OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 Β· Β§3. Metrics, planar fillings, and torsion

Proposition 3.4: With the angle and dipole criteria for empty spheres, one face chain for all triangular fillings of a loop, and a cyclic chain obstruction

The group presented by marked line data is torsion-free.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let qq be a prime and put P=𝔽q20P = \mathbb{F}_q^{20}. From a family of lines in PP, each with a marked point, one builds a triangle complex KK with three vertices OO, VV, WW and a group GG presented by its edges and triangles. Measured in units of Ο€/5\pi/5, a corner of a triangle has angle 33 at OO and 11 at VV and at WW, so every triangle has angle sum 55, or Ο€\pi.

The question is whether GG has torsion: is there an element gβ‰ 1g \neq 1 with gn=1g^n = 1 for some nβ‰₯1n \geq 1? The library answers it together with four statements on diagrams and chains, and these notes give all five with the definitions they are built on.

Marked Line Data

Marked line data dd for qq and an integer rr consist of a set SβŠ‚π”½qS \subset \mathbb{F}_q of ⌊q/100βŒ‹\lfloor q/100 \rfloor scalars, a finite set II of NN labels and a finite set EβŠ‚PE \subset P of exceptional points, each label ii carrying a mark ai∈S20a_i \in S^{20} and a projective direction [Ξ½i][\nu_i] in PP, with distinct marks for distinct labels, subject to three conditions.✦ A point zz of PP is incident to the label ii when it lies on the line β„“i\ell_i through aia_i in direction [Ξ½i][\nu_i] and differs from aia_i, zβˆˆβ„“i\{ai},β„“i={ai+ΞΌΞ½i:ΞΌβˆˆπ”½q},z \in \ell_i \setminus \{a_i\}, \qquad \ell_i = \{a_i + \mu \nu_i : \mu \in \mathbb{F}_q\},(1)✦ and I(z)I(z) is the set of labels incident to zz.✦ The three conditions are a degree bound, a budget and a girth bound: |I(z)|β‰₯4r2for zβˆ‰E,4(2q20+r|E|)<rN,girth⁡ℬ>12,|I(z)| \geq 4r^2 \ \text{for } z \notin E, \qquad 4\,(2q^{20} + r|E|) < rN, \qquad \operatorname{girth} \mathcal{B} > 12,(2) where ℬ\mathcal{B} is the bipartite incidence graph on the points of PP and the labels, a point zz being adjacent to a label ii when i∈I(z)i \in I(z). A point of PP is regular when it lies outside EE.✦

A Cartesian block with parameter rr is a finite set of labels with a bijection i↦(Ξ±(i),Ξ²(i))i \mapsto (\alpha(i), \beta(i)) onto β„€/sΓ—β„€/t\mathbb{Z}/s \times \mathbb{Z}/t, for positive side lengths s,tβ‰₯rs, t \geq r.✦ A two-block partition of a finite set AA of labels is a pair of Cartesian blocks, block 00 and block 11, whose label sets are disjoint with union AA.✦ For rβ‰₯1r \geq 1, every regular point zz carries a fixed two-block partition of I(z)I(z).✦ A block index is a pair b=(z,m)b = (z, m) of a regular point zz and m∈{0,1}m \in \{0, 1\}✦, and the block at bb is block mm of the partition at zz, with side lengths sbs_b, tbt_b and coordinates Ξ±b\alpha_b, Ξ²b\beta_b.✦

The Complex and Its Group

Block presentation data over a set II of labels and a set BB of block indices assign a Cartesian block with parameter rr to each b∈Bb \in B and fix a base block b0∈Bb_0 \in B and a base index u0u_0 with 0≀u0<r0 \leq u_0 < r.✦ For rβ‰₯1r \geq 1, the fixed presentation of dd is the block presentation data over its labels and block indices, each index carrying its block, with base block b0=(z0,0)b_0 = (z_0, 0) at a chosen regular point z0z_0 and base index u0=0u_0 = 0.✦

