OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §7. Bounded scale and a limiting fiber map · §7

Lemma 7.1 [Nonatomic Möbius obstruction]: A Möbius map whose pole, of law β1\beta_1, is independent of (a′,b′)(a',b') cannot carry β1\beta_1 to β2\beta_2 almost surely, under separation and support conditions

An obstruction to pushing nonatomic laws through random Möbius maps.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A fiber system on a finite vertex set VV consists of fibers ee, each with a source xe∈Vx_e\in V and a target set Fe⊆VF_e\subseteq V not containing xex_e. Take one fiber ee, and read each point yy through its two coordinates Z1(y)Z_1(y) and Z2(y)Z_2(y). Along the fiber the product t(xe,y)=(Z1(y)−Z1(xe))(Z2(y)−Z2(xe))t(x_e,y) = (Z_1(y)-Z_1(x_e))(Z_2(y)-Z_2(x_e)) keeps one nonzero value. If the source has coordinates (a,b)(a,b) and one target has coordinates (a′,b′)(a',b'), every target with coordinates (z,w)(z,w) satisfies (z−a)(w−b)=(a′−a)(b′−b)(z-a)(w-b) = (a'-a)(b'-b).

Lemma 7.1 asks whether such a relation can hold in law. Take probability measures β1\beta_1 and β2\beta_2 on ℂ\mathbb{C} with no atoms (made precise below), a random pole aa of law β1\beta_1, a random value bb, and a random reference point (a′,b′)(a',b') independent of aa. Can the Möbius map defined below from aa, bb and (a′,b′)(a',b') carry β1\beta_1 onto one and the same measure β2\beta_2 almost surely?

Möbius Maps and the Riemann Sphere

A probability measure β\beta on ℂ\mathbb{C} is nonatomic if β({z})=0\beta(\{z\}) = 0 for every z∈ℂz\in\mathbb{C}. The support supp⁡β\operatorname{supp}\beta of a measure β\beta on ℂ\mathbb{C} is the set of points every neighborhood of which has positive measure under β\beta. The image of a measure β\beta on a space XX under a measurable map f:X→Yf\colon X\to Y is the measure f*βf_*\beta on YY given by f*β(A)=β(f−1(A))f_*\beta(A) = \beta(f^{-1}(A)).

For a,b,a′,b′∈ℂa,b,a',b'\in\mathbb{C}, the Möbius map ma,b,a′,b′m_{a,b,a',b'} with pole aa is the map from ℂ\mathbb{C} to ℂ\mathbb{C} that sends aa to bb and is given for z≠az\neq a by ma,b,a′,b′(z)=b+(a′−a)(b′−b)z−a(z≠a).m_{a,b,a',b'}(z) = b + \frac{(a'-a)(b'-b)}{z-a} \qquad (z\neq a).(1)✦

The Riemann sphere ℂˆ=ℂ∪{∞}\hat{\mathbb{C}} = \mathbb{C}\cup\{\infty\} is the one-point compactification of ℂ\mathbb{C}, taken with its Borel σ\sigma-algebra, and ι:ℂ→ℂˆ\iota\colon\mathbb{C}\to\hat{\mathbb{C}} is the inclusion, so that ι*β\iota_*\beta is a measure β\beta on ℂ\mathbb{C} seen on the sphere. For a,b,a′,b′∈ℂa,b,a',b'\in\mathbb{C}, the sphere Möbius map mˆa,b,a′,b′\hat m_{a,b,a',b'} is the map of ℂˆ\hat{\mathbb{C}} to itself given by mˆa,b,a′,b′(z)={bif z=∞,∞if z=a,ma,b,a′,b′(z)otherwise.\hat m_{a,b,a',b'}(z) = \begin{cases} b & \text{if } z = \infty,\\ \infty & \text{if } z = a,\\ m_{a,b,a',b'}(z) & \text{otherwise.} \end{cases}(2)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let β1\beta_1 and β2\beta_2 be nonatomic probability measures on ℂ\mathbb{C}, and consider the probability measures QQ on ℂ4\mathbb{C}^4, with coordinates (a,b,a′,b′)(a,b,a',b'), under which aa has law β1\beta_1 and is independent of the pair (a′,b′)(a',b'), while almost surely a′∈supp⁡β1a'\in\operatorname{supp}\beta_1 and b≠b′b\neq b'.

  1. No such QQ has, almost surely, a≠a′a\neq a', b′∈supp⁡β2b'\in\operatorname{supp}\beta_2 and (mˆa,b,a′,b′)*ι*β1=ι*β2.(\hat m_{a,b,a',b'})_*\,\iota_*\beta_1 = \iota_*\beta_2.(3)✦

  2. No such QQ has, almost surely, (ma,b,a′,b′)*β1=β2.(m_{a,b,a',b'})_*\,\beta_1 = \beta_2.(4)✦

What Is Checked

The claims (3) and (4) are stated over two nonatomic probability measures on ℂ\mathbb{C} and a probability measure on ℂ4\mathbb{C}^4, the first through the sphere Möbius map (2) on the Riemann sphere with its Borel σ\sigma-algebra, the second through the Möbius map (1) on ℂ\mathbb{C}.