The Setting
Take a normalized pencil defined by positive unital linear maps on real symmetric matrices and a unit vector . Evaluating kernel projections along unit-sphere curves through in orthogonal directions compares the Choi-Lam biquadratic form with Euclidean operator norms of difference quotients, posing the problem of obtaining a linear tangent norm identity at .
Normalized Pencils and Kernel Projections
For natural numbers and , let denote -dimensional real Euclidean space with inner product and Euclidean norm , and write for the space of real matrices (square matrices of order when ). Denote by the subspace of real symmetric matrices with identity matrix (written when specifying the order), where means is positive semidefinite and means is positive definite.✦ For any , the Euclidean operator norm is the operator norm of the linear map defined by with respect to the Euclidean norms.✦
For a vector , the symmetric outer product of with itself is the matrix in whose entry in row and column (for ) is . For a square matrix , the kernel projection is the matrix representing the orthogonal projection of onto .✦
For , the quadratic matrix is the matrix in whose entry in row and column (with indices taken cyclically in ) is when and when .✦ For , the Choi-Lam form is the biquadratic polynomial .✦ For , the matrix map is the linear map sending each block matrix (with , , and ) to (1): (1)✦
A normalized pencil with positive integer dimensions consists of linear maps , , and such that and are positive (mapping positive semidefinite matrices to positive semidefinite matrices) and unital ( and ), and satisfies the Schur-complement equivalence (2): for all with and all , (2)✦
Given a normalized pencil with dimensions and vectors , the left kernel projection of at and the right kernel projection of at are the orthogonal projection matrices in and defined by (3): (3)
Tangent Curves and Difference Quotients
For vectors and in with and , the wedge coordinates of and is the vector in given by .✦ For any , the tangent space is the linear subspace of given by (4): (4)✦
The spherical tangent curve of vectors is defined at each parameter by (5): (5)✦
Let have norm and take . Then for every , the curve satisfies (6): (6)✦ For any vectors , the curve is differentiable at , with derivative (7): (7)✦ For any vectors and in and every , setting , the wedge coordinates satisfy (8): (8)✦
Given a normalized pencil with dimensions , take with and . Then for every and every with , the difference quotient satisfies (9): (9)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a normalized pencil with dimensions . Then there exist a unit vector with and a linear map such that, for every and every , (10)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for , defining and and passing to the limit in the operator-norm identity yields for all and , where stands for , for , and is the differential of at .
What Is Checked
The tangent norm identity (10) and the preceding claims are stated over Euclidean spaces , square matrices, real symmetric matrices , the outer product and symmetric outer product , wedge coordinates, the quadratic matrix , the Choi-Lam form , the matrix map , kernel projections, the Euclidean operator norm, the tangent space , spherical tangent curves , and a normalized pencil with positive dimensions whose positive unital linear maps and and coupling map satisfy the Schur-complement equivalence, together with its left and right kernel projections and . It also holds that for a unit vector and an orthogonal direction , the spherical tangent curve has unit norm for all , has derivative at , and satisfies the wedge coordinate identity (8), while the difference quotient of right kernel projections along the curve satisfies (9) for every nonzero parameter and every .