OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. Amplification to rank two · §6

Corollary 6.1 [All interpolated free group factors are isomorphic]: For 1<r,s≤∞1 < r, s \le \infty, the interpolated free group factors NrN_r and NsN_s are isomorphic tracial factors, and each NrN_r has fundamental group ℝ>0\mathbb{R}_{>0}

The interpolated free group factors are all isomorphic.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For n∈ℕn \in \mathbb{N}, let FnF_n be the free group on nn generators and F∞F_\infty the free group on ℕ\mathbb{N}. The free group factors L(Fn)L(F_n), n≥2n \ge 2, and L(F∞)L(F_\infty) sit in a one-parameter family of II1_1 factors, the interpolated free group factors L(Fr)L(F_r), 1<r≤∞1 < r \le \infty, of Dykema and Rădulescu. Two questions are asked of the family: whether L(Fr)≅L(Fs)L(F_r) \cong L(F_s) for r≠sr \ne s, and for which t>0t > 0 the amplification L(Fr)tL(F_r)^t is isomorphic to L(Fr)L(F_r), the set of such tt being the fundamental group ℱ(L(Fr))\mathcal{F}(L(F_r)).

Group Factors and Their Amplifications

For a group GG with identity ee, and δg\delta_g the basis vector of ℓ2(G)\ell^2(G) at g∈Gg \in G, the group von Neumann algebra L(G)L(G) is the double commutant of the left translations on ℓ2(G)\ell^2(G), with its ultraweak topology and the trace τ(x)=⟨xδe,δe⟩,x∈L(G).\tau(x) = \langle x\,\delta_e, \delta_e \rangle, \qquad x \in L(G).(1) An isomorphism of tracial von Neumann algebras (M,τM)(M, \tau_M) and (N,τN)(N, \tau_N) is a **-isomorphism Φ:M→N\Phi \colon M \to N with τN∘Φ=τM\tau_N \circ \Phi = \tau_M that is continuous for the ultraweak topologies in both directions; M≅NM \cong N says that there is one.

The stabilization L(G)∞L(G)_\infty of L(G)L(G), standing for L(G)⊗‾B(ℓ2)L(G) \mathbin{\bar\otimes} B(\ell^2), is the commutant of the right translations of GG acting on ℓ2(ℕ×G)\ell^2(\mathbb{N} \times G), with its ultraweak topology. Its trace Tr\mathrm{Tr} takes on a projection pp the value Tr(p)=∑k∈ℕ∥pδ(k,e)∥2∈[0,∞].\mathrm{Tr}(p) = \sum_{k \in \mathbb{N}} \| p\,\delta_{(k,e)} \|^2 \in [0, \infty].(2)

Let t>0t > 0 and let pp be a projection of L(G)∞L(G)_\infty with Tr(p)=t\mathrm{Tr}(p) = t. The amplification L(G)tL(G)^t of L(G)L(G) by tt at pp is the corner pL(G)∞ppL(G)_\infty p, with the ultraweak topology of L(G)∞L(G)_\infty restricted to it and the trace τp(x)=t−1Tr(x),x∈pL(G)∞p.\tau_p(x) = t^{-1}\,\mathrm{Tr}(x), \qquad x \in pL(G)_\infty p.(3) For a second group HH, an amplification isomorphism of L(G)tL(G)^t onto L(H)L(H) is a **-isomorphism Φ\Phi of pL(G)∞ppL(G)_\infty p onto L(H)L(H) with τ∘Φ=τp\tau \circ \Phi = \tau_p that is continuous from the restricted ultraweak topology to the ultraweak topology of L(H)L(H).✦

A **-algebra AA with a trace τ\tau and a topology has a corner scaling by a real number tt when AA contains a projection pp with τ(p)=t\tau(p) = t and a **-isomorphism ee of AA onto the corner pAppAp, continuous with continuous inverse for the topology of AA and its restriction to pAppAp, such that τ(e(x))=tτ(x),x∈A.\tau(e(x)) = t\,\tau(x), \qquad x \in A.(4)✦

