OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. From a coefficient relation to a planar surface

§5 (setting): finite realization of a normal-closure relation: For a group AA and an infinite cyclic group ⟨t⟩\langle t\rangle, outside boundary values form a subgroup of A*⟨t⟩A*\langle t\rangle for fixed relator data

Realizing words on finite planar ribbons.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AA be a group, let H=A*⟨t⟩H=A*\langle t\rangle, and let ι:A→H\iota:A\to H be the canonical coefficient map. The question is which words of HH can occur on the marked outside circuit of a finite planar arrangement of relator disks.

Fix a finite set II of positions, a permutation ρ\rho of II, coefficients a:I→Aa:I\to A, and exponents s:I→ℤs:I\to\mathbb Z. For cyclic word data, I={1,…,n}I=\{1,\ldots,n\} with n=|I|n=|I|, ρ\rho is cyclic successor, and the relator has the form (1); identity coefficients are allowed. w=ts1ι(a1)⋯tsnι(an),si∈{1,−1}.w=t^{s_1}\iota(a_1)\cdots t^{s_n}\iota(a_n), \qquad s_i\in\{1,-1\}.(1)

Permutation and Disk Data

Let DD be a finite set of darts and let σ,θ\sigma,\theta be permutations of DD. For a permutation π\pi of a finite dart set DD, the set 𝒞(π)\mathcal C(\pi) of its cycles is the quotient of DD by its same-cycle relation ∼π\sim_\pi✦; its cycle count c(π)c(\pi) is the cardinality of this set.✦ The class count q(R)q(R) of an equivalence relation RR on DD is the cardinality of its quotient, as in (2). 𝒞(π)=D/∼π,c(π)=|𝒞(π)|,q(R)=|D/R|.\mathcal C(\pi)=D/{\sim_\pi},\qquad c(\pi)=|\mathcal C(\pi)|,\qquad q(R)=|D/R|.(2)

The ribbon graph components relation Rσ,θR_{\sigma,\theta} is the least equivalence relation containing ∼σ\sim_\sigma and ∼θ\sim_\theta.✦ A pair of permutations σ,θ\sigma,\theta of a finite dart set DD is planar when it satisfies (3), where σθ\sigma\theta applies θ\theta first; the cycles of σθ\sigma\theta are the boundary cycles. c(σ)+c(θ)+c(σθ)=|D|+2q(Rσ,θ).c(\sigma)+c(\theta)+c(\sigma\theta) =|D|+2q(R_{\sigma,\theta}).(3)✦

A closed permutation walk Cσ(o,l)C_\sigma(o,l) for a permutation σ\sigma of a dart set DD, based at o∈Do\in D, is a list l=(d1,…,db)l=(d_1,\ldots,d_b) of darts in DD following σ\sigma from oo back to oo, with the condition (4). Cσ(o,l)⇔σ(dj)=dj+1(0≤j≤b),d0=db+1=o.C_\sigma(o,l)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \sigma(d_j)=d_{j+1}\quad(0\le j\le b), \qquad d_0=d_{b+1}=o.(4)✦

For a set VV of disk indices and integer orientations ε:V→ℤ\varepsilon:V\to\mathbb Z, the oriented vertex successor νε:V×I→V×I\nu_\varepsilon:V\times I\to V\times I and signed vertex coefficient αε:V×I→A\alpha_\varepsilon:V\times I\to A are the maps in (5). νε(v,i)={(v,ρi),εv=1,(v,ρ−1i),εv≠1,αε(v,i)={ai,εv=1,aρ−1i−1,εv≠1.\begin{aligned} \nu_\varepsilon(v,i) &=\begin{cases} (v,\rho i),&\varepsilon_v=1,\\ (v,\rho^{-1}i),&\varepsilon_v\ne1, \end{cases} & \alpha_\varepsilon(v,i) &=\begin{cases} a_i,&\varepsilon_v=1,\\ a_{\rho^{-1}i}^{-1},&\varepsilon_v\ne1. \end{cases} \end{aligned}(5)

A relator disk atlas (f,ε)(f,\varepsilon) for a set VV of disk indices and traversal exponents τ:D→ℤ\tau:D\to\mathbb Z is a pair consisting of an injection f:V×I↪Df:V\times I\hookrightarrow D and a polarity function ε:V→{1,−1}\varepsilon:V\to\{1,-1\} satisfying (6), with the oriented successor from (5). σ(f(v,i))=f(νε(v,i)),τ(f(v,i))=εvsi(v∈V,i∈I).\sigma(f(v,i))=f(\nu_\varepsilon(v,i)),\qquad \tau(f(v,i))=\varepsilon_v s_i\qquad(v\in V,\ i\in I).(6)✦

