r,i]โˆฅ2โ‰ค1.f_{y,r,i}\in L^2(\mathbb T,\mu;\mathbb R),\qquad \|[f_{y,r,i}]\|_2\leq1.(18)