OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 Β· Lean results with no numbered counterpart

A free semicircular family generates a copy of L(F_Ξ±): The isomorphism is conjugation by a unitary onto the full Fock space, carries the trace to the vacuum state and is normal both ways

A free semicircular family generates a copy of L(𝔽α)L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha)..

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let Ξ±\alpha be a set and 𝔽α\mathbb{F}_\alpha the free group on Ξ±\alpha. On the full Fock space over β„“2(Ξ±)\ell^2(\alpha) the letters of Ξ±\alpha give a free semicircular family, one semicircular element for each letter. The question is whether the von Neumann algebra this family generates is a copy of L(𝔽α)L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha), and by which unitary from β„“2(𝔽α)\ell^2(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) onto the Fock space.

For one particular index set the library also presents this algebra by a second set of generators, built from a representation of C([0,1])C([0,1]) and from rotated combinations of creation operators and their adjoints.

The Fock Space and the Semicircular Family

For a set Ξ²\beta, β„“2(Ξ²)\ell^2(\beta) is the Hilbert space of square-summable complex functions on Ξ²\beta✦, and the basis vector Ξ΄b\delta_b of a point b∈βb\in\beta is the function equal to 11 at bb and to 00 elsewhere.✦ An injective map f:Ξ²β†’Ξ³f\colon\beta\to\gamma induces the isometry of β„“2(Ξ²)\ell^2(\beta) into β„“2(Ξ³)\ell^2(\gamma) that sends each Ξ΄b\delta_b to Ξ΄f(b)\delta_{f(b)}.✦ We write B(E)B(E) for the algebra of bounded operators on a Hilbert space EE.✦

The full Fock space β„±(Ξ±)\mathcal{F}(\alpha) over a set Ξ±\alpha is β„“2\ell^2 of the set of finite words in the letters of Ξ±\alpha, the empty word included; in its basis of words it is ⨁nβ‰₯0β„“2(Ξ±)βŠ—n\bigoplus_{n\ge0}\ell^2(\alpha)^{\otimes n}.✦ The vacuum vector Ξ©\Omega of β„±(Ξ±)\mathcal{F}(\alpha) is the basis vector of the empty word✦, and the vacuum state on B(β„±(Ξ±))B(\mathcal{F}(\alpha)) is the state Tβ†¦βŸ¨TΞ©,Ω⟩T\mapsto\langle T\Omega,\Omega\rangle✦. For a letter aa, the creation operator β„“(a)\ell(a) is the isometry of β„±(Ξ±)\mathcal{F}(\alpha) induced by the injection w↦aww\mapsto aw of words✦, and the semicircular element s(a)s(a) is the sum of β„“(a)\ell(a) and its adjoint: β„“(a)Ξ΄w=Ξ΄aw,s(a)=β„“(a)+β„“(a)*.\ell(a)\delta_w=\delta_{aw},\qquad s(a)=\ell(a)+\ell(a)^*.(1)✦

The Gaussian algebra Ξ“(Ξ±)\Gamma(\alpha) is the von Neumann algebra on β„±(Ξ±)\mathcal{F}(\alpha) generated by the semicircular family, the commutant of the Gaussian commutant {s(a):a∈α}β€²\{s(a):a\in\alpha\}': Ξ“(Ξ±)={s(a):a∈α}β€³βŠ†B(β„±(Ξ±)).\Gamma(\alpha)=\{s(a):a\in\alpha\}''\subseteq B(\mathcal{F}(\alpha)).(2)✦ The algebra Ξ“(Ξ±)\Gamma(\alpha) carries the ultraweak topology of B(β„±(Ξ±))B(\mathcal{F}(\alpha)).

