OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · Section 1. Introduction

Theorem 1.1 [A fixed-pair quasitrace counterexample]: A quantitative defect on a separable matrix algebra admitting a normalized 2-quasitrace

A fixed pair detects quasitrace nonadditivity.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For positive elements a,ba,b of a unital complex C*C^*-algebra, the expression Re⁡(τ(a+b)−τ(a)−τ(b))\operatorname{Re}(\tau(a+b)-\tau(a)-\tau(b)) measures the failure of additivity of a quasitrace τ\tau on that pair. The construction here fixes the algebra and the pair before choosing the quasitrace. Its generators are operator-weighted shifts on Hilbert spaces assembled from finite-dimensional test spaces. The Kaplansky counterexample is a separable unital complex C*C^*-algebra admitting a normalized 2-quasitrace that is not a trace.

Write QT⁡1(C)\operatorname{QT}_1(C) and QT⁡2(C)\operatorname{QT}_2(C) for the quasitraces and the 2-quasitraces on a unital C*C^*-algebra CC, respectively. A quasitrace τ\tau on a unital C*C^*-algebra CC is normalized when τ(1)=1\tau(1)=1. A positive contraction cc in a unital C*C^*-algebra CC is an element c∈Cc\in C with c≥0c\geq0 and ‖c‖≤1\lVert c\rVert\leq1.

The Test Spaces and the Algebra

A smooth test index z=(m,R,σ)z=(m,R,\sigma) consists of positive integers m,Rm,R and a smooth test datum σ\sigma with those parameters.✦ Let Sz,jS_{z,j} be the finite slot set at stage jj of its test sequence. The test fiber Ez,jE_{z,j} is the Euclidean space on Sz,jS_{z,j}✦, and the test Hilbert space HzH_z is its Hilbert direct sum over the stages: Ez,j=ℓ2(Sz,j),Hz=⨁j≥0ℓ2Ez,j={(ξj):ξj∈Ez,j,∑j≥0‖ξj‖2<∞}.E_{z,j}=\ell^2(S_{z,j}),\qquad H_z=\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_{z,j} =\left\{(\xi_j):\xi_j\in E_{z,j},\ \sum_{j\geq0}\lVert\xi_j\rVert^2<\infty\right\}.(1) The level inclusion ιz,j:Ez,j→Hz\iota_{z,j}:E_{z,j}\to H_z places a vector in coordinate jj and is zero in every other coordinate of (1).✦

The normalized block operator TiT_i at index ii of a normalized Hermitian tuple from a finite-dimensional Hilbert space EE to a finite-dimensional Hilbert space FF is the forward linear map E→FE\to F of that tuple.✦ Write Ti,z,j:Ez,j→Ez,j+1T_{i,z,j}:E_{z,j}\to E_{z,j+1} for the test block operators, with 1≤i≤241\leq i\leq24. For any sequence of Hilbert spaces (Ej)(E_j) and contractive operators Tj:Ej→Ej+1T_j:E_j\to E_{j+1}, the successor inclusion JJ and the operator-weighted forward shift UTU_T are the maps J:⨁j≥0ℓ2Ej+1→⨁j≥0ℓ2Ej,J(η0,η1,…)=(0,η0,η1,…),UT:⨁j≥0ℓ2Ej→⨁j≥0ℓ2Ej,UT(ξ0,ξ1,…)=(0,T0ξ0,T1ξ1,…).\begin{aligned} J:\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_{j+1} &\longrightarrow\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_j, &J(\eta_0,\eta_1,\ldots)&=(0,\eta_0,\eta_1,\ldots),\\ U_T:\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_j &\longrightarrow\bigoplus_{j\geq0}^{\ell^2}E_j, &U_T(\xi_0,\xi_1,\ldots)&=(0,T_0\xi_0,T_1\xi_1,\ldots). \end{aligned}(2)

The bounded product PP of the operator algebras on the spaces HzH_z is the C*C^*-algebra of uniformly bounded operator families, with the supremum norm.✦ The contractive-family inclusion sends a family (yz)(y_z) satisfying ‖yz‖≤1\lVert y_z\rVert\leq1 for every zz to that same family in PP.✦ Applied to the shifts in (2), it defines the bounded shift generators x1,…,x24x_1,\ldots,x_{24}: P={(yz)∈∏zℬ(Hz):supz‖yz‖<∞},xi=(U(Ti,z,j)j≥0)z.P=\left\{(y_z)\in\prod_z\mathcal B(H_z): \sup_z\lVert y_z\rVert<\infty\right\},\qquad x_i=\bigl(U_{(T_{i,z,j})_{j\geq0}}\bigr)_z.(3)

The generated algebra BB is the closed unital C*C^*-subalgebra of PP generated by the elements in (3).✦ Its canonical generators are those same elements regarded as elements of BB.✦ The defect algebra AA is the matrix algebra over BB indexed by two copies of a 24-element set: B=C*(1,x1,…,x24)⊆P,A=M48(B).B=C^*(1,x_1,\ldots,x_{24})\subseteq P,\qquad A=M_{48}(B).(4) The zero-extended generator sequence is x̃n={xn+1,0≤n<24,0,n≥24.\widetilde x_n= \begin{cases} x_{n+1},&0\leq n<24,\\ 0,&n\geq24. \end{cases}(5)✦ Write A+A_+ for the positive cone of AA, and let a,b∈Aa,b\in A be the first and second defect elements associated to (5) with parameter 2424.

The Claim

Theorem 1. For the algebra AA of (4) and its fixed defect elements a,ba,b, the following assertions hold: A is separable.A\text{ is separable}.(6)✦ ∃τ∈QT⁡2(A),τ(1)=1.\exists\tau\in\operatorname{QT}_2(A),\qquad \tau(1)=1.(7)✦ a,b∈A+,‖a‖≤1,‖b‖≤1,Re⁡(τ(a+b)−τ(a)−τ(b))≥1144for every τ∈QT⁡1(A) with τ(1)=1.\begin{gathered} a,b\in A_+,\qquad\lVert a\rVert\leq1,\quad\lVert b\rVert\leq1,\\ \operatorname{Re}\bigl(\tau(a+b)-\tau(a)-\tau(b)\bigr) \geq\frac1{144} \quad\text{for every }\tau\in\operatorname{QT}_1(A) \text{ with }\tau(1)=1. \end{gathered}(8)✦ ∃τ∈QT⁡2(A),τ(1)=1andτ|A+ is not additive.\exists\tau\in\operatorname{QT}_2(A),\qquad \tau(1)=1\quad\text{and}\quad \tau|_{A_+}\text{ is not additive}.(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: there exist a separable unital complex C*C^*-algebra AA admitting a normalized 2-quasitrace and positive contractions a,b∈Aa,b\in A such that every normalized 2-quasitrace τ\tau on AA satisfies τ(a+b)−τ(a)−τ(b)≥1/144\tau(a+b)-\tau(a)-\tau(b)\geq1/144.

What Is Checked

The statements (9), (7), (8) and (6) concern the closed generated C*C^*-algebra BB, its matrix algebra A=M48(B)A=M_{48}(B) and the defect pair formed from its specified generator sequence; the quantitative statement ranges over normalized quasitraces on AA.

The test block operators satisfy ‖Ti,z,j‖≤1(1≤i≤24,z a smooth test index,j≥0).\lVert T_{i,z,j}\rVert\leq1 \qquad(1\leq i\leq24,\ z\text{ a smooth test index},\ j\geq0).(10)✦ The level inclusions into (1) are isometric, the successor levels are mutually orthogonal✦, and the successor inclusion in (2) is isometric.