OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 Β· Β§5. Centrality and rational stability

Lemma 5.7: Central pushouts, unique Steinberg lifts over elementary matrix groups, cocycle models, and bar-cocycle correspondences under second rational homology isomorphisms

Rational central extensions and Steinberg kernel characters.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR and a natural number nn, given a central extension of the elementary matrix group of rank nn over RR by the additive group β„š\mathbb{Q} of rational numbers, one seeks to lift the Steinberg group uniquely into the extension to obtain a rational character on its kernel, and conversely to build a central extension from a homomorphism on a central kernel by pushout.

For an arbitrary group GG, one also models central extensions of GG by β„š\mathbb{Q} through rational 2-cocycles in the bar complex and compares cocycles and coboundaries along homomorphisms inducing isomorphisms on second rational homology.

Steinberg Groups and Elementary Matrices

In any group GG, the commutator of elements x,y∈Gx, y \in G is [x,y]=xyxβˆ’1yβˆ’1[x, y] = x y x^{-1} y^{-1}.✦ For a natural number nn, a root of rank nn is a pair p=(i,j)p = (i, j) of distinct indices i,j∈{1,…,n}i, j \in \{1, \dots, n\}.✦ Over an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR, a Steinberg generator of rank nn is a pair (p,a)(p, a) consisting of a root pp of rank nn and an element a∈Ra \in R.✦ In the free group on these pairs, writing xp(a)x_p(a) for the free generator (p,a)(p, a), the Steinberg relations in rank nn over RR consist of three families of relators for a,b∈Ra, b \in R: the additivity relators xp(a+b)(xp(a)xp(b))βˆ’1x_p(a + b)(x_p(a)x_p(b))^{-1} for each root pp; the commutation relators [xp(a),xq(b)][x_p(a), x_q(b)] for roots p=(i,j)p = (i, j) and q=(k,β„“)q = (k, \ell) with jβ‰ kj \neq k and iβ‰ β„“i \neq \ell; and the commutator-product relators [xij(a),xjk(b)]xik(ab)βˆ’1[x_{ij}(a), x_{jk}(b)] x_{ik}(ab)^{-1} for pairwise distinct indices i,j,ki, j, k.✦ For a natural number nn and an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR, the Steinberg group St⁡n(R)\operatorname{St}_n(R) is the group presented by the Steinberg generators of rank nn and the Steinberg relations in rank nn over RR, and xp(a)x_p(a) (also written xij(a)x_{ij}(a) when p=(i,j)p = (i, j)) denotes the resulting generator in St⁡n(R)\operatorname{St}_n(R).✦

By the universal property of St⁡n(R)\operatorname{St}_n(R), for any group GG, a map assigning an element f(p,a)∈Gf(p, a) \in G to each root pp of rank nn and a∈Ra \in R induces a homomorphism St⁡n(R)β†’G\operatorname{St}_n(R) \to G sending xp(a)x_p(a) to f(p,a)f(p, a) whenever ff preserves the additivity, commutation, and commutator-product Steinberg relations.✦

For an index set Ξ›\Lambda, distinct indices i,jβˆˆΞ›i, j \in \Lambda, and a∈Ra \in R, the elementary matrix eij(a)=I+aEije_{ij}(a) = I + a E_{ij} is the invertible Λ×Λ\Lambda \times \Lambda matrix over RR differing from the identity matrix II by aa in entry (i,j)(i, j).✦ The elementary subgroup E⁡(R)\operatorname{E}(R) over Ξ›\Lambda is the subgroup of invertible Λ×Λ\Lambda \times \Lambda matrices over RR generated by all elementary matrices eij(a)e_{ij}(a).✦ For a natural number nn and an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR, the elementary group E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) of rank nn is the elementary subgroup over the index set {1,…,n}\{1, \dots, n\}, and for a root p=(i,j)p = (i, j) of rank nn we write ep(a)=eij(a)e_p(a) = e_{ij}(a) in the group GL⁡n(R)\operatorname{GL}_n(R) of invertible nΓ—nn \times n matrices over RR.

The elementary matrices ep(a)e_p(a) satisfy the additivity, commutation, and commutator-product Steinberg relations in GL⁡n(R)\operatorname{GL}_n(R). By the universal property of St⁡n(R)\operatorname{St}_n(R), sending xp(a)x_p(a) to ep(a)e_p(a) defines a homomorphism St⁡n(R)β†’GL⁡n(R)\operatorname{St}_n(R) \to \operatorname{GL}_n(R) whose image lies in E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R), restricting to the canonical representation Ο€n:St⁡n(R)β†’E⁡n(R)\pi_n : \operatorname{St}_n(R) \to \operatorname{E}_n(R). For a natural number nn and an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR, the Steinberg kernel Jn(R)J_n(R) is the kernel subgroup ker⁡Ο€n≀St⁡n(R)\ker \pi_n \le \operatorname{St}_n(R) of the canonical representation Ο€n:St⁡n(R)β†’E⁡n(R)\pi_n : \operatorname{St}_n(R) \to \operatorname{E}_n(R).