Haar Unitaries

Let AA be a self-adjoint operator on a Hilbert space EE, with real spectrum Οƒ(A)\sigma(A). The continuous functional calculus of AA is the **-homomorphism g↦g(A)g\mapsto g(A) from the continuous complex functions on Οƒ(A)\sigma(A) to B(E)B(E).✦ For a vector ξ∈E\xi\in E, the spectral measure ΞΌA,ΞΎ\mu_{A,\xi} of AA in ΞΎ\xi is the measure on Οƒ(A)\sigma(A) that the Riesz representation theorem attaches to the positive functional fβ†¦βŸ¨f(A)ΞΎ,ξ⟩f\mapsto\langle f(A)\xi,\xi\rangle on the compactly supported real continuous functions on Οƒ(A)\sigma(A): ∫fdΞΌA,ΞΎ=⟨f(A)ΞΎ,ξ⟩.\int f\,d\mu_{A,\xi}=\langle f(A)\xi,\xi\rangle.(3)✦ The distribution function FA,ΞΎF_{A,\xi} of ΞΌA,ΞΎ\mu_{A,\xi}, viewed as a measure on ℝ\mathbb{R}, is the function on ℝ\mathbb{R} that gives to each real xx the measure of (βˆ’βˆž,x](-\infty,x]; it takes values in [0,1][0,1].

When ΞΌA,ΞΎ\mu_{A,\xi} has no atoms, FA,ΞΎF_{A,\xi} restricts to a continuous map of Οƒ(A)\sigma(A) into [0,1][0,1]✦, and the Haar unitary of AA in ΞΎ\xi is the function x↦e2Ο€iFA,ΞΎ(x)x\mapsto e^{2\pi\mathrm{i}F_{A,\xi}(x)} of AA: uA,ΞΎ=e2Ο€iFA,ΞΎ(A).u_{A,\xi}=e^{2\pi\mathrm{i}F_{A,\xi}(A)}.(4)✦

Let C([0,1])C([0,1]) be the C*^*-algebra of continuous complex functions on the unit interval.✦ The uniform representation of AA in ΞΎ\xi is the **-homomorphism f↦(f∘FA,ΞΎ)(A)f\mapsto(f\circ F_{A,\xi})(A) of C([0,1])C([0,1]) into B(E)B(E).✦

For a letter a∈αa\in\alpha, the spectral Haar unitary uau_a is the Haar unitary of s(a)s(a) in the vacuum vector Ξ©\Omega.✦ The Haar representation ρ\rho is the homomorphism of 𝔽α\mathbb{F}_\alpha into the unitary group of Ξ“(Ξ±)\Gamma(\alpha) with ρ(a)=ua\rho(a)=u_a for every generator aa✦; through the inclusion Ξ“(Ξ±)βŠ†B(β„±(Ξ±))\Gamma(\alpha)\subseteq B(\mathcal{F}(\alpha)) it is a unitary representation of 𝔽α\mathbb{F}_\alpha on β„±(Ξ±)\mathcal{F}(\alpha).✦

The Spatial Isomorphism

Let (xi)i∈I(x_i)_{i\in I} and (yi)i∈I(y_i)_{i\in I} be families of vectors in Hilbert spaces EE and Eβ€²E', each spanning a dense subspace, with equal Gram matrices: ⟨yi,yj⟩=⟨xi,xj⟩\langle y_i,y_j\rangle=\langle x_i,x_j\rangle for all i,j∈Ii,j\in I. The Gram spatial isomorphism of such families (xi)i∈I(x_i)_{i\in I} and (yi)i∈I(y_i)_{i\in I} is the unitary of EE onto Eβ€²E' that sends βˆ‘icixi\sum_ic_ix_i to βˆ‘iciyi\sum_ic_iy_i for every finitely supported family of scalars (ci)(c_i).✦

