The Setting
Take a set of points in the plane and pin one of them, , as in the Erdős pinned distance problem. The other points of lie on circles about , one circle for each distance from , and few distances from means crowded circles. For a real exponent , Lemma 2.1 concerns the largest share of ordered pairs for which the circle about through holds at least points, taken over all sets of points: at a fixed exponent this share is eventually at most its upper limit as plus any margin, and the question is how far that bound survives when the exponent moves.
Rich Pairs and Their Maximal Fraction
The Euclidean plane is the two-dimensional real vector space of pairs of real coordinates, with the Euclidean norm and the distance it gives.✦
For a finite set in the plane and points , of the plane, the pinned distance multiplicity is the number of points of at equal distance, the points of other than whose distance to equals that of : (1)✦
Let be a finite set of points in the plane and a real number. The rich ordered pairs of at exponent are the pairs of distinct points of with : (2) The rich pair fraction of a finite set of points at exponent is , the share of rich pairs among the ordered pairs of distinct points of .✦
Given a natural number and a real number , the maximal rich pair fraction is the supremum of the rich pair fractions at exponent of the sets of points in the plane when , and when : (3)✦
The upper limit at a real exponent is the limit superior of the maximal rich pair fractions as : (4)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a real number at which is continuous, and let .
(a) If is a sequence of real numbers converging to and is a sequence of natural numbers tending to infinity, then there is an such that (5)✦
(b) If is a real number with , then there are a real number with and a natural number such that (6)✦
In the paper, the result reads: if and , then as , where and .
What Is Checked
The bounds (5) and (6) are stated over the maximal rich pair fraction of (3), built from the pinned distance multiplicity (1) and the rich ordered pairs (2) of finite sets in the Euclidean plane, and over its upper limit of (4), assumed continuous at .