OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท 4. Partial cylinders and elementary expansions

Proposition 4.3 [Partial paths and endpoint lifting]: Under expansion-contraction, reflected cylinders give objectwise path data with joint source lifting from a chosen starting degree nn

Endpoint lifting for interpreted partial cylinders.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Partial paths in a model YY of a globular coherator CC begin in a chosen dimension nn. Their representing cylinders have two endpoints, and operations of CC must act compatibly with endpoint evaluation.

The globe category ๐”พ\mathbb G has one object in each natural dimension and source and target face maps subject to the globular identities. A globular presheaf XX is a functor ๐”พopโ†’Set\mathbb G^{\mathrm{op}}\to\mathrm{Set}.โœฆ Its underlying globular set has cell sets XjX_j and source and target maps s,t:Xj+1โ†’Xjs,t:X_{j+1}\to X_j, with ss=sts s=s t and ts=ttt s=t t. A globular map commutes with these face maps.โœฆ Two positive-dimensional cells x,yx,y are parallel, written xโˆฅyx\parallel y, when they have the same source and target; all zero-dimensional cells are parallel.โœฆ

The set Bj(X)B_j(X) of jj-boundaries and the boundary map โˆ‚j\partial_j are given by (1); having fillers for every boundary means that every โˆ‚j\partial_j is surjective. B0(X)={*},Bj+1(X)={(x,y)โˆˆXj2:xโˆฅy},โˆ‚j+1(z)=(sz,tz).B_0(X)=\{*\},\qquad B_{j+1}(X)=\{(x,y)\in X_j^2:x\parallel y\},\qquad \partial_{j+1}(z)=(s z,t z).(1) A globular map f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y lifts jj-boundaries if a boundary bโˆˆBj(X)b\in B_j(X) and a cell yโˆˆYjy\in Y_j with โˆ‚jy=Bj(f)(b)\partial_j y=B_j(f)(b) admit a cell xโˆˆXjx\in X_j with โˆ‚jx=b\partial_j x=b and f(x)=yf(x)=y; the induced boundary map Bj(f)B_j(f) applies ff to the two members of a positive-dimensional boundary.

A shape SS is a finite globular sum, specified by a table of globe dimensions with a distinguished last globe.โœฆ An elementary attachment adds a globe of dimension hh by gluing its source bb-face to the target bb-face of the last globe of SS, where bb is smaller than both globe dimensions.โœฆ The two pushout inclusions are the previous arity inclusion and the attached globe inclusion; the gluing face inclusion is the target face of the old last globe. The height of SS is the greatest dimension in its table.โœฆ The realization |S||S| of a shape SS is the corresponding globular presheaf, with its last globe inclusion. A kk-cell of |S||S| classifies a map from the representable kk-globe to SS.โœฆ

A globular theory CC is a category on finite globular sums whose arity functor sends elementary globular gluings to pushouts.โœฆ A morphism F:Cโ†’Cโ€ฒF:C\to Cโ€ฒ of globular theories is a functor that fixes the arities and preserves their structural maps.โœฆ An admissible pair in CC is a parallel pair of operations from the jj-globe to a shape of height at most j+1j+1; a filler is an operation from the (j+1)(j+1)-globe with those two restrictions. A coherator CC is a globular theory in which every admissible pair has a filler and which admits a cellular presentation: a sequential colimit starting at the initial theory, with each successor freely adjoining specified fillers of admissible pairs.โœฆ Here freeness means that maps out of the successor correspond uniquely to maps out of the preceding stage together with choices of those fillers.โœฆ

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC sending elementary globular sums to pullbacks.โœฆ Restriction to globes gives its underlying globular set; restriction to shapes gives its tuple system. A tuple system TT is a presheaf on finite globular sums that takes elementary globular gluings to pullbacks.โœฆ For a globular presheaf XX, its SS-tuples are maps |S|โ†’X|S|\to X. The underlying globular presheaf of a tuple system TT is its restriction to globes, and tuple evaluation is the natural transformation from TT to the tuple system of that presheaf which sends an element of T(S)T(S) to the globular map whose value on each cell of SS is its restriction along that cellโ€™s classifying map.

The free model F(S)F(S) on a shape SS is the representable presheaf at SS; maps F(S)โ†’XF(S)\to X correspond to globular maps |S|โ†’X|S|\to X. The free disk DjD_j is F(S)F(S) for the single jj-globe.โœฆ The free boundary โˆ‚Dj\partial D_j represents Bj(X)B_j(X), compatibly with boundary restriction, as in (2). The boundary inclusion Ij:โˆ‚Djโ†’DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j is the inclusion of the free boundary in the free disk, and Jj:Djโ†’Dj+1J_j:D_j\to D_{j+1} is the source inclusion. Hom⁡(Dj,X)โ‰…Xj,Hom⁡(โˆ‚Dj,X)โ‰…Bj(X),Ij*โ†”โˆ‚j.\operatorname{Hom}(D_j,X)\cong X_j,\qquad \operatorname{Hom}(\partial D_j,X)\cong B_j(X),\qquad I_j^*\longleftrightarrow\partial_j.(2) The boundary objects begin with the initial object and successively glue two copies of DjD_j along โˆ‚Dj\partial D_j.โœฆ