The complex KK of block presentation data has the vertices OO, VV, WW✦ and the edges xiuv:Vβ†’W,Lb,u,j:Oβ†’V,Rb,v,k:Oβ†’W,x_{iuv}\colon V \to W, \qquad L_{b,u,j}\colon O \to V, \qquad R_{b,v,k}\colon O \to W,(3)✦ for i∈Ii \in I, b∈Bb \in B, 0≀u,v<r0 \leq u, v < r, jβˆˆβ„€/sbj \in \mathbb{Z}/s_b and kβˆˆβ„€/tbk \in \mathbb{Z}/t_b. For a block index bb, a label ii of its block and indices uu, vv, the triangle word is the element Lb,u,Ξ±b(i)+vxiuvRb,v,Ξ²b(i)+uβˆ’1L_{b,u,\alpha_b(i)+v}\, x_{iuv}\, R_{b,v,\beta_b(i)+u}^{-1}(4)✦ of the free group on the edges, its indices taken modulo sbs_b and tbt_b. The group GG is the group generated by the edges of KK subject to all triangle words (4) and to the two tree edges Lb0,u0,0L_{b_0,u_0,0} and Rb0,u0,0R_{b_0,u_0,0}.✦

An oriented edge ee of KK is an edge traversed forward, standing for its generator, or backward, standing for its inverse.✦ The reversal eβ€Ύ\bar e of an oriented edge ee of KK is the same edge traversed the other way.✦ The end Ο„(e)\tau(e) of ee is the head of its arrow in (3) when ee is traversed forward and its tail when ee is traversed backward.✦ The value Ξ΄(e)∈G\delta(e) \in G of ee is the image of the generator when ee is traversed forward and of its inverse when ee is traversed backward.✦ A triangle face of KK is a triple of oriented edges read cyclically around a triangle word (4) or its inverse, from any of its three letters.✦ A positive face is a triangle face whose three edges end at VV, WW and OO in turn.✦

The Lifted Complex and Its Diagrams

The lifted complex KΜƒ\widetilde K has as vertices the pairs (X,g)(X, g) of a vertex XX of KK and an element gg of GG✦, and as edges the pairs (e,g)(e, g) of an oriented edge ee of KK and an element gg of GG✦. A lifted edge has an end and a reversal, Ο„(e,g)=(Ο„(e),g),(e,g)Β―=(eβ€Ύ,gΞ΄(e)βˆ’1),\tau(e, g) = (\tau(e), g), \qquad \overline{(e, g)} = (\bar e,\, g\,\delta(e)^{-1}),(5) and begins where its reversal ends. Three lifted edges form a lifted triangle when their oriented edges, in order, form a triangle face of KK and each begins where the one before it ends, cyclically.✦ For vertices ΞΎ\xi and Ξ·\eta of KΜƒ\widetilde K, a path from ΞΎ\xi to Ξ·\eta in KΜƒ\widetilde K is a word of lifted edges whose first edge begins at ΞΎ\xi, each further edge beginning where the one before ends and the last ending at Ξ·\eta; the empty word is a path from ΞΎ\xi to itself, and a closed path at ΞΎ\xi is one from ΞΎ\xi to ΞΎ\xi.✦

Diagrams are made of darts. A dart map is a finite set DD of darts with an involution Οƒ\sigma of DD without fixed points, pairing the darts into edges, and a permutation Ο†\varphi of DD; its faces are the cycles of Ο†\varphi, its vertices are the cycles of σφ\sigma\varphi, and the degree deg⁡y\deg y of a vertex yy is its number of darts. A dart map is planar when cyc⁡(Οƒ)+cyc⁡(Ο†)+cyc⁡(σφ)=|D|+2ΞΊ,\operatorname{cyc}(\sigma) + \operatorname{cyc}(\varphi) + \operatorname{cyc}(\sigma\varphi) = |D| + 2\kappa,(6)✦ with cyc⁡(Ο€)\operatorname{cyc}(\pi) the number of cycles of a permutation Ο€\pi, fixed points included, and ΞΊ\kappa the number of orbits of the group generated by Οƒ\sigma and Ο†\varphi. This is Euler’s formula on every component, each of which has genus zero.

