The Setting
Consider the closed hyperbolicity cone in the -dimensional space of pairs of real symmetric matrices and a three-dimensional real vector, defined by an explicit determinantal polynomial around the base point formed by two identity matrices and zero. Suppose this cone is spectrahedral, meaning it is cut out by a finite homogeneous linear matrix inequality in real symmetric matrices. The question is what normalized block structure any such linear pencil representation must yield, and how the slice where the first matrix block is positive definite is captured by a Schur-complement equivalence.
The Ambient Space and Hyperbolicity Cone
For nonnegative integers and and a set , write for the set of matrices with entries in , and write for the subspace of real symmetric matrices. A square real matrix satisfies when is positive semidefinite and when is positive definite. For each nonnegative integer , write for the identity matrix. The ambient vector space is the -dimensional product of triples ✦, and the base point is the triple .
Over a commutative ring , for a triple indexed cyclically by (so ), the quadratic matrix is the matrix whose entry for is (1)✦
Given a triple over a commutative ring , the matrix map is the linear map sending each matrix written in block form , with , , and , to (2)✦ where is given by (1) and denotes the trace.
The determinantal formula assigns to matrices and a triple over a commutative ring the scalar (3)✦ using the matrix map (2), where denotes the adjugate matrix of . Evaluating (3) at generic coordinate indeterminates for the real coordinates of defines the real multivariate polynomial on .✦
For a point , the univariate restriction at is the real univariate polynomial .✦ The closed hyperbolicity cone is the subset of points such that every complex root of the univariate restriction at is real and nonnegative.✦
Block Pencils and Normalized Pencils
A linear map , for a positive integer , is positive if whenever in , and unital if .
With a subset, a block pencil for is a tuple consisting of integers , positive unital linear maps and , and linear maps , , , , and such that, for all , if and only if (4)✦
Given a block pencil for , the scaled pencil at and is the block matrix (5)✦
The limit pencil associated with a block pencil for at is the block matrix (6)✦
A normalized pencil is a tuple consisting of integers , positive unital linear maps and , and a linear map satisfying the Schur-complement equivalence: for all with and all , (7)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Suppose is an integer and is a linear map such that . Then (8)✦
Suppose a subset satisfies the zero-slice condition that if and only if and for all , lies in the interior of , and for an integer and a linear map . Then there exist an integer and a linear map such that (9)✦ Suppose a subset satisfies the zero-slice condition, and is a linear map for an integer satisfying (9). Then (10)✦
Let be a subset and let be a block pencil for such that, for all with and all , if and only if . Then for every , (11)✦ for all with , all , and every nonzero , (12)✦ for all with and all , (13)✦ and (14)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for with , if admits a representation by a finite homogeneous real symmetric linear pencil, then there exist integers , positive linear maps and with and , and a linear map such that for every in , every , and every . In (8), forms a normalized pencil, and the statement decomposes on a general subset into the zero-slice claims (9) and (10) and the slice-hypothesis claims (11) through (14) via a block pencil, its scaled pencil at , and its limit pencil.
What Is Checked
The claim (8) is stated over the closed hyperbolicity cone defined from and , a real symmetric linear pencil on , and normalized pencils (7), while (9) through (14) are stated over a subset under the zero-slice condition or the slice condition for , real symmetric linear pencils with in the interior of or positive-definite value at , and block pencils (4) with their scaled and limit pencils (5) and (6).