OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Comparison of edge images

Lemma 5.1: Over a noetherian unique factorization domain, a free submodule MM of a torsion-free module EE with E/ME/M torsion is recovered from its height-one localizations

A free submodule as the intersection of its height-one localizations.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let AA be the real polynomial ring on a basis of the extended realization VV. A nonzero linear form α\alpha generates a prime ideal (α)(\alpha) of AA of height one, and localizing at it inverts every polynomial not divisible by α\alpha.

Take a submodule MM of a module EE over an integral domain RR, and an element xx of EE that lies in MM after localization at every prime ideal of height one. Must xx lie in MM?

Torsion-free Modules and Localizations

A torsion-free RR-module EE is an RR-module in which cx=0cx = 0, with c∈Rc \in R nonzero and x∈Ex \in E, forces x=0x = 0. A free submodule MM of EE is a submodule that has a basis over RR.

For a submodule MM of EE, the quotient E/ME/M is a torsion module when every element of EE has a nonzero multiple in MM: for each x∈Ex \in E there is c≠0c \neq 0 in RR with cx∈Mcx \in M.

The height ht⁡𝔭\operatorname{ht} \mathfrak p of a prime ideal 𝔭\mathfrak p of RR is the supremum of the lengths nn of the chains of prime ideals 𝔭0⊊𝔭1⊊⋯⊊𝔭n=𝔭\mathfrak p_0 \subsetneq \mathfrak p_1 \subsetneq \cdots \subsetneq \mathfrak p_n = \mathfrak p.

For a prime ideal 𝔭\mathfrak p of RR, the localization E𝔭E_{\mathfrak p} of EE at 𝔭\mathfrak p is the R𝔭R_{\mathfrak p}-module of fractions x/sx/s with x∈Ex \in E and s∈R\𝔭s \in R \setminus \mathfrak p, where x/s=y/tx/s = y/t when u(tx−sy)=0u(tx - sy) = 0 for some u∈R\𝔭u \in R \setminus \mathfrak p; the localization map λ𝔭:E→E𝔭\lambda_{\mathfrak p} \colon E \to E_{\mathfrak p} sends xx to x/1x/1. The localization M𝔭M_{\mathfrak p} of a submodule MM is the R𝔭R_{\mathfrak p}-submodule of E𝔭E_{\mathfrak p} of the fractions m/sm/s with m∈Mm \in M and s∈R\𝔭s \in R \setminus \mathfrak p, and its preimage in EE is the submodule λ𝔭−1(M𝔭)={x∈E:x/1∈M𝔭}.\lambda_{\mathfrak p}^{-1}(M_{\mathfrak p}) = \{\, x \in E : x/1 \in M_{\mathfrak p} \,\}.(1)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let RR be a unique factorization domain, EE a torsion-free RR-module and MM a free submodule of EE.

  1. If RR is noetherian and E/ME/M is a torsion module, then MM is the intersection, over the prime ideals 𝔭\mathfrak p of RR of height one, of the preimages (1) of its localizations: M=⋂ht⁡𝔭=1λ𝔭−1(M𝔭).M = \bigcap_{\operatorname{ht} \mathfrak p = 1} \lambda_{\mathfrak p}^{-1}(M_{\mathfrak p}).(2)✦

  2. If an element xx of EE has a nonzero multiple in MM and, for every prime element pp of RR, a multiple ax∈Max \in M with a∈Ra \in R not divisible by pp, then x∈M.x \in M.(3)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if RR, written CC there, is a polynomial ring over a field, EE is a finite free RR-module and M⊆EM \subseteq E is a free submodule with the same span as EE over Frac⁡(R)\operatorname{Frac}(R), then M=⋂ht⁡𝔭=1M𝔭M = \bigcap_{\operatorname{ht} \mathfrak p = 1} M_{\mathfrak p} inside E⊗RFrac⁡(R)E \otimes_R \operatorname{Frac}(R), and M=EM = E when RR is a field.

What Is Checked

Both parts of the claim are stated over a unique factorization domain RR, noetherian in (2), a torsion-free RR-module EE and a free submodule MM of EE; the first over the prime ideals of RR of height one, the localizations M𝔭M_{\mathfrak p} inside E𝔭E_{\mathfrak p} and their preimages (1), the second over the prime elements of RR and divisibility by them.