The Setting
Fix a subset of , the union of two copies of the countable set of pairs with a Boolean function on . The density-zero class of is the family of subsets of that differ from by a set of density zero in the doubled blocks , the finite pieces into which is cut. On every subset of the probe , for , compares with , by a count on the first doubled blocks and by densities on the blocks from on.
Take two sets in the class and the sets with . The theorem below settles whether every such lies in the class, and, for a given and , how many initial blocks of one must know to know to within . The second question is one of continuity for the product topology on the subsets of , in which two sets are close when they agree on a long run of initial blocks, and with it come limits of the probes along decreasing sequences of sets between and .
Density Zero and the Probes
For , the block is the finite subset of of the pairs with first entry , and it has elements.✦ Write for the copies of marked and ; the doubled block is the finite subset of lying over .✦
For a finite subset of a set and a subset of , the trace of on is the finite set ✦, and the density of in is the real number ✦. The block density of a set at is its density in .✦ A subset of has density zero when its block density tends to , (1)✦ and the sets of density zero form the ideal .
Two subsets and of are equivalent modulo when their symmetric difference lies in .✦ The class of is (2)
The probes relative to are built on prefixes. For , the prefix is the finite subset of formed by the first doubled blocks, and .✦ For , the prefix count difference compares with on ✦, and the density difference compares their block densities at : (3)✦ The probe is the real function on all subsets of that adds to the number times the sum of the tail supremum and the tail infimum of the sequence of density differences from on: (4)✦
Cylinder Continuity
The labelling is a fixed bijection.✦ For , the probe on is the real function on the subsets of obtained by transporting along the labelling : (5)✦
For sets and , the interval is the family of the sets with . Two subsets and of agree below when .✦ A family of real functions on the subsets of is cylinder-continuous on an interval of subsets of when for every and every there is an with (6)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let , and be subsets of with , and let be the probes (4) relative to . Then for every subset of , (7)✦ For every and every there is an such that all with satisfy (8)✦ Under the labelling , (9)✦ If a family of real functions on the subsets of is cylinder-continuous on an interval , and are sets in , then for every , (10)✦
In the paper, the result reads: if for all with and the sets converge pointwise to , then and for every fixed .
What Is Checked
The claims (7), (8), (9) and (10) are stated over subsets , and of with and in the class of modulo the ideal of sets of density zero in the doubled blocks , over the probes built from the prefixes , the counts and the tail supremum and infimum of the density differences , and over the labelling of by and cylinder continuity on intervals of subsets of .