OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Circle traces and maximal palettes

Definition 5.1: Weak limits of angular color indicators and their positive sets

Circle samples define traces and palettes.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A circle centered near x∈ℂx\in\mathbb C samples the colors around xx by angle. Limits of these angular indicators describe the colors that persist as the center approaches xx and the radius approaches one.

Let k∈ℕk\in\mathbb N, let I={0,…,k−1}I=\{0,\ldots,k-1\} be the color labels, and let c:ℂ→Ic:\mathbb C\to I be Borel measurable. Write Ai=c−1({i})A_i=c^{-1}(\{i\}) for the iith color class. The angle circle is 𝕋=ℝ/(2πℤ)\mathbb T=\mathbb R/(2\pi\mathbb Z), with normalized angular Haar measure μ\mu, and e(t)=exp⁡(it)e(t)=\exp(it) is its unit direction in ℂ\mathbb C.

For a set A⊆ℂA\subseteq\mathbb C, its density-one points form the set 𝒟(A)\mathcal D(A) defined in (1), where mm is Lebesgue area and B¯(z,ρ)\overline B(z,\rho) is the closed disk: 𝒟(A)={z∈ℂ:limρ↓0m(A∩B¯(z,ρ))m(B¯(z,ρ))=1}.\mathcal D(A)=\left\{z\in\mathbb C: \lim_{\rho\downarrow0} \frac{m(A\cap\overline B(z,\rho))}{m(\overline B(z,\rho))}=1\right\}.(1)✦ The limit in (1) is taken in the extended nonnegative reals.

Let H=L2(𝕋,μ;ℝ)H=L^2(\mathbb T,\mu;\mathbb R) be the real Hilbert space of square-integrable functions modulo equality almost everywhere.✦ The weak unit ball Bw(H)B_w(H) of the real Hilbert space HH is the closed unit ball equipped with the weak topology.✦ Riesz duality identifies f∈Hf\in H with the functional g↦⟨f,g⟩g\mapsto\langle f,g\rangle; the corresponding dual ball has the same weak topology.✦ A trace vector b=(bi)i∈I∈Bw(H)Ib=(b_i)_{i\in I}\in B_w(H)^I is a tuple of elements of the weak unit ball; bib_i also denotes its underlying L2L^2 function. The weak unit ball embedding is the restriction of this identification to vectors f∈Hf\in H with ‖f‖2≤1\lVert f\rVert_2\leq1.✦

For a center y∈ℂy\in\mathbb C, radius r∈ℝr\in\mathbb R, and color i∈Ii\in I, the angular color indicator sy,r,is_{y,r,i} is the function on 𝕋\mathbb T given in (2): sy,r,i(t)=𝟏Ai(y+re(t)).s_{y,r,i}(t)=\mathbf 1_{A_i}\bigl(y+r e(t)\bigr).(2)✦ The circle sampling vector sy,rs_{y,r} is the tuple of the L2L^2 classes of (2), viewed in Bw(H)IB_w(H)^I.✦

The Claim

Definition 1. A typical point zz of the coloring cc is a point of the complex plane at which its own color class has density one.✦ The set TcT_c of typical points is specified by (3): Tc={z∈ℂ:z∈𝒟(Ac(z))}.T_c=\{z\in\mathbb C:z\in\mathcal D(A_{c(z)})\}.(3)✦

A typical circle sample (y,r)∈ℂ×ℝ(y,r)\in\mathbb C\times\mathbb R is a pair in the set 𝒯\mathcal T of (4): 𝒯={(y,r):r>0,y+re(t)∈Tc for μ-almost every t}.\mathcal T=\{(y,r):r>0,\quad y+r e(t)\in T_c \text{ for }\mu\text{-almost every }t\}.(4)✦ The sample graph 𝒮\mathcal S of typical circle samples is the set in (5): 𝒮={(y,r,sy,r):(y,r)∈𝒯}⊆ℂ×ℝ×Bw(H)I.\mathcal S=\{(y,r,s_{y,r}):(y,r)\in\mathcal T\} \subseteq\mathbb C\times\mathbb R\times B_w(H)^I.(5)✦

A unit circle trace bb at xx is a trace vector satisfying (6); WxW_x denotes the set of these traces: b∈Wx⇔(x,1,b)∈𝒮¯.b\in W_x\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad (x,1,b)\in\overline{\mathcal S}.(6) The closure in (6) uses the usual topologies on ℂ\mathbb C and ℝ\mathbb R and the product weak topology on Bw(H)IB_w(H)^I.

For b∈Wxb\in W_x, the positive set Ei(b)E_i(b) of the component bib_i is the subset of the angle circle given in (7), using the chosen representative of bib_i: Ei(b)={t∈𝕋:bi(t)>0}.E_i(b)=\{t\in\mathbb T:b_i(t)>0\}.(7)✦ For each color ii, choose a countable family 𝒢x,i⊆Wx\mathcal G_{x,i}\subseteq W_x such that every Ei(b)E_i(b), with b∈Wxb\in W_x, is contained modulo a μ\mu-null set in ⋃a∈𝒢x,iEi(a)\bigcup_{a\in\mathcal G_{x,i}}E_i(a).✦ The essential angular support Dx,iD_{x,i} at center xx for color ii is the subset of the angle circle 𝕋\mathbb T given in (8): Dx,i=⋃b∈𝒢x,iEi(b).D_{x,i}=\bigcup_{b\in\mathcal G_{x,i}}E_i(b).(8)✦ The angular palette Px(e(t))P_x(e(t)) at center xx and direction e(t)e(t) is the finite subset of the color labels given in (9): Px(e(t))={i∈I:t∈Dx,i}.P_x(e(t))=\{i\in I:t\in D_{x,i}\}.(9)✦ The traces in 𝒢x,i\mathcal G_{x,i} are the countable palette generators at xx for color ii.

A unit circle trace b∈Wxb\in W_x at xx is realized by a sequence of typical circle samples (yn,rn)∈𝒯(y_n,r_n)\in\mathcal T with centers yn→xy_n\to x and radii rn→1r_n\to1; their angular indicators satisfy (10) for every color i∈Ii\in I and every real integrable angular test function vv: limn→∞∫𝕋syn,rn,i(t)v(t)dμ(t)=∫𝕋bi(t)v(t)dμ(t).\lim_{n\to\infty}\int_{\mathbb T}s_{y_n,r_n,i}(t)v(t)\,d\mu(t) =\int_{\mathbb T}b_i(t)v(t)\,d\mu(t).(10)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for five colors, WxW_x consists of the weak-star limits of the five angular class indicators on typical circles with centers yn→xy_n\to x and radii rn→1r_n\to1, allowing constant sequences, Dx,iD_{x,i} is the essential union of the sets {t:bi(t)>0}\{t:b_i(t)>0\} over b∈Wxb\in W_x, and Px(e(t))={i:t∈Dx,i}P_x(e(t))=\{i:t\in D_{x,i}\} modulo angular null sets.

What Is Checked

The definitions and the realization statement are over a Borel measurable coloring c:ℂ→Ic:\mathbb C\to I, with angular samples measured by μ\mu and traces in the product of weak L2L^2 unit balls.

For every center y∈ℂy\in\mathbb C, radius r∈ℝr\in\mathbb R, and color label i∈Ii\in I, the angular color indicator sy,r,is_{y,r,i} is square-integrable with respect to μ\mu✦, and its L2L^2 norm is at most 11.✦