For a natural number qq, let ๐’œq\mathcal A_q be the full category of models with unique boundary fillers in every dimension above qq.โœฆ The coskeletal reflection LqL_q from the category C-ModC\text{-}\mathrm{Mod} of models of CC to ๐’œq\mathcal A_q has unit ฮทX:Xโ†’LqX\eta_X:X\to L_qX and the natural adjunction bijection (3). Write Djq=LqDjD_j^q=L_qD_j and โˆ‚Djq=Lq(โˆ‚Dj)\partial D_j^q=L_q(\partial D_j), with reflected inclusions Ijq=LqIjI_j^q=L_qI_j and Jjq=LqJjJ_j^q=L_qJ_j. Hom⁡๐’œq(LqX,Y)โ‰…Hom⁡C-Mod(X,Y),Yโˆˆ๐’œq.\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal A_q}(L_qX,Y) \cong\operatorname{Hom}_{C\text{-}\mathrm{Mod}}(X,Y), \qquad Y\in\mathcal A_q.(3)โœฆ

For a class โ„ณ\mathcal M of morphisms, โ„ณโ‹”\mathcal M^{\pitchfork} and โ‹”โ„ณ\,{}^{\pitchfork}\mathcal M denote its right and left lifting classes. For a natural number rr, the generating boundary and source classes are (4). โ„q,r={Ijq:jโ‰ฅr},๐’ฅq,r={Jjq:jโ‰ฅr}.\mathcal I_{q,r}=\{I_j^q:j\ge r\},\qquad \mathcal J_{q,r}=\{J_j^q:j\ge r\}.(4) A model Xโˆˆ๐’œqX\in\mathcal A_q is cofibrant if every map Xโ†’QX\to Q lifts along every p:Pโ†’Qp:P\to Q in โ„q,0โ‹”\mathcal I_{q,0}^{\pitchfork}.โœฆ The expansion-contraction principle E(q,r)\mathrm E(q,r) is the following preservation property. Let i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y belong to โ‹”(๐’ฅq,rโ‹”)\,{}^{\pitchfork}(\mathcal J_{q,r}^{\pitchfork}), and suppose that XX is cofibrant and has fillers for every boundary. Then YY has fillers for every boundary.โœฆ

Cylinder Frames and Interpretations

A globular frame FF in a category consists of disks FjF_j, boundaries โˆ‚Fj\partial F_j and inclusions iji_j, with an initial โˆ‚F0\partial F_0 and the boundary pushouts (5).โœฆ Its two face inclusions give a coglobular object; iterated faces start with the chosen source or target and continue by source inclusions. โˆ‚Fj+1=Fjโˆโˆ‚FjFj,Fjโ‡‰โˆ‚Fj+1โ†’ij+1Fj+1.\partial F_{j+1}=F_j\amalg_{\partial F_j}F_j, \qquad F_j\rightrightarrows\partial F_{j+1}\xrightarrow{i_{j+1}}F_{j+1}.(5) A frame morphism e:Fโ†’Ge:F\to G consists of disk maps Fjโ†’GjF_j\to G_j and boundary maps โˆ‚Fjโ†’โˆ‚Gj\partial F_j\to\partial G_j in every degree, commuting with the boundary inclusions and both face maps. The disk frame has disks DjD_j and boundaries โˆ‚Dj\partial D_j; the cutoff disk frame has their reflected counterparts. If a functor preserves pushouts and the initial object, the image frame is obtained by applying it to the disks, boundaries, boundary inclusions and face maps of the original frame.

The realization |T|F|T|_F of a globular presheaf TT in a globular frame FF is the colimit of its diagram of globes interpreted in the coglobular object of FF.โœฆ For an object YY in the category of a globular frame FF, the globular nerve NFYN_FY is the globular presheaf with jj-cells Hom⁡(Fj,Y)\operatorname{Hom}(F_j,Y) and faces given by precomposition.โœฆ Cell inclusions into realization give the realization unit; transposition and descent are the directions of (6), where Glob\mathrm{Glob} denotes the category of globular presheaves. Frame morphisms induce natural transformations between realizations, and postcomposition induces maps of nerves. Hom⁡(|T|F,Y)โ‰…Hom⁡Glob(T,NFY).\operatorname{Hom}(|T|_F,Y) \cong\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{Glob}}(T,N_FY).(6)โœฆ For a shape SS, realization in the cutoff disk frame is naturally isomorphic to the reflected representable Fq(S)=LqF(S)F_q(S)=L_qF(S). A coglobular object in a category with all small colimits realizes the representable globe in dimension jj as its object in degree jj. For a frame morphism e:Fโ†’Ge:F\to G, precomposition by its disk maps gives a globular map NGYโ†’NFYN_GY\to N_FY for every object YY.

