OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. An anchor for successive choices

Proposition 3.4 [An anchor point]: An idempotent lies in every closed convexified tail, and the anchor lies in the norm-closed convex hull of its tail-limit set

Weak compactness yields a resolvent tail anchor.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let XX be a real Banach space, let K⊂XK\subset X be closed and convex, and let T:K→KT:K\to K be nonexpansive in the original norm of XX. The anchor problem concerns the asymptotic values of resolvent compositions at one point of KK.

Write XwX_{\mathrm w} for XX with its weak topology and J:X→XwJ:X\to X_{\mathrm w} for the canonical identification. The set Kw=J(K)K_{\mathrm w}=J(K) is a subset of XwX_{\mathrm w} with the induced topology.✦ A subset D⊂XD\subset X is weakly compact when J(D)J(D) is compact in XwX_{\mathrm w}.✦ The identification ι:K→Kw\iota:K\to K_{\mathrm w} is the restriction of JJ; the underlying ambient point of w∈Kww\in K_{\mathrm w} is p(w)=J−1(w)∈Xp(w)=J^{-1}(w)\in X. Write co\operatorname{co} for the real convex hull and C¯∥⋅∥\overline{C}^{\|\cdot\|} for norm closure.

Resolvents and Tail Families

For a∈Ka\in K and 0≤t≤10\le t\le1, the anchored averaging map St,a:K→KS_{t,a}:K\to K is defined by (1). For a∈Ka\in K and 0<t≤10<t\le1, the weighted resolvent ℛt(a)\mathcal R_t(a) is the unique fixed point in KK of the anchored averaging map St,a:K→KS_{t,a}:K\to K.✦ The discrete resolvent Rn:K→KR_n:K\to K, for a positive natural index nn, uses the reciprocal weight: St,a(v)=ta+(1−t)T(v),ℛt(a)=St,a(ℛt(a)),0<t≤1,Rn=ℛ1/n,n≥1.\begin{aligned} S_{t,a}(v)&=ta+(1-t)T(v),\\ \mathcal R_t(a)&=S_{t,a}\bigl(\mathcal R_t(a)\bigr), &&0<t\le1,\\ R_n&=\mathcal R_{1/n},&&n\ge1. \end{aligned}(1)

A convex mixture of selfmaps f,g:K→Kf,g:K\to K is the map x↦af(x)+bg(x)x\mapsto af(x)+bg(x), where a,b≥0a,b\ge0 and a+b=1a+b=1.✦ The generated family 𝒢\mathcal G is the smallest family of selfmaps of KK containing the identity and every RnR_n, n≥1n\ge1, and closed under composition and convex mixtures.✦

The space ℳ(K)\mathcal M(K) of weak-valued selfmaps consists of all functions f:K→Kwf:K\to K_{\mathrm w}, with the topology of pointwise weak convergence.✦ For a family B⊂ℳ(K)B\subset\mathcal M(K), its closure in the topology of pointwise weak convergence is denoted by B¯p\overline{B}^{\mathrm p}. The underlying norm selfmap f♮f^\natural of f∈ℳ(K)f\in\mathcal M(K) is the selfmap of KK given by f♮=ι−1∘ff^\natural=\iota^{-1}\circ f.✦ For f,g∈ℳ(K)f,g\in\mathcal M(K), their composition is the weak-valued selfmap of KK given, for a∈Ka\in K, by (f∘g)(a)=f(g♮(a))(f\circ g)(a)=f(g^\natural(a)).✦ A selfmap g:K→Kg:K\to K has ambient-valued form gˆ:K→X\widehat g:K\to X, gˆ(a)=g(a)\widehat g(a)=g(a).✦ For f∈ℳ(K)f\in\mathcal M(K), the ambient weak-valued form of ff is the function from KK to XwX_{\mathrm w} given by J∘f♮ˆJ\circ\widehat{f^\natural}.✦ A family B⊂ℳ(K)B\subset\mathcal M(K) is convex when its ambient weak-valued forms constitute a convex subset of (Xw)K(X_{\mathrm w})^K.✦