A labelling system consists of a set of labels, a reversal e↦eβ€Ύe \mapsto \bar e on it, an end map e↦τ(e)e \mapsto \tau(e) from it to a set of colours, and a set of triples of labels, the triangles. Over KΜƒ\widetilde K the labels are the lifted edges with the end and reversal (5), the colours are the vertices of KΜƒ\widetilde K, and the triangles are the lifted triangles. A labelled dart map is a planar dart map with a labelling Ξ»\lambda of its darts such that Ξ»(Οƒa)=Ξ»(a)Β―\lambda(\sigma a) = \overline{\lambda(a)} for every dart aa and τλ\tau\lambda is constant on each vertex. The colour of a vertex is the common end of the labels of its darts.

A triangulated sphere is a labelled dart map in which every dart aa lies on a face of length three whose labels Ξ»(a)\lambda(a), Ξ»(Ο†a)\lambda(\varphi a), Ξ»(Ο†2a)\lambda(\varphi^2 a) form a triangle.✦ A triangulated sphere DD may have several components, and DD is empty when it has no darts. A dipole in a triangulated sphere is a pair of cycles (a0a1a2)(a_0\,a_1\,a_2) and (a3a4a5)(a_3\,a_4\,a_5) of Ο†\varphi on six distinct darts that share the edge a3=Οƒa0a_3 = \sigma a_0 and satisfy Ξ»(a4)=Ξ»(a2)Β―,Ξ»(a5)=Ξ»(a1)Β―,τλ(a1)≠τλ(a0),τλ(a2)≠τλ(a1).\lambda(a_4) = \overline{\lambda(a_2)}, \quad \lambda(a_5) = \overline{\lambda(a_1)}, \quad \tau\lambda(a_1) \neq \tau\lambda(a_0), \quad \tau\lambda(a_2) \neq \tau\lambda(a_1).(7)✦

When the colours are three, numbered 00, 11, 22, the angle of a vertex yy of a triangulated sphere is ΞΈ(y)=3deg⁡yif y has colour 0,ΞΈ(y)=deg⁡yotherwise.\theta(y) = 3\deg y \ \text{if } y \text{ has colour } 0, \qquad \theta(y) = \deg y \ \text{otherwise}.(8)✦

A filling of a word ww of labels is a labelled dart map DD with a boundary βˆ‚D\partial D, a list of distinct darts that runs once around a cycle of Ο†\varphi in order, or is empty, and whose labels spell ww, such that every dart aa off the boundary lies either on a face of length three whose labels form a triangle, or on a face of length two made of the two darts of one edge.✦ A filling is triangular when every dart off its boundary lies on a face of length three.✦

Chains

For a set AA and a group Ξ“\Gamma, the free chain module C(A,Ξ“)C(A, \Gamma) is the free abelian group on AΓ—Ξ“A \times \Gamma.✦ An element gg of Ξ“\Gamma acts by translation on the basis elements (Ο‰,Ξ³)(\omega, \gamma) of C(A,Ξ“)C(A, \Gamma), with Ο‰βˆˆA\omega \in A and Ξ³βˆˆΞ“\gamma \in \Gamma✦, and the augmentation Ξ΅:C(A,Ξ“)β†’β„€\varepsilon\colon C(A, \Gamma) \to \mathbb{Z} sums the coefficients of a chain cc✦. A finite subgroup HH of Ξ“\Gamma has the norm NHN_H, the sum of the translations by its elements: gβ‹…(Ο‰,Ξ³)=(Ο‰,gΞ³),Ξ΅(Ο‰,Ξ³)=1,NHc=βˆ‘h∈Hhβ‹…c.g \cdot (\omega, \gamma) = (\omega, g\gamma), \qquad \varepsilon(\omega, \gamma) = 1, \qquad N_H c = \sum_{h \in H} h \cdot c.(9)✦

