The Setting
Let , and let be the standard orthonormal basis of the Euclidean plane. All spaces below use area measure restricted to . The ambient space of scalar-vector pairs is the product Hilbert space with the Euclidean product norm in (1): (1)✦
A test function on is a smooth real function on with compact closed support contained in .✦ For a test function on , write for its differential at . For a direction , the test derivative of in direction is , and the associated test vector field is ; these belong to and , respectively. A weak gradient of a real function is a square-integrable vector field such that is square-integrable and (2) holds for every such and every : (2)✦
The Sobolev space is the weak gradient graph, the linear subspace of consisting of pairs satisfying (2).✦ The value map and gradient map of the Sobolev space are the continuous linear maps and . A function with weak gradient determines the Sobolev class formed from their equivalence classes.✦
The space consists of square-integrable vector fields.✦ For , the coordinate projection to scalar and the coordinate embedding from scalar are continuous linear maps. The actions of the coordinate maps, the weak coordinate derivatives, and the Sobolev vector value are given in (3) for , , , and a field : (3) For a field , its Sobolev divergence and curl are the scalar functions in defined by (4): (4)
Write for the appropriate real inner product. The Cartesian Dirichlet energy and divergence-curl energy on are the bilinear forms with arguments given in (5); write for the corresponding quadratic energy: (5) For a real parameter , the shifted Cartesian form and vector form are the bilinear forms on defined by (6): (6)
The quarter-turn rotation is the continuous linear map ; its action on vector fields is pointwise rotation. The skew gradient energy on and the algebraic boundary defect on are the bilinear forms defined by (7): (7)
On a bounded open set , Lipschitz multiplication by a real Lipschitz function on is the map whose value is for .✦ On fields, acts on each component; write and .
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a set, let be a real parameter, and let be vector fields. Then the energy decomposition is (8)✦ If is bounded and open, is Lipschitz, and , then (9)✦
In the paper, the result reads as (10) for tangent fields , with unit tangent and curvature , positive on a convex circle: (10)
What Is Checked
The statements concern the weak gradient graph and its energy forms, with an arbitrary real shift in (8) and Lipschitz multiplication on bounded open sets in (9). Lipschitz multiplication on a bounded open set gives a Sobolev class whose weak gradient satisfies the product rule.