OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · Section 1. Introduction

Corollary 1.2 [Tensor products and stable finiteness]: Simple factors, loss of normalized 22-quasitraces, and separable algebras without tracial states

Stable finiteness fails under spatial tensor products.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A unital complex C*C^*-algebra DD is stably finite if every isometry in every matrix algebra over DD is unitary, as in (1): v∈Mn(D),n≥1,v*v=1⇒vv*=1.v\in M_n(D),\quad n\geq 1,\quad v^*v=1 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad vv^*=1.(1)✦ A closed two-sided **-ideal JJ of DD is a norm-closed nonunital complex **-subalgebra satisfying DJ⊆JDJ\subseteq J and JD⊆JJD\subseteq J.✦ The algebra DD is simple if its only closed two-sided **-ideals are 00 and DD.✦

For an index set ι\iota and a normed abelian group HH, the space ℓ2(ι,H)\ell^2(\iota,H) consists of square-summable HH-valued families, with its ℓ2\ell^2 norm.✦ When HH is a complex Hilbert space, a permutation ee of ι\iota defines a unitary operator ReR_e on ℓ2(ι,H)\ell^2(\iota,H), given for ξ∈ℓ2(ι,H)\xi\in\ell^2(\iota,H) and i∈ιi\in\iota by (2): (Reξ)(i)=ξ(e−1(i)).(R_e\xi)(i)=\xi(e^{-1}(i)).(2)✦ For a group GG, a complex Hilbert space HH, and g∈Gg\in G, the operator λgH\lambda_g^H of the left regular representation on ℓ2(G,H)\ell^2(G,H) is given by reindexing by left multiplication by gg.✦ The diagonal operator I⊗TI\otimes T associated with a group GG and a bounded operator TT on a complex Hilbert space HH acts on ℓ2(G,H)\ell^2(G,H) by applying TT to each coordinate.✦ For ξ∈ℓ2(G,H)\xi\in\ell^2(G,H) and h∈Gh\in G, their formulas are (3): (λgHξ)(h)=ξ(g−1h),((I⊗T)ξ)(h)=T(ξ(h)).(\lambda_g^H\xi)(h)=\xi(g^{-1}h), \qquad ((I\otimes T)\xi)(h)=T(\xi(h)).(3) Write ℬ(K)\mathcal B(K) for the bounded complex-linear operators on a Hilbert space KK. The reduced group C*C^*-algebra Cr*(G)C_r^*(G) is the norm closure of the complex **-algebra generated by the scalar left regular representation: Cr*(G)=alg⁡ℂ*{λgℂ:g∈G}¯∥⋅∥⊆ℬ(ℓ2(G,ℂ)).C_r^*(G)= \overline{\operatorname{alg}_{\mathbb C}^{*} \{\lambda_g^{\mathbb C}:g\in G\}}^{\|\cdot\|} \subseteq\mathcal B(\ell^2(G,\mathbb C)).(4)✦ The free group 𝔽2\mathbb F_2 is the free group on two generators, and Cr*(𝔽2)C_r^*(\mathbb F_2) is its reduced algebra from (4).

For a group GG and a unital complex **-representation ρ:D→ℬ(H)\rho:D\to\mathcal B(H), the concrete spatial tensor algebra Cr*(G)⊗minρ(D)C_r^*(G)\otimes_{\min}\rho(D) is the norm-closed complex **-subalgebra of ℬ(ℓ2(G,H))\mathcal B(\ell^2(G,H)) generated by the diagonal operators I⊗ρ(d)I\otimes\rho(d) for d∈Dd\in D and the left regular operators λgH\lambda_g^H for g∈Gg\in G.✦ For G=𝔽2G=\mathbb F_2, write TρT_\rho for this algebra, as in (5): Tρ=Cr*(𝔽2)⊗minρ(D):=alg⁡ℂ*({I⊗ρ(d):d∈D}∪{λgH:g∈𝔽2})¯∥⋅∥.T_\rho=C_r^*(\mathbb F_2)\otimes_{\min}\rho(D) :=\overline{\operatorname{alg}_{\mathbb C}^{*} \bigl(\{I\otimes\rho(d):d\in D\} \cup\{\lambda_g^H:g\in\mathbb F_2\}\bigr)}^{\|\cdot\|}.(5)✦

A tracial state τ\tau on DD is a positive complex-linear functional D→ℂD\to\mathbb C satisfying (6): τ(1)=1,τ(cd)=τ(dc)(c,d∈D).\tau(1)=1,\qquad \tau(cd)=\tau(dc)\quad(c,d\in D).(6)✦ Write TS⁡(D)\operatorname{TS}(D) for the set of tracial states on the unital complex C*C^*-algebra DD and QT⁡2(D)\operatorname{QT}_2(D) for the set of normalized 22-quasitraces on DD.

The Existence Conditions

The family 𝒮\mathcal S of simple tensor counterexamples consists of triples (M,H,ρ)(M,H,\rho), where MM is a nonzero unital simple stably finite complex C*C^*-algebra, HH is a complex Hilbert space, and ρ:M→ℬ(H)\rho:M\to\mathcal B(H) is a faithful unital **-representation with TρT_\rho properly infinite; membership also requires Cr*(𝔽2)C_r^*(\mathbb F_2) to be simple and stably finite.✦

The family 𝒬\mathcal Q of quasitrace loss examples consists of triples (D,H,ρ)(D,H,\rho), where DD is a nonzero separable unital complex C*C^*-algebra admitting a normalized 22-quasitrace, HH is a complex Hilbert space, and ρ:D→ℬ(H)\rho:D\to\mathcal B(H) is a faithful unital **-representation such that TρT_\rho is properly infinite and QT⁡2(Tρ)\operatorname{QT}_2(T_\rho) is empty.✦

The family 𝒯\mathcal T of traceless stably finite algebras consists of the nonzero separable unital stably finite complex C*C^*-algebras EE for which TS⁡(E)\operatorname{TS}(E) is empty.✦ The stable finiteness consequences are the joint existence of members of 𝒮\mathcal S, 𝒬\mathcal Q and 𝒯\mathcal T.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. The simple tensor counterexample condition (7), the quasitrace loss condition (8), and traceless stable finiteness (9) hold: 𝒮≠⌀.\mathcal S\ne\varnothing.(7)✦ 𝒬≠⌀.\mathcal Q\ne\varnothing.(8)✦ 𝒯≠⌀.\mathcal T\ne\varnothing.(9)✦ Their simultaneous existence is the stable finiteness corollary (10): 𝒮×𝒬×𝒯≠⌀.\mathcal S\times\mathcal Q\times\mathcal T\ne\varnothing.(10)✦

In the paper, the result reads: there are two unital simple stably finite complex C*C^*-algebras whose minimal tensor product is properly infinite, one factor being Cr*(𝔽2)C_r^*(\mathbb F_2); there is a separable unital complex C*C^*-algebra DD admitting a normalized 22-quasitrace such that D⊗minCr*(𝔽2)D\otimes_{\min}C_r^*(\mathbb F_2) is properly infinite and admits no normalized 22-quasitrace; and there is a separable unital stably finite complex C*C^*-algebra with no tracial state.

What Is Checked

The statements concern nonzero unital complex C*C^*-algebras, faithful unital **-representations on complex Hilbert spaces for the tensor examples, and the matrix condition (1) for stable finiteness. Reindexing preserves square summability: for a permutation ee of ι\iota and ξ∈ℓ2(ι,H)\xi\in\ell^2(\iota,H), the family i↦ξ(e(i))i\mapsto\xi(e(i)) is square-summable.✦