The 2-chain module of the presentation is C2=C(F+,G)C_2 = C(F^+, G), with F+F^+ the set of positive faces.✦ For lifted edges (e1,g1)(e_1, g_1), (e2,g2)(e_2, g_2), (e3,g3)(e_3, g_3), the bracket [(e1,g1),(e2,g2),(e3,g3)][(e_1, g_1), (e_2, g_2), (e_3, g_3)] is the basis element ((e1,e2,e3),g3)((e_1, e_2, e_3), g_3) of C2C_2 when (e1,e2,e3)(e_1, e_2, e_3) is a positive face, and 00 otherwise.✦ The face chain of a filling DD over KΜƒ\widetilde K is ch⁡(D)=βˆ’βˆ‘a∈D\βˆ‚D([Ξ»a,λφa,λφ2a]βˆ’[λφ2aΒ―,λφaΒ―,Ξ»aΒ―]).\operatorname{ch}(D) = -\sum_{a \in D \setminus \partial D} \Bigl( [\lambda a, \lambda\varphi a, \lambda\varphi^2 a] - [\overline{\lambda\varphi^2 a}, \overline{\lambda\varphi a}, \overline{\lambda a}] \Bigr).(10)✦

The Claim

Two of the statements hold for any labels and any group.

Theorem 1. Let labels be given with a reversal, an end map to three colours numbered 00, 11, 22 and a set of triangles, the three labels of every triangle ending at three different colours. For a triangulated sphere DD over them, with the angles (8), if ΞΈ(y)β‰₯10\theta(y) \geq 10 for every vertex yy, then D=βˆ…,D = \emptyset,(11)✦ an angle of 1010 being 2Ο€2\pi.

Theorem 2. Let Ξ“\Gamma be a group, HH a finite cyclic subgroup of Ξ“\Gamma generated by gg, and Mn=C(An,Ξ“)M_n = C(A_n, \Gamma) for sets A0A_0, A1A_1, A2A_2. Let βˆ‚1:M1β†’M0\partial_1\colon M_1 \to M_0 and βˆ‚2:M2β†’M1\partial_2\colon M_2 \to M_1 be homomorphisms commuting with the translations by the elements of HH, with βˆ‚1βˆ‚2=0\partial_1\partial_2 = 0 and Ξ΅βˆ‚1=0\varepsilon\partial_1 = 0. For chains p∈M0p \in M_0, c∈M1c \in M_1 and Σ∈M2\Sigma \in M_2 with Ξ΅(p)=1\varepsilon(p) = 1, βˆ‚1c=gβ‹…pβˆ’p\partial_1 c = g\cdot p - p, βˆ‚2Ξ£=NHc\partial_2 \Sigma = N_H c and gβ‹…Ξ£=Ξ£g \cdot \Sigma = \Sigma, one has g=1.g = 1.(12)✦

Theorem 3. Let dd be marked line data for a prime qq and an integer rβ‰₯1r \geq 1, GG the group of its fixed presentation and KΜƒ\widetilde K the lifted complex. Every triangulated sphere DD over KΜƒ\widetilde K that has no dipole is empty: D=βˆ….D = \emptyset.(13)✦ If ww is a closed path at a vertex of KΜƒ\widetilde K and DD, Dβ€²D' are triangular fillings of ww over KΜƒ\widetilde K, then ch⁡(D)=ch⁡(Dβ€²).\operatorname{ch}(D) = \operatorname{ch}(D').(14)✦ The group GG is torsion-free: g∈G,gn=1 for some nβ‰₯1β‡’g=1.g \in G,\ g^n = 1 \text{ for some } n \geq 1 \ \Longrightarrow\ g = 1.(15)✦ Every element gg of GG of finite order satisfies g=1.g = 1.(16)✦

In the paper, the result reads: the group Ο€1(K)\pi_1(K) is torsion-free, with GG standing for Ο€1(K)\pi_1(K).

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over marked line data dd with rβ‰₯1r \geq 1, the group GG of its fixed presentation, and triangulated spheres, dipoles, triangular fillings of closed paths and face chains over the lifted complex KΜƒ\widetilde K; the two general ones are stated over triangulated spheres with three colours and over free chain modules of a group with a finite cyclic subgroup.

About these constructions the library proves two facts beyond the claims: marked line data have a regular point, which gives the base block b0b_0✦, and a function on a set that is invariant under a permutation is constant on each cycle of the permutation.✦