Let ΞΈ\theta be a unitary representation of a group GG on a Hilbert space EE, and ξ∈E\xi\in E a vector with ⟨θ(g)ΞΎ,ξ⟩\langle\theta(g)\xi,\xi\rangle equal to 11 for g=eg=e and to 00 otherwise, whose orbit {ΞΈ(g)ΞΎ:g∈G}\{\theta(g)\xi:g\in G\} spans a dense subspace of EE. The cyclic spatial isomorphism of ΞΈ\theta and ΞΎ\xi is the Gram spatial isomorphism of the basis (Ξ΄g)g∈G(\delta_g)_{g\in G} of β„“2(G)\ell^2(G) and the orbit (ΞΈ(g)ΞΎ)g∈G(\theta(g)\xi)_{g\in G}, the unitary of β„“2(G)\ell^2(G) onto EE with Ξ΄g↦θ(g)ΞΎ\delta_g\mapsto\theta(g)\xi.✦

The Haar spatial isomorphism U:β„“2(𝔽α)β†’β„±(Ξ±)U\colon\ell^2(\mathbb{F}_\alpha)\to\mathcal{F}(\alpha) is the cyclic spatial isomorphism of the Haar representation ρ\rho and the vacuum vector: UΞ΄g=ρ(g)Ξ©(gβˆˆπ”½Ξ±).U\delta_g=\rho(g)\Omega\qquad(g\in\mathbb{F}_\alpha).(5)✦

The group von Neumann algebra L(𝔽α)L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) on β„“2(𝔽α)\ell^2(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) carries the trace Ο„(T)=⟨TΞ΄e,Ξ΄e⟩\tau(T)=\langle T\delta_e,\delta_e\rangle and its ultraweak topology. Conjugation by UU is a **-isomorphism of B(β„“2(𝔽α))B(\ell^2(\mathbb{F}_\alpha)) onto B(β„±(Ξ±))B(\mathcal{F}(\alpha)), and the Gaussian group isomorphism Ξ¦:L(𝔽α)β†’Ξ“(Ξ±)\Phi\colon L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha)\to\Gamma(\alpha) is its restriction to L(𝔽α)L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha): Ξ¦(T)=UTU*(T∈L(𝔽α)).\Phi(T)=UTU^*\qquad(T\in L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha)).(6)✦

A Second Presentation

Let π’œ\mathcal{A} be a complex **-algebra, EE a Hilbert space, II an index set and cc a covariance on II, which assigns to indices i,j∈Ii,j\in I a map a↦c(i,j,a)a\mapsto c(i,j,a) of π’œ\mathcal{A} into itself. A Gaussian recognition system for cc on EE consists of a unital **-homomorphism Ο€:π’œβ†’B(E)\pi\colon\mathcal{A}\to B(E), the coefficient map, a root vector ΞΎ0∈E\xi_0\in E, and a creation operator β„“i∈B(E)\ell_i\in B(E) for each i∈Ii\in I, subject to the contraction and annihilation rules β„“i*Ο€(a)β„“j=Ο€(c(i,j,a)),β„“i*Ο€(a)ΞΎ0=0(i,j∈I,aβˆˆπ’œ).\ell_i^*\pi(a)\ell_j=\pi\bigl(c(i,j,a)\bigr),\qquad\ell_i^*\pi(a)\xi_0=0 \qquad(i,j\in I,\ a\in\mathcal{A}).(7)✦

For a Gaussian recognition system as above and a map Οƒ:Iβ†’I\sigma\colon I\to I, the von Neumann algebra WΟƒW_\sigma generated by the system with Οƒ\sigma is the double commutant of the set formed by the operators Ο€(a)\pi(a) for aβˆˆπ’œa\in\mathcal{A} and the operators β„“i+β„“Οƒ(i)*\ell_i+\ell_{\sigma(i)}^* for i∈Ii\in I: WΟƒ=(Ο€(π’œ)βˆͺ{β„“i+β„“Οƒ(i)*:i∈I})β€³.W_\sigma=\bigl(\pi(\mathcal{A})\cup\{\ell_i+\ell_{\sigma(i)}^*:i\in I\}\bigr)''.(8)✦

