The Setting
Let be a nonempty bounded open planar domain. The Dirichlet energy is considered on functions obtained by closing smooth compactly supported functions in the Sobolev norm. The spectral quantities are defined using real functions and Lebesgue measure on .
The test space consists of the smooth functions on the Euclidean plane whose support is compact and contained in : (1)✦ For a test function and a direction , the test derivative and test vector field are the functions in (2). (2)
The ambient Hilbert space for a scalar function and its gradient is the product of the scalar and vector spaces on , with the norm in (3). (3) A weak gradient of a function is a vector field , with both functions square-integrable on , satisfying the identity in (4) for every test function and every direction.✦ The Sobolev space is the weak gradient graph in (3): (4) A function together with a weak gradient determines its Sobolev class by taking their classes.✦
The Sobolev value map and gradient map are the two projections in (5). (5) In formulas involving integrals, a Sobolev element is written as its value under (5). The smooth test inclusion is the map sending a test function to its value and classical gradient.✦ The Dirichlet Sobolev space is the closed subspace of obtained as the closure of in (6). (6) The Dirichlet value map and gradient map are the restrictions of the Sobolev projections in (5) to .
The set of mean-zero Rayleigh values consists of the quotients in (7), formed from functions in with zero mean and nonzero value.✦ The first positive Neumann value of is the infimum of the mean-zero Rayleigh values in (7): (7)
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be nonempty, bounded and open. There are a number and an element with nonzero value such that (8)✦ For any and any with nonzero value, suppose that for every . Then (9)✦ There is also a number satisfying (10)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for a nonempty bounded simply connected planar domain as above, the first positive Neumann eigenvalue is strictly below the first Dirichlet eigenvalue .
What Is Checked
The assertions (8), (9) and (10) are stated over nonempty bounded open subsets of , with the Dirichlet space defined by (6) and the Neumann value defined by (7).
The value and gradient maps on and are continuous and linear, and the smooth test inclusion is linear.