OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. A strict spectral surplus

Lemma 3.1: Bihomogeneous harmonic kernels have explicit dimensions; paired nonzero charges give real angular multiplicities in ℝ16\mathbb R^{16}

Hopf charges determine eigenvalues and bound real multiplicities.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The Hopf charge of a bihomogeneous polynomial is the integer equal to the difference between its holomorphic and antiholomorphic degrees. The library relates these charges to the square of the angular derivative and to the number of real harmonic polynomial modes in dimension sixteen.

Let nn denote the Cartesian dimension and m=n−1m=n-1 the link dimension. The real polynomial space 𝒫n\mathcal P_n is the algebra ℝ[x1,…,xn]\mathbb R[x_1,\ldots,x_n].✦ The Euclidean polynomial Laplacian Δ\Delta and the degree ℓ\ell harmonic polynomial space Vℓ⊂𝒫nV_\ell\subset\mathcal P_n are defined by (1); write Nℓ=dim⁡ℝVℓN_\ell=\dim_{\mathbb R}V_\ell. Δ=∑i=1n∂xi2,Vℓ={P∈𝒫n:P is homogeneous of degree ℓ,ΔP=0}.\Delta=\sum_{i=1}^n\partial_{x_i}^2, \qquad V_\ell=\{P\in\mathcal P_n:P\text{ is homogeneous of degree }\ell, \ \Delta P=0\}.(1) The inner product on VℓV_\ell is the Fischer inner product.

An orthogonal complex structure JJ on ℝn\mathbb R^n is a real matrix satisfying J2=−IJ^2=-I and J𝖳J=IJ^{\mathsf T}J=I.✦ In dimension n=2sn=2s, the standard complex structure J0J_0 on the paired coordinates (x,y)∈ℝs⊕ℝs(x,y)\in\mathbb R^s\oplus\mathbb R^s is the matrix in (2). J0=(0−IsIs0).J_0=\begin{pmatrix}0&-I_s\\ I_s&0\end{pmatrix}.(2)✦ Relabelling coordinates by a bijection ee replaces JJ by the matrix with entries Je(a)e(b)J_{e(a)e(b)}.✦

For coordinate variables wiw_i and a matrix M=(Mij)M=(M_{ij}) over their field, the linear vector field derivation ℒM\mathcal L_M on polynomials is given by (3).✦ When M∈Mn(ℝ)M\in M_n(\mathbb R), the space of real n×nn\times n matrices, this is the infinitesimal coordinate motion on 𝒫n\mathcal P_n. ℒMP=∑i,jMijwj∂wiP.\mathcal L_M P=\sum_{i,j}M_{ij}w_j\partial_{w_i}P.(3)✦ The infinitesimal Hopf rotation DJD_J on VℓV_\ell is the restriction of ℒJ\mathcal L_J✦; regarded as a continuous linear operator, it is the bounded Hopf derivative.✦

Complex Polynomial Spaces

The split polynomial algebra 𝒫sℂ\mathcal P^{\mathbb C}_s is the complex polynomial algebra in the independent variables z1,…,zs,z‾1,…,z‾sz_1,\ldots,z_s,\bar z_1,\ldots,\bar z_s.✦ Assign weight (1,0)(1,0) to each ziz_i and weight (0,1)(0,1) to each z‾i\bar z_i.✦ For nonnegative integers p,qp,q, the bihomogeneous subspace 𝒫p,q⊂𝒫sℂ\mathcal P_{p,q}\subset\mathcal P^{\mathbb C}_s consists of polynomials whose monomials all have total weight (p,q)(p,q).✦

In the complex coordinates z=x+iyz=x+iy, z‾=x−iy\bar z=x-iy, the complex coordinate matrix Jˆ\widehat J of a real complex structure JJ is specified by (4). Jˆ=SJS−1,S=(IsiIsIs−iIs).\widehat J=SJS^{-1}, \qquad S=\begin{pmatrix}I_s&iI_s\\ I_s&-iI_s\end{pmatrix}.(4)✦

The mixed Laplacian Δmix\Delta_{\mathrm{mix}} on 𝒫sℂ\mathcal P^{\mathbb C}_s and the bihomogeneous harmonic space ℋp,q⊂𝒫p,q\mathcal H_{p,q}\subset\mathcal P_{p,q} are defined by (5). Δmix=∑i=1s∂zi∂z‾i,ℋp,q=𝒫p,q∩ker⁡Δmix.\Delta_{\mathrm{mix}}=\sum_{i=1}^s \partial_{z_i}\partial_{\bar z_i}, \qquad \mathcal H_{p,q}=\mathcal P_{p,q}\cap\ker\Delta_{\mathrm{mix}}.(5)

For nonnegative p,qp,q, the Hopf multiplicity mpqm_{pq} used in dimension sixteen is the integer in (6), with (ab)=0\binom ab=0 for a<ba<b. mpq=(p+77)(q+77)−(p+67)(q+67).m_{pq}=\binom{p+7}{7}\binom{q+7}{7} -\binom{p+6}{7}\binom{q+6}{7}.(6)✦

