The Setting
A unital complex -algebra is stably finite if every isometry in every matrix algebra over is unitary, as in (1): (1)✦ A closed two-sided -ideal of is a norm-closed nonunital complex -subalgebra satisfying and .✦ The algebra is simple if its only closed two-sided -ideals are and .✦
For an index set and a normed abelian group , the space consists of square-summable -valued families, with its norm.✦ When is a complex Hilbert space, a permutation of defines a unitary operator on , given for and by (2): (2)✦ For a group , a complex Hilbert space , and , the operator of the left regular representation on is given by reindexing by left multiplication by .✦ The diagonal operator associated with a group and a bounded operator on a complex Hilbert space acts on by applying to each coordinate.✦ For and , their formulas are (3): (3) Write for the bounded complex-linear operators on a Hilbert space . The reduced group -algebra is the norm closure of the complex -algebra generated by the scalar left regular representation: (4)✦ The free group is the free group on two generators, and is its reduced algebra from (4).
For a group and a unital complex -representation , the concrete spatial tensor algebra is the norm-closed complex -subalgebra of generated by the diagonal operators for and the left regular operators for .✦ For , write for this algebra, as in (5): (5)✦
A tracial state on is a positive complex-linear functional satisfying (6): (6)✦ Write for the set of tracial states on the unital complex -algebra and for the set of normalized -quasitraces on .
The Existence Conditions
The family of simple tensor counterexamples consists of triples , where is a nonzero unital simple stably finite complex -algebra, is a complex Hilbert space, and is a faithful unital -representation with properly infinite; membership also requires to be simple and stably finite.✦
The family of quasitrace loss examples consists of triples , where is a nonzero separable unital complex -algebra admitting a normalized -quasitrace, is a complex Hilbert space, and is a faithful unital -representation such that is properly infinite and is empty.✦
The family of traceless stably finite algebras consists of the nonzero separable unital stably finite complex -algebras for which is empty.✦ The stable finiteness consequences are the joint existence of members of , and .✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. The simple tensor counterexample condition (7), the quasitrace loss condition (8), and traceless stable finiteness (9) hold: (7)✦ (8)✦ (9)✦ Their simultaneous existence is the stable finiteness corollary (10): (10)✦
In the paper, the result reads: there are two unital simple stably finite complex -algebras whose minimal tensor product is properly infinite, one factor being ; there is a separable unital complex -algebra admitting a normalized -quasitrace such that is properly infinite and admits no normalized -quasitrace; and there is a separable unital stably finite complex -algebra with no tracial state.
What Is Checked
The statements concern nonzero unital complex -algebras, faithful unital -representations on complex Hilbert spaces for the tensor examples, and the matrix condition (1) for stable finiteness. Reindexing preserves square summability: for a permutation of and , the family is square-summable.✦