OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Centrality and rational stability

Lemma 5.8: Surjective homomorphisms with locally finite kernel induce isomorphisms on rational group homology and on homology with modules restricted from the target

Relative coinvariants preserve homology for locally finite normal subgroups.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Take a group GG and a normal subgroup NN of GG, with quotient homomorphism q:G→G/Nq : G \to G/N, or more generally a surjective group homomorphism f:G→Hf : G \to H with kernel ker⁡f\ker f. The question is when quotienting by NN or ker⁡f\ker f respects homology over ℚ\mathbb{Q}: when does factoring out the action of NN on a ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-module preserve homology of complexes, and when does qq or ff induce isomorphisms on group homology over ℚ\mathbb{Q}?

Definitions

A locally finite group KK is a group in which every finite subset SS of KK is contained in a finite subgroup LL of KK.✦

Given a group GG and a normal subgroup NN of GG, the relative coinvariants functor (−)N(-)_N from the category of left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-modules to the category of left ℚ[G/N]\mathbb{Q}[G/N]-modules sends each left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-module MM to its module of NN-coinvariants MN=M/span⁡ℚ{nm−m:n∈N,m∈M}M_N = M / \operatorname{span}_{\mathbb{Q}}\{nm - m : n \in N,\, m \in M\} with the induced G/NG/N-action (gN)⋅[m]=[gm](gN) \cdot [m] = [gm], where [m][m] is the class of m∈Mm \in M in MNM_N, and sends each ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-module homomorphism to the induced ℚ[G/N]\mathbb{Q}[G/N]-module homomorphism.✦

For a group homomorphism f:G→Hf : G \to H and a left ℚ[H]\mathbb{Q}[H]-module AA, the restriction Res⁡fA\operatorname{Res}_f A is the left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-module on the underlying ℚ\mathbb{Q}-vector space of AA with GG-action g⋅a=f(g)⋅ag \cdot a = f(g) \cdot a for g∈Gg \in G and a∈Aa \in A.

For a group KK, a left ℚ[K]\mathbb{Q}[K]-module MM, and an integer n≥0n \ge 0, write Hn(K;M)H_n(K; M) for the group homology of KK in degree nn with coefficients in MM, and write Hn(K;ℚ)H_n(K; \mathbb{Q}) when M=ℚM = \mathbb{Q} carries the trivial KK-action. For a group homomorphism f:G→Hf : G \to H, a left ℚ[H]\mathbb{Q}[H]-module AA, and an integer n≥0n \ge 0, the induced map Hn(f,A):Hn(G;Res⁡fA)→Hn(H;A)H_n(f, A) : H_n(G; \operatorname{Res}_f A) \to H_n(H; A) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear map in degree nn induced by ff and the identity map on AA. With trivial coefficients ℚ\mathbb{Q}, the induced map on rational homology Hn(f):Hn(G;ℚ)→Hn(H;ℚ)H_n(f) : H_n(G; \mathbb{Q}) \to H_n(H; \mathbb{Q}) is the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-linear map in degree n≥0n \ge 0 induced by ff on group homology with coefficients in the respective trivial ℚ\mathbb{Q}-modules.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let GG be a group, let NN be a locally finite normal subgroup of GG, and let q:G→G/Nq : G \to G/N be the quotient homomorphism. For every complex C•C_\bullet of left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-modules with differential dd and homology Hi(C•)=ker⁡di/im⁡di+1H_i(C_\bullet) = \ker d_i / \operatorname{im} d_{i+1} in degree ii, the relative coinvariants functor (−)N(-)_N satisfies the canonical isomorphism Hi((C•)N)≅(Hi(C•))N.H_i\bigl((C_\bullet)_N\bigr) \cong \bigl(H_i(C_\bullet)\bigr)_N.(1)✦ Given a left ℚ[G/N]\mathbb{Q}[G/N]-module AA and an integer n≥0n \ge 0, there is an isomorphism of ℚ\mathbb{Q}-vector spaces Hn(G;Res⁡qA)≅Hn(G/N;A),H_n(G; \operatorname{Res}_q A) \cong H_n(G/N; A),(2)✦ and the induced map satisfies Hn(q,A):Hn(G;Res⁡qA)→∼Hn(G/N;A).H_n(q, A) : H_n(G; \operatorname{Res}_q A) \xrightarrow{\;\sim\;} H_n(G/N; A).(3)✦ More generally, for any surjective group homomorphism f:G→Hf : G \to H with locally finite kernel ker⁡f\ker f, any left ℚ[H]\mathbb{Q}[H]-module AA, and any integer n≥0n \ge 0, Hn(f,A):Hn(G;Res⁡fA)→∼Hn(H;A),H_n(f, A) : H_n(G; \operatorname{Res}_f A) \xrightarrow{\;\sim\;} H_n(H; A),(4)✦ and for trivial coefficients ℚ\mathbb{Q}, Hn(f):Hn(G;ℚ)→∼Hn(H;ℚ).H_n(f) : H_n(G; \mathbb{Q}) \xrightarrow{\;\sim\;} H_n(H; \mathbb{Q}).(5)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a locally finite normal subgroup NN of a group GG and a left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-module MM, there are natural isomorphisms Hn(G;M)≅Hn(G/N;MN)H_n(G; M) \cong H_n(G/N; M_N), where MNM_N denotes the module of NN-coinvariants. Here (1) applies to arbitrary left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-modules through (−)N(-)_N, while (2), (3), (4), and (5) apply to modules restricted from G/NG/N or from a surjective image HH and to trivial ℚ\mathbb{Q}-coefficients.