Real Spectral Multiplicities

For n=16n=16 and m=15m=15, take orthogonal complex structures on ℝ8⊕ℝ8\mathbb R^8\oplus\mathbb R^8, identified with ℝ16\mathbb R^{16} by coordinate relabelling. The Hopf derivative square on VℓV_\ell is QJ=DJ2Q_J=D_J^2✦, and its standard value is Q0=QJ0Q_0=Q_{J_0}.✦ In the construction, block number rr denotes Vr+2V_{r+2}; the first LL blocks therefore cover degrees 2,…,L+12,\ldots,L+1.✦

For a bounded linear operator TT on a finite-dimensional real inner product space EE and an orthonormal basis e=(ei)e=(e_i) of EE, the matrix of TT in this basis has entries [T]e,ij=⟨ei,Tej⟩[T]_{e,ij}=\langle e_i,Te_j\rangle; this matrix depends linearly and continuously on TT.✦ An orthonormal spectral decomposition of a bounded linear operator TT on a finite-dimensional real inner product space EE is an orthonormal basis ee of EE together with real numbers λi\lambda_i satisfying (7). Tei=λiei,[T]e=diag⁡(λi).Te_i=\lambda_i e_i, \qquad [T]_e=\operatorname{diag}(\lambda_i).(7)✦ For each degree ℓ≥2\ell\ge2, the standard Hopf spectral decomposition is the chosen orthonormal spectral decomposition of Q0Q_0 on VℓV_\ell.✦ Denote its eigenvalues by δℓ,i\delta_{\ell,i}✦, indexed by the harmonic basis index set Iℓ={0,…,Nℓ−1}I_\ell=\{0,\ldots,N_\ell-1\}.✦ Multiplicities below count indices in this set.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let s,p,qs,p,q be nonnegative integers, and let P∈𝒫p,qP\in\mathcal P_{p,q} in ss complex coordinate pairs. Then −ℒJˆ0(ℒJˆ0P)=(p−q)2P.-\mathcal L_{\widehat J_0} \bigl(\mathcal L_{\widehat J_0}P\bigr)=(p-q)^2P.(8)✦ For s≥2s\ge2, the complex dimension of the bihomogeneous harmonic space is dim⁡ℂℋp,q=(s+p−1p)(s+q−1q)−{0,p=0 or q=0,(s+p−2p−1)(s+q−2q−1),p,q>0.\dim_{\mathbb C}\mathcal H_{p,q} =\binom{s+p-1}{p}\binom{s+q-1}{q} -\begin{cases} 0,&p=0\text{ or }q=0,\\ \displaystyle\binom{s+p-2}{p-1}\binom{s+q-2}{q-1},&p,q>0. \end{cases}(9)✦ In real dimension sixteen, let ℓ≥2\ell\ge2 and let p,qp,q be nonnegative integers with p+q=ℓp+q=\ell and p≠qp\ne q. Then 2mpq≤#{i∈Iℓ:δℓ,i=−(p−q)2}.2m_{pq}\le \#\{i\in I_\ell:\delta_{\ell,i}=-(p-q)^2\}.(10)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for m=2s−1m=2s-1 with s≥4s\ge4 and 0≤b≤ℓ0\le b\le\ell, the squared Hopf charge (2b−ℓ)2(2b-\ell)^2 contributes multiplicity hℓ,bh_{\ell,b} given by (11), hℓ,b=(s+b−1s−1)(s+ℓ−b−1s−1)−(s+b−2s−1)(s+ℓ−b−2s−1)=ℓ+s−1s−1(b+s−2s−2)(ℓ−b+s−2s−2),\begin{aligned} h_{\ell,b} &=\binom{s+b-1}{s-1}\binom{s+\ell-b-1}{s-1} -\binom{s+b-2}{s-1}\binom{s+\ell-b-2}{s-1}\\ &=\frac{\ell+s-1}{s-1} \binom{b+s-2}{s-2}\binom{\ell-b+s-2}{s-2}, \end{aligned}(11) with missing bidegrees interpreted as zero, and, with probabilities hℓ,b/Nℓh_{\ell,b}/N_\ell, the quantities (2b−ℓ)2/ℓ2(2b-\ell)^2/\ell^2 converge in distribution to Beta⁡(1/2,(m−1)/2)\operatorname{Beta}(1/2,(m-1)/2) as ℓ→∞\ell\to\infty.

What Is Checked

The complex assertions (8) and (9) are stated over bihomogeneous polynomials and their mixed Laplacian kernels, with s≥2s\ge2 for the dimension formula. The bound (10) concerns the real spectral decomposition on VℓV_\ell in dimension sixteen, for ℓ≥2\ell\ge2 and distinct bidegrees summing to ℓ\ell.

The standard Hopf square Q0Q_0 is symmetric for the Fischer inner product.✦ Every symmetric bounded linear operator on a finite-dimensional real inner product space has an orthonormal eigenbasis in which its matrix is diagonal.✦