OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · Section 6. The energy bound and the scaling contradiction

Section 6 scaling contradiction: For positive powers in dimension n≥2n\ge2, using the first component on the unit ball

Subcritical solutions have dilates of unbounded energy.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

For positive powers p,qp,q and real weights A,BA,B, a positive solution (u,v)(u,v) of the weighted elliptic system on Euclidean coordinate space ℝn\mathbb R^n is a pair of continuous, strictly positive real-valued functions that are C2C^2 off the origin and satisfy (1) there: −Δu(x)=|x|Av(x)p,−Δv(x)=|x|Bu(x)q(x≠0).-\Delta u(x)=|x|^A v(x)^p,\qquad -\Delta v(x)=|x|^B u(x)^q\qquad (x\ne0).(1)✦ All powers are interpreted as real powers. The corresponding sources f,gf,g are the functions specified by (2): f(x)={|x|Bu(x)q,x≠0,0,x=0,g(x)={|x|Av(x)p,x≠0,0,x=0.f(x)=\begin{cases}|x|^B u(x)^q,&x\ne0,\\0,&x=0,\end{cases} \qquad g(x)=\begin{cases}|x|^A v(x)^p,&x\ne0,\\0,&x=0.\end{cases}(2)

The subcritical hyperbola condition on n,p,q,A,Bn,p,q,A,B is the strict inequality (3): n+Ap+1+n+Bq+1>n−2.\frac{n+A}{p+1}+\frac{n+B}{q+1}>n-2.(3)✦ The scaling exponent α\alpha of the first component is the real number in (4): α=2+A+p(2+B)pq−1.\alpha=\frac{2+A+p(2+B)}{pq-1}.(4)✦

For a real-valued function ww on ℝn\mathbb R^n, a real exponent ss, and a real scale RR, its dilation Ds,RwD_{s,R}w is the function defined by (5): (Ds,Rw)(x)=Rsw(Rx).(D_{s,R}w)(x)=R^s w(Rx).(5)✦

Definition 1. For a real-valued function ww on ℝn\mathbb R^n and real parameters q,Bq,B, its weighted energy density eq,B[w]e_{q,B}[w] is the function in (6): eq,B[w](x)=|x|Bw(x)q+1.e_{q,B}[w](x)=|x|^B w(x)^{q+1}.(6)✦ For a nonnegative real-valued function ww on ℝn\mathbb R^n, real parameters q,Bq,B, and r>0r>0, the weighted energy ℰq,B(w;r)\mathcal E_{q,B}(w;r) on the ball Br={x∈ℝn:|x|<r}B_r=\{x\in\mathbb R^n:|x|<r\} is the nonnegative extended integral in (7): ℰq,B(w;r)=∫Br+eq,B[w](x)dx∈[0,∞].\mathcal E_{q,B}(w;r) =\int_{B_r}^{+}e_{q,B}[w](x)\,dx\in[0,\infty].(7)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let w:ℝn→ℝw:\mathbb R^n\to\mathbb R be continuous and nonnegative, let s,q,Bs,q,B be real, and let R>0R>0. The energy scaling identity is (8): ℰq,B(Ds,Rw;1)=Rs(q+1)−B−nℰq,B(w;R).\mathcal E_{q,B}(D_{s,R}w;1) =R^{s(q+1)-B-n}\mathcal E_{q,B}(w;R).(8)✦ Let n≥2n\ge2, let p,q>0p,q>0 and A,B∈ℝA,B\in\mathbb R, and let (u,v)(u,v) be a positive solution satisfying the subcritical hyperbola condition. For every real CC, there is a scale R≥1R\ge1 satisfying (9): max⁡{C,0}<ℰq,B(Dα,Ru;1).\max\{C,0\}<\mathcal E_{q,B}(D_{\alpha,R}u;1).(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a solution in the reduced range, with β\beta the scaling exponent of vv, every R>0R>0 gives another solution (uR,vR)=(Dα,Ru,Dβ,Rv)(u_R,v_R)=(D_{\alpha,R}u,D_{\beta,R}v), whose corresponding sources fR,gRf_R,g_R satisfy ∫B1(fRuR+gRvR)=Rα+β+2−n∫BR(fu+gv)\int_{B_1}(f_Ru_R+g_Rv_R)=R^{\alpha+\beta+2-n}\int_{B_R}(fu+gv); strict subcriticality makes α+β+2−n\alpha+\beta+2-n positive, while positivity supplies a fixed positive lower energy on B1B_1, so the unit-ball energies of these dilates are unbounded as R→∞R\to\infty, contradicting Proposition 6.1.

What Is Checked

The identity (8) is stated over continuous nonnegative functions on Euclidean space with arbitrary real exponents and weights and positive scales; (9) concerns the first component of positive solutions with positive powers in dimension n≥2n\ge2 under the subcritical hyperbola condition.