The Setting
A planar surface whose other boundary words are trivial has one exceptional boundary word to consider. The question is whether the boundary phase inequalities allow that word to represent a nontrivial group element.
Let be an arbitrary group. The relevant phases are attached to elements of through their left regular operators on , with the phase cut at .
Regular Operators
For a complex inner product space , a bounded operator on is a continuous complex-linear map from to itself.✦ The regular Hilbert space operators of are the bounded operators on .✦
The delta vector , for in an index set , is the square-summable complex family defined by (1): (1)✦
For a bijection , the linear coordinate permutation is the complex-linear equivalence between the corresponding spaces given, together with its inverse, by (2).✦ The unitary coordinate permutation associated with a bijection is the isometric coordinate equivalence between and given by (2).✦ (2)
For , the left regular isometry on is the coordinate permutation induced by .✦ For , the left regular operator is the bounded operator on specified on delta vectors by (3): (3)✦
Spectral Phase
The scalar rotation through a real parameter is the complex number given by (4), where is the imaginary unit: (4)✦
The fractional argument is the real-valued function on that assigns to each complex number the fractional part of its principal argument divided by .✦ Its values, including the value at the cut, are fixed by (5): (5)✦
For a continuous real-valued function on a topological space , its complexification is the continuous complex-valued function obtained by composing with the inclusion .✦
For a normal bounded operator on and a vector , the spectral vector functional is the positive real-linear functional on compactly supported continuous real functions on the spectrum given by (6).✦ Here denotes continuous functional calculus. (6)
The vector spectral measure is the finite measure on obtained by Riesz representation of .✦ For a normal bounded operator on and a vector , the vector spectral phase is the real number obtained by integrating the fractional argument against the vector spectral measure , as in (7): (7)✦
For and a scalar of modulus one, the scalar-rotated group phase is the vector spectral phase at of the unitary operator , as in (8): (8)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let , and let be a sequence of nonnegative real numbers converging to zero. Then (9) holds: (9)✦
Theorem 2. Let be a finite nonempty set, let , and choose . Let assign a boundary coefficient to each label. Suppose that, for every real with , the boundary inequality (10) holds: (10) Then the exceptional coefficient satisfies (11): (11)✦
What Is Checked
The continuity statement is over regular operators of an arbitrary group and nonnegative sequences tending to zero; the boundary criterion is over a finite nonempty set of labels and a coefficient assignment satisfying the inequalities for every .
A bijection preserves square-summability under the coordinate change in (2).✦ Every scalar rotation in (4) has modulus one.✦