OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §11. Infinite-volume spectral type

Proposition 11.4: For fixed positive disorder, with pure-point type and spectral closure under a complete orthonormal eigenbasis

The almost-sure spectral interval and eigenvalue closure.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Pure-point type concerns the density of the span of eigenvectors, rather than whether every spectral point is an eigenvalue.

The square lattice is ℤ2=ℤ×ℤ\mathbb Z^2=\mathbb Z\times\mathbb Z, and ℋ=ℓ2(ℤ2;ℂ)\mathcal H=\ell^2(\mathbb Z^2;\mathbb C) is the space of square-summable complex functions on this lattice. A potential configuration vv is a real-valued function on ℤ2\mathbb Z^2.✦ For h≥0h\ge0 and |vx|≤h|v_x|\le h at every site, the Anderson operator HvH_v is the bounded complex-linear operator in (1); Δ\Delta is the nearest-neighbor hopping operator and VvV_v is multiplication by the potential. Hv=Δ+Vv,(Vvu)x=vxux,(Hvu)x=∑y:∥y−x∥1=1uy+vxux.\begin{aligned} H_v&=\Delta+V_v, & (V_vu)_x&=v_xu_x,\\ (H_vu)_x&=\sum_{y:\,\|y-x\|_1=1}u_y+v_xu_x. \end{aligned}(1)

For h>0h>0, let νh\nu_h be Lebesgue measure conditioned on [−h,h][-h,h]. The uniform product disorder law ℙh\mathbb P_h on configurations is defined by (2); ℒℙh\mathcal L_{\mathbb P_h} denotes distribution under this law. The interval Ih⊂ℂI_h\subset\mathbb C in (3) lies on the real axis. ℙh=⨂x∈ℤ2νh.\mathbb P_h=\bigotimes_{x\in\mathbb Z^2}\nu_h.(2) Ih=[−4−h,4+h]={z∈ℂ:Im⁡z=0,−4−h≤Re⁡z≤4+h}.I_h=[-4-h,4+h] =\{z\in\mathbb C:\operatorname{Im}z=0,\ -4-h\le\operatorname{Re}z\le4+h\}.(3)

For n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, the square patch PnP_n, its lattice embedding ιn\iota_n and the lattice square QnQ_n are given in (4). The disjoint trial box embedding Tn,kT_{n,k}, for k∈ℕk\in\mathbb N, is given in (5). Pn={0,…,n}2⊂ℕ2,ιn(p)=(p1,p2)∈ℤ2,Qn=ιn(Pn).P_n=\{0,\ldots,n\}^2\subset\mathbb N^2,\qquad \iota_n(p)=(p_1,p_2)\in\mathbb Z^2,\qquad Q_n=\iota_n(P_n).(4) Tn,k(p)=ιn(p)+(k(n+1),0).T_{n,k}(p)=\iota_n(p)+(k(n+1),0).(5) A configuration vv has almost constant boxes at disorder hh if, for every w∈(−h,h)w\in(-h,h), every real ε>0\varepsilon>0 and every n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, there is a translation t∈ℤ2t\in\mathbb Z^2 satisfying (6). |vιn(p)+t−w|<ε(p∈Pn).|v_{\iota_n(p)+t}-w|<\varepsilon\qquad(p\in P_n).(6)✦

The plane wave ψq\psi_q for q∈ℂq\in\mathbb C is the lattice function in (7). The unnormalized cut-off fq,n∈ℋf_{q,n}\in\mathcal H of the plane wave ψq\psi_q is the lattice function supported on QnQ_n and defined in (7); the free energy E(q)E(q) is the scalar defined there. ψq(x)=qx1+x2,fq,n(x)=𝟏Qn(x)ψq(x),E(q)=2(q+q−1).\psi_q(x)=q^{x_1+x_2},\qquad f_{q,n}(x)=\mathbf 1_{Q_n}(x)\psi_q(x),\qquad E(q)=2(q+q^{-1}).(7)