Let a>0a > 0 and let pp be a projection of L(G)∞L(G)_\infty with Tr(p)=a\mathrm{Tr}(p) = a. The infinite repeat p(∞)p^{(\infty)} of pp is the projection 1⊗p1 \otimes p on ℓ2(ℕ)⊗ℓ2(ℕ×G)=ℓ2(ℕ×ℕ×G)\ell^2(\mathbb{N}) \otimes \ell^2(\mathbb{N} \times G) = \ell^2(\mathbb{N} \times \mathbb{N} \times G), carried to ℓ2(ℕ×G)\ell^2(\mathbb{N} \times G) by the relabeling (m,n,g)↦(π(m,n),g)(m, n, g) \mapsto (\pi(m, n), g) along the standard pairing π\pi of ℕ×ℕ\mathbb{N} \times \mathbb{N} onto ℕ\mathbb{N}; it lies in L(G)∞L(G)_\infty. The corner of stabilization at pp is the corner p(∞)L(G)∞p(∞)p^{(\infty)} L(G)_\infty\, p^{(\infty)}, a copy of pL(G)∞p⊗‾B(ℓ2)pL(G)_\infty p \mathbin{\bar\otimes} B(\ell^2), with the restricted ultraweak topology and the trace a−1Tra^{-1}\,\mathrm{Tr}.✦

The Interpolated Factors

For rr in [0,∞][0, \infty] with r>1r > 1, the interpolated free group factor NrN_r is Nr={L(Fn)if r=n∈ℕ,L(F∞)if r=∞,L(F2)a,a=(r−1)−1/2,otherwise,N_r = \begin{cases} L(F_n) & \text{if } r = n \in \mathbb{N}, \\ L(F_\infty) & \text{if } r = \infty, \\ L(F_2)^{a}, \quad a = (r - 1)^{-1/2}, & \text{otherwise}, \end{cases}(5) the amplification in the last case being taken at a projection of trace aa in L(F2)∞L(F_2)_\infty chosen once for each aa.

A model mm of an interpolated factor is of one of three kinds, each with its factor NmN_m: an integer model nn, with Nm=L(Fn)N_m = L(F_n); a continuous model rr, for a real number rr, with Nm=L(F2)aN_m = L(F_2)^a and a=(r−1)−1/2a = (r - 1)^{-1/2} as in (5); and the infinite model, with Nm=L(F∞)N_m = L(F_\infty). A model is valid when n≥2n \ge 2, when r>1r > 1, or always, according to its kind.✦ The model of NrN_r is the integer model nn at r=nr = n, the infinite model at r=∞r = \infty and the continuous model rr otherwise.

The factor NmN_m carries its trace τm\tau_m and its ultraweak topology. The stabilization (Nm)∞(N_m)_\infty of NmN_m, standing for Nm⊗‾B(ℓ2)N_m \mathbin{\bar\otimes} B(\ell^2), is L(Fn)∞L(F_n)_\infty with the trace Tr\mathrm{Tr} for the integer model nn, L(F∞)∞L(F_\infty)_\infty with the trace Tr\mathrm{Tr} for the infinite model, and, for a continuous model, the corner of stabilization of L(F2)∞L(F_2)_\infty at the chosen projection of trace aa, with the trace a−1Tra^{-1}\,\mathrm{Tr}. Write Trm\mathrm{Tr}_m for this trace of (Nm)∞(N_m)_\infty, with values in [0,∞][0, \infty] on projections. The stabilization (Nm)∞(N_m)_\infty carries its ultraweak topology: that of L(Fn)∞L(F_n)_\infty for the integer model nn, that of L(F∞)∞L(F_\infty)_\infty for the infinite model, and, for a continuous model, the topology the corner of stabilization of L(F2)∞L(F_2)_\infty at the chosen projection inherits from the ultraweak topology of L(F2)∞L(F_2)_\infty.

For t>0t > 0 and a projection pp of (Nm)∞(N_m)_\infty with Trm(p)=t\mathrm{Tr}_m(p) = t, the amplification NmtN_m^t at pp is the corner p(Nm)∞pp(N_m)_\infty p with the trace t−1Trmt^{-1}\,\mathrm{Tr}_m and the restricted ultraweak topology. The fundamental group of NmN_m is ℱ(Nm)={t>0:Nmt≅Nm at some projection p∈(Nm)∞ with Trm(p)=t},\mathcal{F}(N_m) = \{\, t > 0 : N_m^t \cong N_m \text{ at some projection } p \in (N_m)_\infty \text{ with } \mathrm{Tr}_m(p) = t \,\},(6)✦ and ℱ(Nr)\mathcal{F}(N_r) is the fundamental group of the factor of the model of NrN_r.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let rr and ss lie in (1,∞](1, \infty]. Then the interpolated free group factors NrN_r and NsN_s are isomorphic as tracial von Neumann algebras, Nr≅Ns,N_r \cong N_s,(7)✦ and the fundamental group of NrN_r is the set of all positive reals, ℱ(Nr)=ℝ>0.\mathcal{F}(N_r) = \mathbb{R}_{>0}.(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for all 1<r,s≤∞1 < r, s \le \infty there is a unital normal trace-preserving **-isomorphism L(Fr)≅L(Fs)L(F_r) \cong L(F_s), and moreover ℱ(L(Fr))=ℝ>0\mathcal{F}(L(F_r)) = \mathbb{R}_{>0} for 1<r≤∞1 < r \le \infty, its L(Fr)L(F_r) being the page’s NrN_r.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the interpolated factors NrN_r of (5), with their traces and ultraweak topologies, and over the fundamental group (6) of the model of each.

