The Setting
Take three elements , , and of a group . Because the commutator operation is not associative in general, taking the commutator of the commutator of and with need not yield the same element as taking the commutator of with the commutator of and . The question is which commutation assumptions on , , , and those inner commutators force the two iterated commutators to coincide and determine which elements commute with them.
Commutators
In a group , the commutator of two elements is the element of defined by (1)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a group, let , and set and . Suppose that commutes with and , that commutes with and , that commutes with , and that commutes with . Then (2)✦ and this common element commutes with , , , and .
What Is Checked
The claim is stated over an arbitrary group and three elements , with the commutator (1), under the hypotheses that commutes with and , that commutes with and , that commutes with , and that commutes with .