The self indices form the set S=β„•βŠ”{0,1}βŠ”{0,1}S=\mathbb{N}\sqcup\{0,1\}\sqcup\{0,1\}✦, and the pair indices the set P=β„•βŠ”{0,1,2}P=\mathbb{N}\sqcup\{0,1,2\}✦. The set KK of weighted corner indices is the set SβŠ”(PΓ—{0,1})S\sqcup(P\times\{0,1\}), in which each self index is one index and each pair index pp gives two, (p,0)(p,0) and (p,1)(p,1).✦ The flip of KK is the involution k↦kβ€Ύk\mapsto\bar k of KK that fixes SS and sends (p,b)(p,b) to (p,1βˆ’b)(p,1-b).✦

The circular rotation RΜƒ\tilde R of a family RR of elements of a complex algebra indexed by KK is the family indexed by KK that agrees with RR on SS and takes on each pair index pp the values RΜƒ(p,0)=R(p,0)+iR(p,1)2,RΜƒ(p,1)=R(p,0)βˆ’iR(p,1)2.\tilde R(p,0)=\frac{R(p,0)+\mathrm{i}R(p,1)}{\sqrt2},\qquad \tilde R(p,1)=\frac{R(p,0)-\mathrm{i}R(p,1)}{\sqrt2}.(9)✦

The scalar generator index set is Isc=(KΓ—β„•)βŠ”{*}I_{\mathrm{sc}}=(K\times\mathbb{N})\sqcup\{\ast\}: the pairs (k,n)(k,n) of a weighted corner index and a natural number, with one extra point *\ast adjoined.✦ The scalar flip of KΓ—β„•K\times\mathbb{N} is the map (k,n)↦(kβ€Ύ,n)(k,n)\mapsto(\bar k,n).✦ For (k,n)∈KΓ—β„•(k,n)\in K\times\mathbb{N}, the rotated creation operator β„“Μƒ(k,n)\tilde\ell(k,n) on β„±(Isc)\mathcal{F}(I_{\mathrm{sc}}) is the value at kk of the circular rotation of the family j↦ℓ(j,n)j\mapsto\ell(j,n) of creation operators.✦

The Lebesgue state on C([0,1])C([0,1]) is Ο„0(f)=∫01f(x)dx\tau_0(f)=\int_0^1f(x)\,dx✦, and the uniform covariance on an index set JJ is the covariance with c(i,j,f)=Ο„0(f)1c(i,j,f)=\tau_0(f)1 for i=ji=j and c(i,j,f)=0c(i,j,f)=0 for iβ‰ ji\ne j, where i,j∈Ji,j\in J✦.

The scalar Gaussian system is the Gaussian recognition system over C([0,1])C([0,1]) on β„±(Isc)\mathcal{F}(I_{\mathrm{sc}}) for the uniform covariance on KΓ—β„•K\times\mathbb{N}, with coefficient map Ο€\pi the uniform representation of s(*)s(\ast) in Ξ©\Omega, a unital **-homomorphism of C([0,1])C([0,1]) into B(β„±(Isc))B(\mathcal{F}(I_{\mathrm{sc}})), with root vector Ξ©\Omega, and with the rotated creation operators as its creation operators.✦ The von Neumann algebra MscM_{\mathrm{sc}} generated by the scalar Gaussian system with the scalar flip is the Gaussian algebra Ξ“(Isc)\Gamma(I_{\mathrm{sc}}). The scalar group isomorphism Ξ¨:L(𝔽Isc)β†’Msc\Psi\colon L(\mathbb{F}_{I_{\mathrm{sc}}})\to M_{\mathrm{sc}} is the Gaussian group isomorphism Ξ¦\Phi for Ξ±=Isc\alpha=I_{\mathrm{sc}}, whose range is MscM_{\mathrm{sc}}.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let Ξ±\alpha be a set and Ξ¦\Phi the Gaussian group isomorphism of L(𝔽α)L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) onto Ξ“(Ξ±)\Gamma(\alpha).✦ Then every T∈L(𝔽α)T\in L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) satisfies ⟨Φ(T)Ξ©,Ω⟩=Ο„(T),\langle\Phi(T)\Omega,\Omega\rangle=\tau(T),(10)✦ and the map Ξ¦:L(𝔽α)β†’Ξ“(Ξ±)\Phi\colon L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha)\to\Gamma(\alpha)(11)✦ and its inverse Ξ¦βˆ’1:Ξ“(Ξ±)β†’L(𝔽α)\Phi^{-1}\colon\Gamma(\alpha)\to L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha)(12)✦ are continuous for the ultraweak topologies. For the scalar generator index set IscI_{\mathrm{sc}}, the scalar group isomorphism Ξ¨:L(𝔽Isc)β†’Msc\Psi\colon L(\mathbb{F}_{I_{\mathrm{sc}}})\to M_{\mathrm{sc}} satisfies, for every T∈L(𝔽Isc)T\in L(\mathbb{F}_{I_{\mathrm{sc}}}), ⟨Ψ(T)Ξ©,Ω⟩=Ο„(T).\langle\Psi(T)\Omega,\Omega\rangle=\tau(T).(13)✦