What Is Checked

The claims above are stated over groups GG and HH, a locally finite normal subgroup NN of GG with quotient map q:G→G/Nq : G \to G/N, and a surjective homomorphism f:G→Hf : G \to H with locally finite kernel ker⁡f\ker f. They concern left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-modules, left modules AA over ℚ[G/N]\mathbb{Q}[G/N] or ℚ[H]\mathbb{Q}[H], the relative coinvariants functor (−)N(-)_N, restriction along qq and ff, and group homology in degree n≥0n \ge 0 with the induced maps Hn(q,A)H_n(q, A), Hn(f,A)H_n(f, A), and Hn(f)H_n(f) for trivial coefficients ℚ\mathbb{Q}.

Beyond these claims, the library establishes that the relative coinvariants functor (−)N(-)_N is left adjoint to restriction Res⁡q\operatorname{Res}_q, with unit M→Res⁡q(MN)M \to \operatorname{Res}_q(M_N) and counit (Res⁡qA)N→A(\operatorname{Res}_q A)_N \to A for a left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-module MM and a left ℚ[G/N]\mathbb{Q}[G/N]-module AA.✦ It identifies (−)N(-)_N with the induction functor Ind⁡q\operatorname{Ind}_q along qq✦ and gives an isomorphism ℚN≅ℚ\mathbb{Q}_N \cong \mathbb{Q} between the NN-coinvariants of the trivial ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-module ℚ\mathbb{Q} and the trivial ℚ[G/N]\mathbb{Q}[G/N]-module ℚ\mathbb{Q}.✦ For any group homomorphism f:G→Hf : G \to H, a left ℚ[H]\mathbb{Q}[H]-module AA, and a left ℚ[G]\mathbb{Q}[G]-module MM, it establishes a projection isomorphism natural in MM identifying the diagonal-action coinvariants (Res⁡fA⊗ℚM)G(\operatorname{Res}_f A \otimes_{\mathbb{Q}} M)_G with (A⊗ℚInd⁡fM)H(A \otimes_{\mathbb{Q}} \operatorname{Ind}_f M)_H✦, and for a left ℚ[G/N]\mathbb{Q}[G/N]-module BB it likewise identifies (Res⁡qB⊗ℚM)G(\operatorname{Res}_q B \otimes_{\mathbb{Q}} M)_G with (B⊗ℚMN)G/N(B \otimes_{\mathbb{Q}} M_N)_{G/N}.✦ When NN is locally finite, it also constructs a projective resolution of the trivial ℚ[G/N]\mathbb{Q}[G/N]-module ℚ\mathbb{Q}.✦