Rational Central Extensions and Pushouts

Write β„š\mathbb{Q} for the additive group of rational numbers.✦ For a group GG, a central extension SS of GG by β„š\mathbb{Q} with total group XX is a short exact sequence 0β†’β„šβ†’ΞΉSX→ρSGβ†’10 \to \mathbb{Q} \xrightarrow{\iota_S} X \xrightarrow{\rho_S} G \to 1 whose image im⁡ΞΉS\operatorname{im} \iota_S lies in the center Z(X)Z(X) of XX.✦ For a central extension SS of GG by β„š\mathbb{Q} with inclusion ΞΉS\iota_S and projection ρS\rho_S, the kernel isomorphism ΞΊS:β„šβ†’βˆΌker⁡ρS\kappa_S : \mathbb{Q} \xrightarrow{\sim} \ker \rho_S of SS is the restriction of the codomain of ΞΉS\iota_S to ker⁡ρS\ker \rho_S, and for any subgroup H≀GH \le G the preimage ρSβˆ’1(H)≀X\rho_S^{-1}(H) \le X with the restricted maps forms a central extension of HH by β„š\mathbb{Q}.✦

When GG is finite, ker⁡ρS\ker \rho_S has finite index [X:ker⁡ρS][X : \ker \rho_S] in XX, and dividing the transfer homomorphism Xβ†’β„šX \to \mathbb{Q} associated with ΞΊSβˆ’1:ker⁡ρSβ†’β„š\kappa_S^{-1} : \ker \rho_S \to \mathbb{Q} by [X:ker⁡ρS][X : \ker \rho_S] gives a transfer retraction Xβ†’β„šX \to \mathbb{Q}.✦ The restriction of ρS\rho_S to the kernel of this retraction is a bijection onto GG, whose inverse is a splitting homomorphism Gβ†’XG \to X right inverse to ρS\rho_S. Applying this splitting to the restriction of SS to any finite subgroup H≀GH \le G gives a splitting homomorphism Hβ†’XH \to X✦, and evaluating this splitting on the finite cyclic subgroup ⟨g⟩\langle g \rangle generated by a torsion element g∈Gg \in G defines the finite-order lift of gg in XX.✦

Given groups PP and GG, a homomorphism p:Pβ†’Gp : P \to G with ker⁡p≀Z(P)\ker p \le Z(P), and a homomorphism Ο†:ker⁡pβ†’β„š\varphi : \ker p \to \mathbb{Q}, the pushout relation subgroup NΟ†={(j,βˆ’Ο†(j)):j∈ker⁡p}≀PΓ—β„šN_\varphi = \{(j, -\varphi(j)) : j \in \ker p\} \le P \times \mathbb{Q} is the image of j↦(j,βˆ’Ο†(j))j \mapsto (j, -\varphi(j)), and the central pushout group is the quotient EΟ†=(PΓ—β„š)/NΟ†E_\varphi = (P \times \mathbb{Q}) / N_\varphi. The pushout inclusion ΞΉΟ†:β„šβ†’EΟ†\iota_\varphi : \mathbb{Q} \to E_\varphi sends qq to the coset (1,q)NΟ†(1, q)N_\varphi✦, and the pushout projection πφ:EΟ†β†’G\pi_\varphi : E_\varphi \to G is induced by (x,q)↦p(x)(x, q) \mapsto p(x).✦

For an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR, every elementary root element ep(a)e_p(a) in E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) (for a root pp of rank nn and a∈Ra \in R) has finite order. Given a central extension SS of E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) by β„š\mathbb{Q} with total group XX, denote by eΜƒp(a)∈X\tilde{e}_p(a) \in X (also written eΜƒij(a)\tilde{e}_{ij}(a) when p=(i,j)p = (i, j)) the finite-order lift of ep(a)e_p(a).✦ For all roots p,qp, q of rank nn and a,b∈Ra, b \in R, the lifts eΜƒp(a)\tilde{e}_p(a) satisfy the additivity, commutation, and commutator-product Steinberg relations in XX.

