OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Differentiable coordinates and transverse directions

Lemma 4.4: For nonempty allowed sets in a dyadic window of positive time mass, when singletons have zero mass

Local independence forces three distinct directions.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

During a planar sweep, direction constraints depend on which time intervals have ended and which have not yet begun. Fix a continuous linear isomorphism Q:ℝ2→ℝ2Q:\mathbb R^2\to\mathbb R^2, continuous linear forms gi:ℝ2→ℝg_i:\mathbb R^2\to\mathbb R indexed by a set ι\iota, and real thresholds ai,bia_i,b_i. A planar point is an ordered pair of real numbers, and the Euclidean plane ℝ2\mathbb R^2 is the space of these pairs.

The standard simplex parametrization u:ℝ→ℝ2u:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R^2 is the map in (1). u(x)=(x,1−x).u(x)=(x,1-x).(1)✦ The allowed direction set D(t)D(t) at a real time tt is the subset of projective parameters in [0,1][0,1] specified by the sign conditions in (2). D(t)={x∈[0,1]:gi(Q(u(x)))≥0for every i with bi<t,gi(Q(u(x)))≤0for every i with t<ai}.D(t)=\left\{x\in[0,1]: \begin{array}{ll} g_i(Q(u(x)))\geq0&\text{for every }i\text{ with }b_i<t,\\ g_i(Q(u(x)))\leq0&\text{for every }i\text{ with }t<a_i \end{array}\right\}.(2)✦

Set I=[0,1]I=[0,1]. For a positive integer mm, the uniform partition boundaries Bm,j∈IB_{m,j}\in I and the uniform partition cells Cm,j⊆IC_{m,j}\subseteq I are given by (3). Bm,j=jm(0≤j≤m),Cm,j={[Bm,j,Bm,j+1)0≤j<m−1,[Bm,j,Bm,j+1]j=m−1.\begin{aligned} B_{m,j}&=\frac{j}{m} &&(0\leq j\leq m),\\ C_{m,j}&= \begin{cases} [B_{m,j},B_{m,j+1})&0\leq j<m-1,\\ [B_{m,j},B_{m,j+1}]&j=m-1. \end{cases} \end{aligned}(3) A dyadic time window JJ is a pair (d,j)(d,j) of integers with d≥0d\geq0 and 0≤j<2d0\leq j<2^d.✦ The lower and upper endpoints ℓJ,rJ\ell_J,r_J of a dyadic window J=(d,j)J=(d,j) and its time interval CJ⊆IC_J\subseteq I are defined by (4). ℓJ=B2d,j,rJ=B2d,j+1,CJ=C2d,j.\ell_J=B_{2^d,j},\qquad r_J=B_{2^d,j+1},\qquad C_J=C_{2^d,j}.(4) The subwindows of a dyadic window KK form the family 𝒮(K)\mathcal S(K) of dyadic windows JJ with CJ⊆CKC_J\subseteq C_K.✦ For forms indexed by 𝒮(K)\mathcal S(K), write DK(t)D_K(t) for the allowed set with thresholds aJ=ℓJa_J=\ell_J and bJ=rJb_J=r_J.

The Claim

Theorem 1. For real times s,ts,t, suppose two indices i,j∈ιi,j\in\iota satisfy s<ais<a_i, bi<tb_i<t, s<ajs<a_j and bj<tb_j<t, and the linear map v↦(gi(v),gj(v))v\mapsto(g_i(v),g_j(v)) is injective. Their allowed sets satisfy (5). D(s)∩D(t)=⌀.D(s)\cap D(t)=\varnothing.(5)✦

Let ρ\rho be a measure on ℝ\mathbb R assigning zero mass to every singleton, and let E⊆ℝE\subseteq\mathbb R be bounded with ρ(E)>0\rho(E)>0. Suppose F(t)⊆ℝF(t)\subseteq\mathbb R is nonempty and convex for every t∈Et\in E, and F(s)∩F(t)=⌀F(s)\cap F(t)=\varnothing whenever s<ts<t belong to EE and ρ((s,t))>0\rho((s,t))>0. There are real times t1,t2,t3t_1,t_2,t_3 and parameters d1,d2,d3d_1,d_2,d_3 satisfying (6). t1,t2,t3∈E,t1<t2<t3,F(tk)={dk}(k=1,2,3),d1≠d2,d2≠d3,d1≠d3.\begin{gathered} t_1,t_2,t_3\in E,\qquad t_1<t_2<t_3,\\ F(t_k)=\{d_k\}\quad(k=1,2,3),\\ d_1\ne d_2,\qquad d_2\ne d_3,\qquad d_1\ne d_3. \end{gathered}(6)✦

Let η\eta be a measure on II assigning zero mass to every singleton, and let KK be a dyadic window with η(CK)>0\eta(C_K)>0. Suppose the forms gJg_J are indexed by 𝒮(K)\mathcal S(K) and DK(t)D_K(t) is nonempty for every ℓK<t<rK\ell_K<t<r_K. Assume that each J∈𝒮(K)J\in\mathcal S(K) with η(CJ)>0\eta(C_J)>0 contains subwindows J1,J2∈𝒮(K)J_1,J_2\in\mathcal S(K) with CJ1,CJ2⊆CJC_{J_1},C_{J_2}\subseteq C_J for which v↦(gJ1(v),gJ2(v))v\mapsto(g_{J_1}(v),g_{J_2}(v)) is injective. There are times t1,t2,t3∈It_1,t_2,t_3\in I and real parameters d1,d2,d3d_1,d_2,d_3 satisfying (7). ℓK<t1<t2<t3<rK,DK(tk)={dk}(k=1,2,3),d1≠d2,d2≠d3,d1≠d3.\begin{gathered} \ell_K<t_1<t_2<t_3<r_K,\\ D_K(t_k)=\{d_k\}\quad(k=1,2,3),\\ d_1\ne d_2,\qquad d_2\ne d_3,\qquad d_1\ne d_3. \end{gathered}(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a remaining label zz in the positive chart, with nonatomic conditional probability hzh_z, positive hz(K)h_z(K) and the preceding independent-gradient property, the nonempty allowed intervals D(s)D(s) and D(t)D(t) are disjoint whenever s<ts<t lie inside KK and hz((s,t))>0h_z((s,t))>0, and there are τ1<τ2<τ3\tau_1<\tau_2<\tau_3 inside KK for which D(τk)D(\tau_k) are singletons with distinct projective directions.

What Is Checked

The statements concern continuous linear changes of planar coordinates and linear forms, with time measures vanishing on singletons and positive mass on the bounded set or dyadic window under consideration.