So the von Neumann algebra generated by the free semicircular family indexed by Ξ±\alpha, with its vacuum state, is a copy of L(𝔽α)L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) with its trace, under an isomorphism of tracial von Neumann algebras.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the group von Neumann algebra L(𝔽α)L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) of the free group on an arbitrary set Ξ±\alpha, with its trace and its ultraweak topology, and the Gaussian algebra Ξ“(Ξ±)\Gamma(\alpha) on the full Fock space, with the vacuum state and the ultraweak topology of B(β„±(Ξ±))B(\mathcal{F}(\alpha)), the isomorphism between them being conjugation by the Haar spatial isomorphism UU of (5); in (13) the index set is IscI_{\mathrm{sc}} and the target is the algebra MscM_{\mathrm{sc}} generated by the scalar Gaussian system.

About these constructions the library proves that every semicircular element s(a)s(a) is self-adjoint✦ with a spectral measure in Ξ©\Omega that has no atoms✦, and that every spectral Haar unitary uau_a lies in Ξ“(Ξ±)\Gamma(\alpha).✦ For every gβˆˆπ”½Ξ±g\in\mathbb{F}_\alpha the Haar representation satisfies ρ(g)*=ρ(gβˆ’1),⟨ρ(g)Ξ©,Ω⟩={1,g=e,0,gβ‰ e,\rho(g)^*=\rho(g^{-1}),\qquad \langle\rho(g)\Omega,\Omega\rangle= \begin{cases}1,&g=e,\\0,&g\ne e,\end{cases}(14) and the vectors ρ(g)Ξ©\rho(g)\Omega span a dense subspace of β„±(Ξ±)\mathcal{F}(\alpha).✦ An operator TT on β„“2(𝔽α)\ell^2(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) lies in L(𝔽α)L(\mathbb{F}_\alpha) exactly when UTU*UTU^* lies in Ξ“(Ξ±)\Gamma(\alpha).✦ In the second presentation, the adjoint of every rotated creation operator annihilates every vector Ο€(f)Ξ©\pi(f)\Omega with f∈C([0,1])f\in C([0,1]).✦ Moreover the rotated creation operators satisfy the contraction rule β„“Μƒi*Ο€(f)β„“Μƒj=Ο„0(f)1\tilde\ell_i^*\pi(f)\tilde\ell_j=\tau_0(f)1 for i=ji=j and β„“Μƒi*Ο€(f)β„“Μƒj=0\tilde\ell_i^*\pi(f)\tilde\ell_j=0 for iβ‰ ji\ne j, for all f∈C([0,1])f\in C([0,1]), where Ο„0\tau_0 is the Lebesgue state.