For every valid model mm, the continuous models at integer parameters included, the library also shows that the factor NmN_m is isomorphic to L(F2)L(F_2) and to the factor of any other valid model m′m', Nm≅L(F2),N_m \cong L(F_2),(9)✦ Nm≅Nm′,N_m \cong N_{m'},(10)✦ and that its fundamental group is ℝ>0\mathbb{R}_{>0}, ℱ(Nm)=ℝ>0.\mathcal{F}(N_m) = \mathbb{R}_{>0}.(11)✦ For every t>0t > 0 the stabilization (Nm)∞(N_m)_\infty has a projection pp with Trm(p)=t,\mathrm{Tr}_m(p) = t,(12)✦ and at every such projection the amplification is isomorphic to the factor, Nmt≅Nmat every projection p∈(Nm)∞ with Trm(p)=t.N_m^t \cong N_m \qquad \text{at every projection } p \in (N_m)_\infty \text{ with } \mathrm{Tr}_m(p) = t.(13)✦

The factor L(F∞)L(F_\infty), with its trace and ultraweak topology, has a corner scaling by every tt with 0<t≤10 < t \le 1, L(F∞) has a corner scaling by t,0<t≤1,L(F_\infty) \text{ has a corner scaling by } t, \qquad 0 < t \le 1,(14)✦ and for every t>0t > 0 its stabilization has a projection of trace tt, at every one of which the amplification is isomorphic to L(F∞)L(F_\infty): Tr(p)=t for some projection p∈L(F∞)∞,L(F∞)t≅L(F∞) at every such p.\mathrm{Tr}(p) = t \text{ for some projection } p \in L(F_\infty)_\infty, \qquad L(F_\infty)^t \cong L(F_\infty) \text{ at every such } p.(15)✦

Let GG be a group whose von Neumann algebra L(G)L(G) is a factor, its only elements commuting with all of L(G)L(G) being the scalar multiples of 11, and has a corner scaling by every t∈(0,1]t \in (0, 1]. Then for every t>0t > 0, Tr(p)=t for some projection p∈L(G)∞,L(G)t≅L(G) at every such p.\mathrm{Tr}(p) = t \text{ for some projection } p \in L(G)_\infty, \qquad L(G)^t \cong L(G) \text{ at every such } p.(16)✦ For the free group of rank two the same holds at every t>0t > 0, Tr(p)=t for some projection p∈L(F2)∞,L(F2)t≅L(F2) at every such p,\mathrm{Tr}(p) = t \text{ for some projection } p \in L(F_2)_\infty, \qquad L(F_2)^t \cong L(F_2) \text{ at every such } p,(17)✦ and at every projection pp of L(F2)∞L(F_2)_\infty with Tr(p)=t>0\mathrm{Tr}(p) = t > 0 there is an amplification isomorphism of L(F2)tL(F_2)^t onto L(F2)L(F_2): Φ:pL(F2)∞p→L(F2),τ∘Φ=τp,Φ ultraweakly continuous.\Phi \colon pL(F_2)_\infty p \to L(F_2), \qquad \tau \circ \Phi = \tau_p, \qquad \Phi \text{ ultraweakly continuous}.(18)✦

Let GG be a group with L(G)t≅L(G)L(G)^t \cong L(G) at every projection of L(G)∞L(G)_\infty of trace tt, for every t>0t > 0. Let a>0a > 0, let pp be a projection of L(G)∞L(G)_\infty with Tr(p)=a\mathrm{Tr}(p) = a, and let qq be a projection of the corner of stabilization at pp with a−1Tr(q)=t>0a^{-1}\,\mathrm{Tr}(q) = t > 0. Then the corner at qq, with the trace (at)−1Tr(at)^{-1}\,\mathrm{Tr}, is isomorphic to L(G)aL(G)^a at pp: (L(G)a)t≅L(G)a.(L(G)^a)^t \cong L(G)^a.(19)✦

For groups GG and HH, write L(G)≃L(H)L(G) \simeq L(H) for the library’s relation of normal tracial isomorphism between group von Neumann algebras. For every n≥2n \ge 2, L(Fn)≃L(F2),L(F_n) \simeq L(F_2),(20)✦ and the relation yields an isomorphism of tracial von Neumann algebras: L(G)≃L(H)⟹L(G)≅L(H).L(G) \simeq L(H) \implies L(G) \cong L(H).(21)✦