OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Weak compactness and a minimal invariant set

Lemma 2.2 [Separable normalized minimal invariant reduction]: The closed difference span is separable and its whole unit ball is weakly compact

Reflexive counterexamples admit normalized minimal sets.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let XX be a real Banach space and let C⊂XC\subset X be nonempty, norm-closed, bounded and convex. A nonexpansive selfmap F:C→CF\colon C\to C is a map satisfying the ambient norm inequality (1). ∥F(x)−F(y)∥≤∥x−y∥(x,y∈C).\|F(x)-F(y)\|\leq \|x-y\| \qquad (x,y\in C).(1) A selfmap F:C→CF\colon C\to C is fixed-point-free when F(x)≠xF(x)\ne x for every x∈Cx\in C.

A real Banach space XX is canonically reflexive when the canonical map ιX:X→X**\iota_X\colon X\to X^{**} into its continuous bidual is surjective.✦

Invariant Sets and Their Topologies

An invariant subset S⊂XS\subset X for a selfmap U:A→AU\colon A\to A of a subset A⊂XA\subset X is a set such that U(A∩S)⊂SU(A\cap S)\subset S.✦ A subset A⊂XA\subset X is minimal for closed convex invariance under a selfmap U:A→AU\colon A\to A when every nonempty, norm-closed, convex invariant subset S⊂AS\subset A equals AA.✦

For a subset A⊂XA\subset X, write AwA_{\mathrm w} for AA viewed in (X,σ(X,X*))(X,\sigma(X,X^*)) with the induced weak topology.✦ A subset AA of XX is weakly compact when AwA_{\mathrm w} is compact.✦ Separability of a subset of XX refers to the norm topology.

Minimal invariant data (M,U)(M,U) in XX consist of a nonempty, norm-closed, bounded, convex, separable, weakly compact subset M⊂XM\subset X and a fixed-point-free nonexpansive selfmap U:M→MU\colon M\to M for which MM is minimal for closed convex invariance.✦

For a subset A⊂XA\subset X, its closed difference span YAY_A is the norm-closed real linear span of its differences, and BYA⊂XB_{Y_A}\subset X is the whole closed unit ball of that subspace, as in (2). YA=span⁡ℝ(A−A)¯,BYA={x∈YA:∥x∥≤1}.Y_A=\overline{\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb R}(A-A)}, \qquad B_{Y_A}=\{x\in Y_A:\|x\|\leq 1\}.(2) The norm in (2) is the original norm of XX.

Normalized minimal invariant data (K,T,z)(K,T,z) in XX are minimal invariant data (K,T)(K,T) of diameter one, together with a sequence z:ℕ→Kz\colon\mathbb N\to K having norm-dense range, such that KwK_{\mathrm w} is metrizable and BYB_Y is weakly compact, with the notation (3). Y=span⁡ℝ(K−K)¯,BY={x∈Y:∥x∥≤1}.Y=\overline{\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb R}(K-K)}, \qquad B_Y=\{x\in Y:\|x\|\leq 1\}.(3)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let C⊂XC\subset X be nonempty, norm-closed, bounded and convex, and let F:C→CF\colon C\to C be nonexpansive. There is a subset S⊂CS\subset C satisfying (4). S≠⌀,F(S)⊂S,S is norm-closed, bounded, convex and separable.\begin{gathered} S\ne\varnothing,\qquad F(S)\subset S,\\ S\text{ is norm-closed, bounded, convex and separable}. \end{gathered}(4)✦ If XX is canonically reflexive and FF is fixed-point-free, there are minimal invariant data (M,U)(M,U) in XX with (5). M⊂C.M\subset C.(5)✦ Under these additional hypotheses, (6) also holds. There exist normalized minimal invariant data (K,T,z) in X.\text{There exist normalized minimal invariant data }(K,T,z)\text{ in }X.(6)✦ For every separable weakly compact subset A⊂XA\subset X, (7) holds. Aw is metrizable.A_{\mathrm w}\text{ is metrizable}.(7)✦ The closed difference span of every separable subset A⊂XA\subset X satisfies (8). YA is separable in its norm topology.Y_A\text{ is separable in its norm topology}.(8)✦ In a canonically reflexive space XX, the unit ball satisfies (9) for every subset A⊂XA\subset X. BYA is weakly compact.B_{Y_A}\text{ is weakly compact}.(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if Theorem 1.1 fails, there are a nonempty separable weakly compact convex set KK and a fixed-point-free nonexpansive map T:K→KT\colon K\to K such that KK has no proper nonempty norm-closed convex TT-invariant subset; scalar normalization gives diam⁡K=1\operatorname{diam}K=1, the weak topology on KK is metrizable, and Y=span⁡ℝ(K−K)¯Y=\overline{\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb R}(K-K)} is separable with weakly compact unit ball BYB_Y.

What Is Checked

The statements concern real Banach spaces and subsets with the inherited norm, with canonical reflexivity assumed in (5), (6) and (9).