The Setting
Let be a set, for the counterexample the countable set of pairs with , and let be a matroid on , where and are the left and the right copy of . The ground set is spread over a double ray whose vertices are the integers and whose edges are the bundles , the bundle joining to ; the central bundle is , between and . For , the vertices of class are the integers congruent to modulo , and is their set.✦
At a vertex the inward bundle, toward , is , and the outward bundle is , where (1)✦ The placement of at is the map that puts on the inward and on the outward bundle at : (2)✦
For each class , the map given by is a bijection.✦ The ray matroid of is the matroid on that is the image under of the direct sum of copies of , one for each vertex of class : (3)✦
The question is whether has an independent cover by and : a set and a set with , where is the family of independent sets of a matroid .
Let be an ultrafilter on and a rank assigning to each subset of an ordinal below , the continuum taken as its initial ordinal. A subset of is large when it belongs to .
Slices and the Rank Step
The left slice and the right slice of a set are the subsets of given by (4)
The independent sets of satisfy a rank step: if a set is independent in and its left slice is large, then (5)✦
The Parts at the Vertices
The part of a set at a vertex is the subset of that places in when is even and outside when is odd: (6)✦ The slices of at are the slices and of this part.✦
The double ray has a right ray, with the vertices , and a left ray, with the vertices ; on each ray the th vertex , for , is on the right ray and on the left ray, so that each ray is numbered outward from the central bundle.✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let , and be as above, and let and be the ray matroids of . If a set is independent in , then (7)✦ If a set is independent in and a set is independent in , then (8)✦
In the paper, the result reads: an independent covering by and gives an independent partition, at each vertex the assigned elements are independent in the copy , and, starting from the large side of the central bundle and moving outward, , an infinite descending sequence of ordinals, with , and the paper’s sets along the ray.
What Is Checked
The claim is stated over an arbitrary set , a matroid on with an ultrafilter on and a rank , and the ray matroids (3) of , built through the placements (2) and the bijections .
About the parts at the vertices: if is independent in and is independent in , then (9)✦
For every set , the slices at the two ends of the central bundle satisfy (10)✦ and those at the two ends of the bundle between and , on either ray and for every , satisfy (11)✦