The Setting
Let be a nonempty bounded simply connected open set. All spaces and inner products below use area measure on ; denotes the scalar or vector norm.
A test function is a smooth real function on with compact closed support contained in .✦ For a test function and a constant vector , the directional derivative is the derivative of in the direction ✦, and is the associated test vector field.✦ A function has weak gradient when (1)✦ The Sobolev space consists of functions having weak gradients satisfying (1).✦ Its scalar value and gradient maps are continuous linear maps into the respective spaces. The Sobolev class of a smooth test function has its classical gradient as weak gradient. The map sending each test function to its Sobolev class is linear.✦
The Dirichlet Sobolev space is the closure of in .✦ The mean-zero Sobolev space is the subspace of with zero integral.✦ The value and gradient maps on these subspaces are the restrictions of those on . The first positive Neumann value of is the infimum of the mean-zero Rayleigh quotients in (2): (2)✦ The Sobolev mean is the continuous real linear functional assigning to each function its mean on .✦
Weak Vector Data and Energy
Write for the standard orthonormal basis of and for a weak coordinate derivative. The quarter-turn sends to and acts pointwise on vector fields. A field has divergence with zero weak normal trace, and weak curl , when the respective identities in (3) hold: (3)
For , the coordinate embedding is the continuous real linear map from to that places in coordinate and sets the other coordinate to zero.✦ For , the coordinate projection is the continuous real linear map from to that extracts coordinate .✦
For a Sobolev vector field , the associated square-integrable field is ✦, and its divergence and curl are the functions in (4): (4) The space of weakly tangent Sobolev vector fields is the subspace of consisting of fields satisfying the first identity of (3) with .✦ For Sobolev vector fields and , the divergence-curl energy and its shifted bilinear form are defined by (5): (5)
A weak Neumann eigenfunction at a real value is a function satisfying (6); the real first Neumann eigenspace consists of the solutions at : (6)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. Assume and let be a real number satisfying the Dirichlet bound (7): (7) Let have divergence with zero weak normal trace and weak curl , in the sense of (3). Then (8)✦ If equality holds in (8), there is a function with (9)✦
On any open planar set , let and let satisfy (6). If equals almost everywhere, then (10)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for as above and every tangent , , with equality exactly when for some .
What Is Checked
The assertions (8) and (9) concern vector fields with the weak divergence and curl relations (3), while (10) concerns weak Neumann gradients whose components belong to .