Proposition 4.6 concerns two families of subsets of attached to a subset of , the local lower rule and the local upper rule, whose members lie in the class of , and asks where their members fall relative to an interval of subsets of , according to how and compare with modulo .
The Setting
The ground set is .✦ Here is the countable set of pairs with and , and the left copy and the right copy of in are the pairs with second entry false and true respectively. The block of has elements✦, and the doubled block is the finite subset of made of both copies of ✦.
For a subset of and , the density of in is .✦ The ideal is the family of subsets of whose density in tends to : (1)✦ A subset of is positive when is not in . A subset of lies in the class of a subset of when the symmetric difference is in .✦
For subsets of , the interval is the family of subsets of with . A subset of is an outcome for when (2)✦ A family of subsets of meets the interval when some member of is an outcome for .
The Probes and the Local Rules
The probes compare a subset of with a fixed subset of . For the prefix has elements.✦ The density difference is the density of in minus that of ✦, and the prefix count difference is ✦. The probe and its lower limit , taken in the extended reals, are (3)
The local lower rule at is the family of subsets of in the class of whose lower limit lies in : (4)✦ The local upper rule at is the family of subsets of whose complement lies in the local lower rule at : (5)✦ For a Boolean , the local rule is when is true and when is false.✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a Boolean, let be a subset of such that and are positive, and let be subsets of . If one of the conditions (6)✦ (7)✦ (8)✦ holds, then meets . If is positive and lies in the class of , then some satisfies (9)✦ and if is positive and lies in the class of , then some satisfies (10)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for and , if or , then some satisfies , or , or , with and in place of false and true.
What Is Checked
The claim is stated over the ground set with its doubled blocks , the ideal of (1) and the classes modulo it, the probes relative to with their lower limit , the local rules of (4) and (5) chosen by , and the outcomes of (2).
The local lower rule has two further properties. Let , and be subsets of with in the class of and positive. If is disjoint from and , then some satisfies (11)✦ and if and , then some satisfies (12)✦