For each nonnegative integer mm, the resolvent tail family HmH_m is the family of selfmaps of KK consisting of compositions whose outer resolvent has index at least mm, as specified in (2). The ambient-valued family FmF_m of the resolvent tail family HmH_m is the family of maps from KK to XX specified in (2), and CmC_m is the convex hull of FmF_m. The convexified weak-valued tail WmW_m consists of the weak-valued selfmaps whose underlying ambient-valued maps belong to CmC_m; the family AA of weak-valued selfmaps of KK is the intersection of the closures of these tails at positive indices: Hm={Rn∘g:n≥1,n≥m,g∈𝒢},Fm={hˆ:h∈Hm},Cm=co⁡Fm,Wm={f∈ℳ(K):f♮ˆ∈Cm},A=⋂n≥0Wn+1¯p.\begin{aligned} H_m&=\{R_n\circ g:n\ge1,\ n\ge m,\ g\in\mathcal G\},\\ F_m&=\{\widehat h:h\in H_m\},\qquad C_m=\operatorname{co}F_m,\\ W_m&=\{f\in\mathcal M(K):\widehat{f^\natural}\in C_m\},\\ A&=\bigcap_{n\ge0}\overline{W_{n+1}}^{\mathrm p}. \end{aligned}(2)

For any family H=(Hm)m≥0H=(H_m)_{m\ge0} of sets of selfmaps of KK and any x∈Kx\in K, the weak tail image closure En(H,x)E_n(H,x) is the subset of KwK_{\mathrm w} given in the first line of (3), and the ambient tail-limit set DxHD_x^H is the subset of XX given in its second line; the closure in the first line is taken in KwK_{\mathrm w}: En(H,x)={ι(h(x)):h∈Hn+1}¯Kw,DxH=p(⋂n≥0En(H,x)).\begin{aligned} E_n(H,x)&=\overline{\{\iota(h(x)):h\in H_{n+1}\}}^{K_{\mathrm w}},\\ D_x^H&=p\left(\bigcap_{n\ge0}E_n(H,x)\right). \end{aligned}(3)

An anchor for HH is a pair (x,D)(x,D), where x∈Kx\in K and D⊂KD\subset K is a nonempty weakly compact set satisfying (4); denote the set of these pairs by Anch⁡(H)\operatorname{Anch}(H): D=DxH,x∈co⁡D¯∥⋅∥,ι(D)⊂Em−1(H,x)(m≥1).D=D_x^H,\qquad x\in\overline{\operatorname{co}D}^{\|\cdot\|},\qquad \iota(D)\subset E_{m-1}(H,x)\quad(m\ge1).(4)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let B⊂ℳ(K)B\subset\mathcal M(K) be a convex family whose underlying norm selfmaps are nonexpansive, and suppose BB is closed under composition. For h,k∈B¯ph,k\in\overline B^{\mathrm p}, h∘k∈B¯p.h\circ k\in\overline B^{\mathrm p}.(5)✦

Suppose KwK_{\mathrm w} is compact and Hausdorff. Then ∃P∈A:P∘P=P,∥P♮(a)−P♮(b)∥≤∥a−b∥(a,b∈K).\exists P\in A:\quad P\circ P=P,\qquad \|P^\natural(a)-P^\natural(b)\|\le\|a-b\|\quad(a,b\in K).(6)✦

If KK is nonempty and weakly compact, the resolvent tail family H=(Hm)m≥0H=(H_m)_{m\ge0} satisfies Anch⁡(H)≠⌀.\operatorname{Anch}(H)\ne\varnothing.(7)✦

Let (Bn)n≥0(B_n)_{n\ge0} be a decreasing sequence of nonempty compact subsets of XwX_{\mathrm w}. Suppose x∈Xx\in X belongs to co⁡J−1(Bn)¯∥⋅∥\overline{\operatorname{co}J^{-1}(B_n)}^{\|\cdot\|} for every nn. Then x∈co⁡J−1(⋂n≥0Bn)¯∥⋅∥.x\in\overline{\operatorname{co}J^{-1}\!\left(\bigcap_{n\ge0}B_n\right)}^{\|\cdot\|}.(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: when KK is a minimal invariant set for a fixed-point-free nonexpansive map TT and diam⁡K=1\operatorname{diam}K=1, AA is a nonempty compact semigroup of nonexpansive selfmaps of KK containing an idempotent PP, and there is x∈Kx\in K with P♮(x)=xP^\natural(x)=x such that DxHD_x^H is nonempty and weakly compact and x∈co⁡DxH¯∥⋅∥x\in\overline{\operatorname{co}D_x^H}^{\|\cdot\|}.

What Is Checked

The closure statement (5) concerns weak-valued maps; the tail statements (6) and (7) use a closed convex KK and a selfmap TT nonexpansive in the ambient norm, while (8) concerns decreasing nonempty weakly compact subsets of XX.

For 0<t≤10<t\le1, the averaging map in (1) has contraction bound 1−t1-t in the original norm of XX.✦ The discrete weights satisfy 0<1/n≤10<1/n\le1 for every positive natural index nn.