The Setting
Integer-degree harmonic dimension comparison asks how many independent harmonic functions can satisfy a fixed polynomial growth bound on a complete manifold with nonnegative Ricci curvature. Here growth is measured by intrinsic distance from the origin, and the comparison count is a binomial expression.
On Cartesian space , a smooth Riemannian metric is a matrix field with smooth coefficients and positive definite values, where denotes the real matrices. Write for the entries of its inverse. The coordinate derivative of a real function is its differential in the coordinate direction , as in (1). (1)✦
The Christoffel symbols and the Ricci tensor are the coefficient functions defined by (2). (2) A smooth Riemannian metric on has nonnegative Ricci curvature when for every .
The Riemannian length of a curve is the integral in (3); the intrinsic distance is the infimum there over such curves joining to . (3) A complete Riemannian metric on is a Riemannian metric for which every Cauchy sequence for converges to a point of . Writing for the identity matrix, a Riemannian metric on is Euclidean near the origin when there is an such that whenever .✦
The Laplace-Beltrami operator on real functions is the trace with respect to of the covariant Hessian, given in coordinates by (4). (4) For a nonnegative integer , the harmonic growth class is the space of smooth real harmonic functions satisfying the pointwise bound in (5). (5)✦ For positive integers , the Euclidean comparator is the integer in (6), defined directly by binomial coefficients. (6)✦
For a Riemannian metric on and a radius , the intrinsic ball is the set of points with . For a Riemannian metric on , the volume of the intrinsic ball is the integral against Cartesian Lebesgue measure in (7), where is the volume of the Euclidean unit ball. (7) A Riemannian metric on with positive subunit asymptotic volume ratio is a Riemannian metric for which there is a real number satisfying (8). (8)✦
The Claim
Theorem 1. There exist an even integer , an integer , and a complete smooth Riemannian metric on with nonnegative Ricci curvature, Euclidean near the origin and with positive subunit asymptotic volume ratio, together with a family satisfying (9)✦
In the paper, the result reads: writing and for the Euclidean metric, there exist an even integer , an integer , and a complete smooth metric on with and , Euclidean near the origin and satisfying .
What Is Checked
The claim (9) is stated over smooth positive definite matrix fields on , with the intrinsic distance of (3), the Ricci tensor and Laplace-Beltrami operator of (2) and (4), the pointwise growth class of (5), and the intrinsic ball volumes of (7).