The Rational Bar Complex and Cocycle Models

For a group GG, equip β„š\mathbb{Q} with the trivial GG-action.✦ The rational bar chain spaces C1(G)C_1(G), C2(G)C_2(G), and C3(G)C_3(G) are the β„š\mathbb{Q}-vector spaces of finitely supported β„š\mathbb{Q}-valued functions on GG, GΓ—GG \times G, and GΓ—GΓ—GG \times G \times G, connected by the bar boundary maps d2G:C2(G)β†’C1(G)d_2^G : C_2(G) \to C_1(G) and d3G:C3(G)β†’C2(G)d_3^G : C_3(G) \to C_2(G). Write Z2(G)βŠ†C2(G)Z_2(G) \subseteq C_2(G) for the subspace of rational 2-cycles, H2(G)H_2(G) for the second rational homology of GG with trivial coefficients β„š\mathbb{Q}, and qG:Z2(G)β†’H2(G)q_G : Z_2(G) \to H_2(G) for the canonical quotient projection. A group homomorphism f:Gβ†’Hf : G \to H into a group HH induces a β„š\mathbb{Q}-linear map f2:C2(G)β†’C2(H)f_2 : C_2(G) \to C_2(H) on 2-chains and an induced map f*:H2(G)β†’H2(H)f_* : H_2(G) \to H_2(H) on second rational homology.

The space of rational 2-cocycles of GG is the β„š\mathbb{Q}-subspace Z2(G)={c∈Hom⁡β„š(C2(G),β„š):c∘d3G=0}Z^2(G) = \{c \in \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathbb{Q}}(C_2(G), \mathbb{Q}) : c \circ d_3^G = 0\}✦, and for c∈Z2(G)c \in Z^2(G) and g,h∈Gg, h \in G the cocycle value c(g,h)βˆˆβ„šc(g, h) \in \mathbb{Q} is the evaluation of cc on the basis 2-chain (g,h)∈C2(G)(g, h) \in C_2(G).✦ The space of rational 2-coboundaries of GG is B2(G)={b∘d2G:b∈Hom⁡β„š(C1(G),β„š)}B^2(G) = \{b \circ d_2^G : b \in \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathbb{Q}}(C_1(G), \mathbb{Q})\}. For a homomorphism f:Gβ†’Hf : G \to H, pullback along ff is the β„š\mathbb{Q}-linear map f*:Z2(H)β†’Z2(G)f^* : Z^2(H) \to Z^2(G) given by f*(c)=c∘f2f^*(c) = c \circ f_2.✦

For any rational 2-cocycle c∈Z2(G)c \in Z^2(G), the cocycle extension E(c)=β„šΓ—GE(c) = \mathbb{Q} \times G with group operation (q1,g1)(q2,g2)=(q1+q2+c(g1,g2),g1g2)(q_1, g_1)(q_2, g_2) = (q_1 + q_2 + c(g_1, g_2), g_1 g_2), inclusion q↦(qβˆ’c(1,1),1)q \mapsto (q - c(1, 1), 1), and projection (q,g)↦g(q, g) \mapsto g is a central extension of GG by β„š\mathbb{Q}.✦

For any central extension SS of GG by β„š\mathbb{Q} with total group XX, choose a set-theoretic section sS:Gβ†’Xs_S : G \to X right inverse to ρS\rho_S.✦ The factor set Ξ±S:GΓ—Gβ†’β„š\alpha_S : G \times G \to \mathbb{Q} of SS is defined by Ξ±S(g,h)=ΞΊSβˆ’1(sS(g)sS(h)sS(gh)βˆ’1)\alpha_S(g, h) = \kappa_S^{-1}(s_S(g)s_S(h)s_S(gh)^{-1})✦, and extending (g,h)↦αS(g,h)(g, h) \mapsto \alpha_S(g, h) by β„š\mathbb{Q}-linearity yields a 2-cochain on C2(G)C_2(G) satisfying the cocycle condition, giving the extension 2-cocycle cS∈Z2(G)c_S \in Z^2(G). The extension homomorphism ΞΌS:E(cS)β†’X\mu_S : E(c_S) \to X is given by ΞΌS(q,g)=ΞΉS(q)sS(g)\mu_S(q, g) = \iota_S(q) s_S(g).✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let PP and GG be groups, let p:Pβ†’Gp : P \to G be a surjective homomorphism with ker⁡p≀Z(P)\ker p \le Z(P), and let Ο†:ker⁡pβ†’β„š\varphi : \ker p \to \mathbb{Q} be a homomorphism. Then the pushout sequenceΒ (1) is a central extension of GG by β„š\mathbb{Q}: 0β†’β„šβ†’ΞΉΟ†Eφ→πφGβ†’1.0 \to \mathbb{Q} \xrightarrow{\;\iota_\varphi\;} E_\varphi \xrightarrow{\;\pi_\varphi\;} G \to 1.(1)✦