The eigenvalue set σp(H)⊂ℂ\sigma_p(H)\subset\mathbb C of a bounded complex-linear operator HH on ℋ\mathcal H is defined by (8). A bounded complex-linear operator HH on ℋ\mathcal H has pure-point type when the complex span of its eigenvectors is dense in ℋ\mathcal H, as in (9). σp(H)={z∈ℂ:∃u∈ℋ\{0},Hu=zu}.\sigma_p(H)=\{z\in\mathbb C:\exists u\in\mathcal H\setminus\{0\},\ Hu=zu\}.(8)✦ span⁡ℂ{u∈ℋ\{0}:∃z∈ℂ,Hu=zu}¯=ℋ.\overline{\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb C} \{u\in\mathcal H\setminus\{0\}:\exists z\in\mathbb C,\ Hu=zu\}} =\mathcal H.(9)✦ A complete orthonormal eigenbasis (bk)k∈ℕ(b_k)_{k\in\mathbb N} for HH on ℋ\mathcal H is an orthonormal Hilbert basis of ℋ\mathcal H with real eigenvalues λk\lambda_k satisfying (10). Hbk=λkbk(k∈ℕ),λk∈ℝ.Hb_k=\lambda_kb_k\qquad(k\in\mathbb N),\qquad\lambda_k\in\mathbb R.(10)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. For h≥0h\ge0 and |vx|≤h|v_x|\le h at every site, the spectrum σ(Hv)\sigma(H_v) satisfies (11). σ(Hv)⊆Ih.\sigma(H_v)\subseteq I_h.(11)✦

For |q|=1|q|=1 and n≥1n\ge1, the free residual satisfies (12). ∥Δfq,n−E(q)fq,n∥2≤512(n+1).\|\Delta f_{q,n}-E(q)f_{q,n}\|^2\le512(n+1).(12)✦ For |q|=1|q|=1 and every δ>0\delta>0, there exists n≥1n\ge1 satisfying (13). ∥Δfq,n−E(q)fq,n∥≤δ∥fq,n∥.\|\Delta f_{q,n}-E(q)f_{q,n}\|\le\delta\|f_{q,n}\|.(13)✦

For a disorder bound h≥0h\ge0 and a potential vv satisfying |vx|≤h|v_x|\le h at every site, take a complex phase qq satisfying |q|=1|q|=1, a square size n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, a constant potential w∈ℝw\in\mathbb R and an error bound ε≥0\varepsilon\ge0. If |vx−w|≤ε|v_x-w|\le\varepsilon on QnQ_n, then (14) holds. ∥Vvfq,n−wfq,n∥≤ε(n+1).\|V_vf_{q,n}-wf_{q,n}\|\le\varepsilon(n+1).(14)✦ Under the same bounds on h,v,qh,v,q, let n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, w∈ℝw\in\mathbb R, δ>0\delta>0 and t∈ℤ2t\in\mathbb Z^2. Suppose ∥Δfq,n−E(q)fq,n∥≤δ∥fq,n∥\|\Delta f_{q,n}-E(q)f_{q,n}\|\le\delta\|f_{q,n}\| and |vx+t−w|≤δ|v_{x+t}-w|\le\delta for every x∈Qnx\in Q_n. There exists u∈ℋ\{0}u\in\mathcal H\setminus\{0\} satisfying (15). ∥Hvu−(E(q)+w)u∥≤2δ∥u∥.\|H_vu-(E(q)+w)u\|\le2\delta\|u\|.(15)✦

Let HH be bounded and complex-linear on ℋ\mathcal H, and let z∈ℂz\in\mathbb C. If, for every ε>0\varepsilon>0, there is u≠0u\ne0 with ∥Hu−zu∥≤ε∥u∥\|Hu-zu\|\le\varepsilon\|u\|, then (16) holds. z∈σ(H).z\in\sigma(H).(16)✦

