OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. An anchor for successive choices

Lemma 3.3 [Idempotent in a compact semigroup]: For decreasing convex families of nonexpansive selfmaps closed under composition, with a compact Hausdorff weak carrier

An idempotent in all the closures.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let XX be a real normed space and K⊆XK\subseteq X. Successive restrictions on families of selfmaps of KK give decreasing families whose closures are taken in the topology of pointwise weak convergence.

Write XwX^w for the ambient space with its weak topology. The weak carrier KwK^w is the copy of KK inside XwX^w, with the induced topology.✦ The norm-to-weak identification ι:K→Kw\iota:K\to K^w is the bijection that leaves the underlying point of XX unchanged.✦ The domain KK retains its ambient norm.

A weak-valued selfmap ff of KK is a function f:K→Kwf:K\to K^w.✦ Write ℳ(K)\mathcal M(K) for the space of all such functions, equipped with the topology of pointwise weak convergence. For a family B⊆ℳ(K)B\subseteq\mathcal M(K), write B¯pw\overline B^{\mathrm{pw}} for its closure in this topology.

The underlying norm selfmap fˆ:K→K\widehat f:K\to K represents the values of ff in the norm carrier.✦ For a weak-valued selfmap ff of KK, the ambient weak-valued map f̃:K→Xw\widetilde f:K\to X^w is the function obtained by viewing the values of ff as points of XwX^w: fˆ(x)=ι−1(f(x)),f̃(x)=f(x)∈Xw(x∈K).\widehat f(x)=\iota^{-1}(f(x)), \qquad \widetilde f(x)=f(x)\in X^w \quad (x\in K).(1) A map f∈ℳ(K)f\in\mathcal M(K) is nonexpansive when its norm representative in (1) satisfies ∥fˆ(x)−fˆ(y)∥X≤∥x−y∥X(x,y∈K).\|\widehat f(x)-\widehat f(y)\|_X\leq\|x-y\|_X \qquad (x,y\in K).(2)

Selfmap composition f⋆gf\star g of f,g∈ℳ(K)f,g\in\mathcal M(K) is the weak-valued selfmap defined by (f⋆g)(x)=f(gˆ(x))(x∈K).(f\star g)(x)=f(\widehat g(x)) \qquad (x\in K).(3)✦

A family B⊆ℳ(K)B\subseteq\mathcal M(K) is convex when its ambient weak-valued maps form a convex subset of the real vector space (Xw)K(X^w)^K, meaning that tf̃+(1−t)g̃∈{h̃:h∈B}(f,g∈B,0≤t≤1).t\widetilde f+(1-t)\widetilde g \in\{\widetilde h:h\in B\} \qquad (f,g\in B,\ 0\leq t\leq1).(4)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Assume that KwK^w is compact and Hausdorff. Let (Bn)n≥0(B_n)_{n\geq0} be a decreasing sequence of nonempty families in ℳ(K)\mathcal M(K), each convex in the sense of (4). Suppose every member of every BnB_n is nonexpansive in the sense of (2), and each BnB_n is closed under the composition (3). Then there is P∈ℳ(K)P\in\mathcal M(K) such that P∈⋂n≥0Bn¯pw,P⋆P=P,∥Pˆ(x)−Pˆ(y)∥X≤∥x−y∥X(x,y∈K).P\in\bigcap_{n\geq0}\overline{B_n}^{\mathrm{pw}}, \qquad P\star P=P, \qquad \|\widehat P(x)-\widehat P(y)\|_X\leq\|x-y\|_X \quad (x,y\in K).(5)✦

In the paper, the result reads: a nonempty compact Hausdorff semigroup SS, for which every right translation h↦hph\mapsto hp with p∈Sp\in S is continuous, contains an element pp satisfying p2=pp^2=p.

What Is Checked

The statement (5) is over a subset of a real normed space with compact Hausdorff weak carrier, and decreasing nonempty convex families of nonexpansive selfmaps closed under composition.