Let RR be an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra, let nn be a natural number, and let SS be a central extension of E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) by β„š\mathbb{Q} with total group XX and projection ρS:Xβ†’E⁡n(R)\rho_S : X \to \operatorname{E}_n(R). The finite-order lifts eΜƒp(a)\tilde{e}_p(a) induce a homomorphism Ο€ΜƒS:St⁡n(R)β†’X\tilde{\pi}_S : \operatorname{St}_n(R) \to X sending each generator xp(a)x_p(a) to eΜƒp(a)\tilde{e}_p(a)✦, and any homomorphism f:St⁡n(R)β†’Xf : \operatorname{St}_n(R) \to X satisfying ρS∘f=Ο€n\rho_S \circ f = \pi_n obeysΒ (2): f=Ο€ΜƒS.f = \tilde{\pi}_S.(2)✦ Restricting Ο€ΜƒS\tilde{\pi}_S to Jn(R)J_n(R) gives a homomorphism Ξ»S:Jn(R)β†’ker⁡ρS\lambda_S : J_n(R) \to \ker \rho_S, which yields the rational kernel character Ο‡S:Jn(R)β†’β„š\chi_S : J_n(R) \to \mathbb{Q} inΒ (3): Ο‡S=ΞΊSβˆ’1∘λS.\chi_S = \kappa_S^{-1} \circ \lambda_S.(3)✦

Two central extensions of GG by β„š\mathbb{Q} are equivalent, written E1≃E2E_1 \simeq E_2, when an isomorphism between their total groups commutes with the inclusions and projections; for any central extension SS of GG by β„š\mathbb{Q}, the homomorphism ΞΌS\mu_S defines an equivalenceΒ (4): E(cS)≃S.E(c_S) \simeq S.(4)✦ For every rational 2-cocycle c∈Z2(G)c \in Z^2(G), there is a β„š\mathbb{Q}-linear evaluation functional ev⁡(c):H2(G)β†’β„š\operatorname{ev}(c) : H_2(G) \to \mathbb{Q} satisfyingΒ (5): ev⁡(c)∘qG=c|Z2(G).\operatorname{ev}(c) \circ q_G = c|_{Z_2(G)}.(5)✦

Let HH be a group and let f:Gβ†’Hf : G \to H be a homomorphism inducing an isomorphism f*:H2(G)β†’βˆΌH2(H)f_* : H_2(G) \xrightarrow{\sim} H_2(H). For every rational 2-cocycle c∈Z2(G)c \in Z^2(G), there exist d∈Z2(H)d \in Z^2(H) and a β„š\mathbb{Q}-linear functional b:C1(G)β†’β„šb : C_1(G) \to \mathbb{Q} satisfyingΒ (6): cβˆ’f*(d)=b∘d2G.c - f^*(d) = b \circ d_2^G.(6)✦ The pullback f*(c)f^*(c) of any rational 2-cocycle c∈Z2(H)c \in Z^2(H) satisfiesΒ (7): f*(c)∈B2(G)⇔c∈B2(H).f^*(c) \in B^2(G) \iff c \in B^2(H).(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for nβ‰₯6n \ge 6, equivalence classes of central extensions of E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R) by β„š\mathbb{Q} are naturally in bijection with Hom⁡(Jn(R),β„š)\operatorname{Hom}(J_n(R), \mathbb{Q}) (where Jn(R)J_n(R) stands for the paper’s JnJ_n), and this bijection commutes with restriction along inclusions of ranks. In the library’s statement, the pushout and kernel-character constructions inΒ (1), (2), andΒ (3) are stated for arbitrary rank nn, and the bar-cocycle correspondence inΒ (4) throughΒ (7) is stated for general groups and H2H_2-isomorphisms.

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over groups PP, GG, and HH, a surjective homomorphism p:Pβ†’Gp : P \to G with central kernel and homomorphism Ο†:ker⁡pβ†’β„š\varphi : \ker p \to \mathbb{Q}, an 𝔽2\mathbb{F}_2-algebra RR and natural number nn with the Steinberg group St⁡n(R)\operatorname{St}_n(R), elementary matrix group E⁡n(R)\operatorname{E}_n(R), and kernel Jn(R)J_n(R), rational central extensions by the additive group β„š\mathbb{Q}, and the rational bar complex and second rational homology H2H_2. For the pushout construction, even without assuming surjectivity of pp, the inclusion ΞΉΟ†\iota_\varphi is injective with central image equal to ker⁡πφ\ker \pi_\varphi.