For a corner potential u:D→Au:D\to A, the corner coefficient function c:D→Ac:D\to A is the map assigning to each dart its following corner coefficient by (7). c(d)=u(θd)u(σd)−1.c(d)=u(\theta d)u(\sigma d)^{-1}.(7)✦

For a dart d∈Dd\in D and a finite list LL of darts, the dart letter λτ,c(d)∈H\lambda_{\tau,c}(d)\in H and the dart word evaluation Eτ,c(L)∈HE_{\tau,c}(L)\in H are respectively the group element and the product defined in (8), with the product taken in the order of the list. λτ,c(d)=tτ(d)ι(c(d)),Eτ,c(L)=∏d in Lλτ,c(d).\lambda_{\tau,c}(d)=t^{\tau(d)}\iota(c(d)),\qquad E_{\tau,c}(L)=\prod_{d\text{ in }L}\lambda_{\tau,c}(d).(8)

The Definition

Definition 1. Let DD and VV be finite sets, let o∈Do\in D, and let l=(d1,…,db)l=(d_1,\ldots,d_b) be a list of darts. Write O={o,d1,…,db}O=\{o,d_1,\ldots,d_b\} and F={d∈D:σd=d,θd=d}F=\{d\in D:\sigma d=d,\ \theta d=d\}. A finite planar relator ribbon r=(σ,θ,τ,f,ε,u)r=(\sigma,\theta,\tau,f,\varepsilon,u) for (ρ,a,s)(\rho,a,s), with marked outside dart oo, is a tuple satisfying (9); cc is its corner coefficient from (7). $$\begin{aligned} &r\in\operatorname{Out}_{\rho,a,s}(D,V;o,l)\\ &\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \left\{\begin{gathered} \theta^2=\operatorname{id}_D,\qquad \text{\eqref{eq:planarity} holds},\\ \tau\circ\theta=-\tau,\qquad \theta(o)=o,\qquad \tau(o)=0,\\ C_\sigma(o,l),\qquad o,d_1,\ldots,d_b\text{ are distinct},\\ \tau(d_j)\in\{1,-1\}\quad(1\le j\le b),\\ (f,\varepsilon)\text{ is a disk atlas as in \eqref{eq:atlas}},\\ f(V\times I)\cap O=\varnothing,\qquad D=f(V\times I)\cup O\cup F,\\ c(f(v,i))=\alpha_\varepsilon(v,i)\quad(v\in V,\ i\in I). \end{gathered}\right. \end{aligned}$$(9)✦

The outside boundary word val⁡(r)∈H\operatorname{val}(r)\in H of a finite planar relator ribbon rr is the evaluation in (10), using (8). val⁡(r)=Eτ,c(o,d1,…,db).\operatorname{val}(r)=E_{\tau,c}(o,d_1,\ldots,d_b).(10)✦

A finite planar realization rr of a word z∈Hz\in H is a finite planar relator ribbon whose outside boundary word is zz, as in (11). Real⁡ρ,a,s(z)⇔z=val⁡(r) for some finite planar relator ribbon r.\operatorname{Real}_{\rho,a,s}(z) \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad z=\operatorname{val}(r)\text{ for some finite planar relator ribbon }r.(11)✦

The realized subgroup ℛρ,a,s\mathcal R_{\rho,a,s} of HH is the set in (12). ℛρ,a,s={z∈H:Real⁡ρ,a,s(z)}≤H.\mathcal R_{\rho,a,s} =\{z\in H:\operatorname{Real}_{\rho,a,s}(z)\}\le H.(12)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for g∈Ag\in A with ι(g)∈⟨⟨w⟩⟩H\iota(g)\in\langle\!\langle w\rangle\!\rangle_H, write ι(g)\iota(g) as a finite product of conjugates of ww and w−1w^{-1}, realize this product on a finite punctured disk mapped into a wedge of spaces Y∨TY\vee T, where π1(Y)=A\pi_1(Y)=A, and extract oppositely signed bands while retaining the original coefficient map into YY.

What Is Checked

The definitions (9), (11) and (12) are stated over an arbitrary coefficient group AA and finite position data (I,ρ,a,s)(I,\rho,a,s), with arbitrary integer exponents and finite dart and disk sets in each realization.