Let μ\mu be a probability measure on a measurable space XX, and let s⊆Xs\subseteq X be measurable with μ(s)>0\mu(s)>0. Independent identically distributed samples from μ\mu satisfy (17). μ⊗ℕ({ω∈Xℕ:∃k∈ℕ,ωk∈s})=1.\mu^{\otimes\mathbb N} \bigl(\{\omega\in X^{\mathbb N}:\exists k\in\mathbb N,\ \omega_k\in s\}\bigr)=1.(17)✦ For each fixed h>0h>0 and n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, the trial values have the law (18). ℒℙh(((vTn,k(p))p∈Pn)k∈ℕ)=(νh⊗Pn)⊗ℕ.\mathcal L_{\mathbb P_h} \left(\bigl((v_{T_{n,k}(p)})_{p\in P_n}\bigr)_{k\in\mathbb N}\right) =\left(\nu_h^{\otimes P_n}\right)^{\otimes\mathbb N}.(18)✦ For w∈(−h,h)w\in(-h,h) and ε>0\varepsilon>0, the interval mass satisfies (19). νh((w−ε,w+ε))>0.\nu_h\bigl((w-\varepsilon,w+\varepsilon)\bigr)>0.(19)✦ With h>0h>0, w∈(−h,h)w\in(-h,h), ε>0\varepsilon>0 and n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N fixed, (20) gives the almost-sure occurrence of a trial box. ℙh({v:∃k∈ℕ,|vTn,k(p)−w|<εfor every p∈Pn})=1.\mathbb P_h\!\left(\left\{v:\exists k\in\mathbb N,\ |v_{T_{n,k}(p)}-w|<\varepsilon\ \text{for every }p\in P_n\right\}\right)=1.(20)✦ Almost every configuration at each fixed h>0h>0 has almost constant boxes, as in (21). ℙh({v:v has almost constant boxes at disorder h})=1.\mathbb P_h\bigl(\{v:v\text{ has almost constant boxes at disorder }h\}\bigr)=1.(21)✦

Let h≥0h\ge0, let |vx|≤h|v_x|\le h at every site, and suppose vv has almost constant boxes at disorder hh. For w∈(−h,h)w\in(-h,h) and |q|=1|q|=1, (22) holds. E(q)+w∈σ(Hv).E(q)+w\in\sigma(H_v).(22)✦ If h>0h>0 under these assumptions, every real e∈(−4−h,4+h)e\in(-4-h,4+h) satisfies (23), and the spectrum satisfies (24). e∈σ(Hv).e\in\sigma(H_v).(23)✦ σ(Hv)=Ih.\sigma(H_v)=I_h.(24)✦ For each fixed h>0h>0, almost every vv under ℙh\mathbb P_h admits a self-adjoint Anderson operator HvH_v satisfying (25). σ(Hv)=Ih.\sigma(H_v)=I_h.(25)✦

A bounded complex-linear operator HH on ℋ\mathcal H with a complete orthonormal eigenbasis satisfies (26). H has pure-point type.H\text{ has pure-point type}.(26)✦ For every bounded complex-linear operator HH on ℋ\mathcal H, the eigenvalue inclusions are (27) and (28). σp(H)⊆σ(H).\sigma_p(H)\subseteq\sigma(H).(27)✦ σp(H)¯⊆σ(H).\overline{\sigma_p(H)}\subseteq\sigma(H).(28)✦ For such an HH with a complete orthonormal eigenbasis, the equality is (29). σ(H)=σp(H)¯.\sigma(H)=\overline{\sigma_p(H)}.(29)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for each fixed h>0h>0, almost surely σ(Hv)=[−4−h,4+h]\sigma(H_v)=[-4-h,4+h], and, under Proposition 11.3, the eigenvalues are dense in this interval.

What Is Checked

The statements concern bounded complex-linear operators on complex ℓ2(ℤ2)\ell^2(\mathbb Z^2), bounded real potentials and the uniform product law; the eigenbasis conclusions assume a complete orthonormal eigenbasis.

For a∈ℤ2a\in\mathbb Z^2, the lattice translation τa:x↦x+a\tau_a:x\mapsto x+a is a bijection of ℤ2\mathbb Z^2 with inverse x↦x−ax\mapsto x-a.✦ For any lattice bijection ee, the reindexing operator ReR_e on ℋ\mathcal H is the complex-linear isometry defined in (30). (Reu)x=ue(x),∥Reu∥=∥u∥(u∈ℋ).(R_eu)_x=u_{e(x)},\qquad \|R_eu\|=\|u\|\qquad(u\in\mathcal H).(30)✦

The unnormalized cut-off waves have the norm in (31) for |q|=1|q|=1 and n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N. ∥fq,n∥=n+1.\|f_{q,n}\|=n+1.(31)