The Setting
A configuration is a finite set of points in the Euclidean plane , with . The distance class of a point about a point is the set of points of other than at distance from ✦, and the pinned multiplicity is its size✦. An ordered pair of distinct points of is rich at exponent when .✦ The rich pair fraction of at exponent is the number of rich pairs divided by ✦, and the extremal fraction is the supremum of the rich pair fraction over configurations of points when , and when ✦. The upper limit of the extremal fraction and the critical exponent are (1) The weak pinned distances statement asserts that as for every exponent .✦
Proposition 2.2 supposes that this statement fails. It then finds arbitrarily large subsets of configurations on which the distance classes of size at least , read as directed edges from the point about which a class is taken to its points in , form graphs of edge density close to and of large minimum degree, each with a model in a number field, that is, injective coordinates into the field for which the product is constant on each such distance class.
For maps from a set into a field, write .
Fiber Systems
A fiber system on a finite vertex set is a finite family of fibers , each with a source and a target set not containing , such that distinct fibers with the same source have disjoint target sets.✦ The edge set of a fiber system is the set of pairs with and .✦ Each vertex has a total degree , the number of edges leaving plus the number entering it. The in-neighborhood of a vertex is the set of vertices with .✦
On a finite set , the uniform law gives mass to each point of ✦, and the uniform pair law gives mass to each ordered pair of distinct points of ✦. For a fiber system on , is the uniform law on and is the uniform pair law on , and is the -mass of for ; is the uniform law on and the uniform law on . The edge law is the uniform law on , with on edges and elsewhere.✦ A fiber has weight ✦, and a vertex has incoming weight ✦.
The heavy count of a subset at threshold is the sum of over the fibers with source in that put at least the proportion of their targets in : (2)✦
A fiber is active at level in a subset when its source lies in and more than of its targets lie in .✦ The edges at level in are the pairs with active and ✦; they form the set ✦, and is the number of these edges leaving plus the number entering ✦. The restriction of the system to at level is the fiber system on whose fibers are the active fibers, each with source and target set .✦
Prepared Graphs and Cores
For reals , a prepared graph with parameters is a fiber system on a vertex set with in which every fiber has more than targets, (3) and every subset has (4)✦
The distance class system of a configuration at exponent is the fiber system on whose fibers, the large distance classes, are the pairs with for some rich pair ; the fiber has source and target set the points of at distance from .✦ The core graph of a subset of a configuration of points is the restriction of to at the cutoff level .✦
For subsets , a level and a threshold , a fiber of is heavy in when it is active at level in and , and the heavy count is the sum of over the heavy fibers with source in ✦; below, is the cutoff level .
A prepared core of with parameters is a subset of points with and such that, at the cutoff level and with edges and degrees taken in , (5)✦ and every satisfies (4) with , and in place of , and .
The Claim
Theorem 1 (Proposition 2.2).
Suppose there is an exponent such that does not tend to . Then there are exponents with and, for each , a configuration and a subset with (6)✦ These can be chosen so that also, for each , there are a number field inside the algebraic closure of , an element with , injective maps and a nonzero for each fiber of , with (7)✦
Under the hypothesis of (a), let be reals with , , and continuous at . Then for every and every there are a configuration and a subset with (8)✦ and there are a configuration and a subset with (9)✦
Let be a configuration of points, let be reals and , and let be an integer with and . Suppose , , the rich pair fraction of at exponent is at least , and every integer with has and . Then there is a subset of points with, in at level , (10)✦
Let a fiber system on , with , be a prepared graph with parameters , where . Then (11)✦ If also , then every vertex and every subset satisfy (12)✦ (13)✦ and, when , (14)✦
Let a fiber system on with satisfy pointwise for a real . Then every vertex satisfies (15)✦ (16)✦ Every fiber system on and every real satisfy (17)✦
Let be a configuration, a real and a subset such that every fiber of has a target. Then there are a number field , an element with , injective maps and a nonzero for each fiber of such that, for all , (18)✦
Let be a finite family of distinct points of the plane. Then there are a number field , an element with and injective maps such that, for all , (19)✦
Let be a set and a finite set of polynomials with rational coefficients in finitely many variables, and suppose some complex point has for and for . Then there are a number field and a point with coordinates in such that (20)✦
In the paper, the result reads: if Theorem 1.1, the weak pinned distances statement, fails, there are finite sets of real algebraic points, with , and nonempty directed graphs on with densities and every fiber of size such that, for a fixed , , and pointwise (2.2), (2.3), and, with , every with and has if and if (2.4), all errors uniform, where and are the marginals of and is the expectation over fibers.
The paper’s bounds (2.2) to (2.4) appear as parts (d) and (e).
What Is Checked
The claim is stated over configurations in the Euclidean plane , the extremal fraction of rich ordered pairs with its upper limit and the critical exponent , fiber systems with their edge law, uniform laws and heavy counts, the distance class system with its core graphs, prepared graphs and prepared cores, and number fields inside .
Beyond the claim, the library shows that the large distance classes of a configuration satisfy the two conditions of a fiber system, and that the restriction of a fiber system to a subset at a level is again a fiber system.