A cylinder stage in degree jj over the cutoff disk frame consists of a boundary BjB_j, an object PjP_j, an inclusion ij:Bjโ†’Pji_j:B_j\to P_j, and boundary and disk endpoint maps bฮต,jb_{\varepsilon,j} and aฮต,ja_{\varepsilon,j} satisfying (7), for ฮต=0,1\varepsilon=0,1. bฮต,j:โˆ‚Djqโ†’Bj,aฮต,j:Djqโ†’Pj,ijbฮต,j=aฮต,jIjq.b_{\varepsilon,j}:\partial D_j^q\to B_j,\qquad a_{\varepsilon,j}:D_j^q\to P_j,\qquad i_j b_{\varepsilon,j}=a_{\varepsilon,j}I_j^q.(7)โœฆ A cylinder boundary step has two maps Pjโ‡‰Bj+1P_j\rightrightarrows B_{j+1} making Bj+1B_{j+1} the pushout of iji_j along itself, compatibly with the disk faces and endpoint maps.โœฆ

The partial disk cylinders are stationary below nn: their boundaries and objects are โˆ‚Djq\partial D_j^q and DjqD_j^q, and their endpoints are identities. The critical stage at nn has boundary โˆ‚Dnq\partial D_n^q and object Dn+1qD_{n+1}^q, with source and target disk endpoints, identity boundary endpoints and boundary inclusion JnqInqJ_n^qI_n^q.โœฆ At each later stage the successor boundary is PjโˆBjPjP_j\amalg_{B_j}P_j.โœฆ Its boundary endpoint maps are induced from the preceding disk endpoints.โœฆ The double boundary attachment attaches two copies of Dj+1qD_{j+1}^q along these maps; its base inclusion is the composite of the two left pushout inclusions, and its disk endpoints are the attached disk inclusions. A chosen cylinder factorization of the base inclusion through the successor cylinder object completes this attachment to the successor cylinder stage. The stationary and critical transitions use the disk frame faces; successor transitions use the two inclusions into the successor boundary. For an object Bโˆˆ๐’œqB\in\mathcal A_q and two maps โˆ‚Djqโ†’B\partial D_j^q\to B, the completed cylinder stage in degree jj is the cylinder stage with boundary BB obtained by completing the attachment of two copies of DjqD_j^q along those maps.

The partial cylinder frame ๐–ฏ(n)\mathsf P^{(n)} consists of the stationary cylinder stages below nn, the critical cylinder stage at nn and the successor cylinder stages above nn. The shape realization of the partial cylinder frame ๐–ฏ(n)\mathsf P^{(n)} at a shape SS is Rn(S)=|S|๐–ฏ(n)R_n(S)=|S|_{\mathsf P^{(n)}}. The two endpoint frame morphisms, combined with the natural shape realization isomorphism, give shape endpoints eฮต,S:Fq(S)โ†’Rn(S)e_{\varepsilon,S}:F_q(S)\to R_n(S).โœฆ

The cylinder theory ๐’ฏn\mathcal T_n is the represented globular theory whose operations Sโ†’TS\to T are pairs (f,fฬƒ)(f,\widetilde f) satisfying (8).โœฆ Identities and composition act componentwise; an arity map is paired with its image under RnR_n.โœฆ The cylinder theory projection ฯ€:๐’ฏnโ†’C\pi:\mathcal T_n\to C retains ff.โœฆ fโˆˆC(S,T),fฬƒ:Rn(S)โ†’Rn(T),fฬƒeฮต,S=eฮต,TFq(f)(ฮต=0,1).f\in C(S,T),\qquad \widetilde f:R_n(S)\to R_n(T),\qquad \widetilde f\,e_{\varepsilon,S} =e_{\varepsilon,T}F_q(f)\quad(\varepsilon=0,1).(8)โœฆ

A section ฯƒ\sigma of ฯ€\pi determines a cylinder realization Rฯƒ:Cโ†’๐’œqR_\sigma:C\to\mathcal A_q by taking the cylinder component of each interpreted operation.โœฆ For Yโˆˆ๐’œqY\in\mathcal A_q, the full cylinder Pห†ฯƒY\widehat P_\sigma Y and its reflection PฯƒYP_\sigma Y are defined by (9). (Pห†ฯƒY)(S)=Hom⁡๐’œq(Rฯƒ(S),Y),PฯƒY=Lq(Pห†ฯƒY).(\widehat P_\sigma Y)(S)= \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal A_q}(R_\sigma(S),Y),\qquad P_\sigma Y=L_q(\widehat P_\sigma Y).(9) The full endpoint pห†ฮต:Pห†ฯƒYโ†’Y\widehat p_\varepsilon:\widehat P_\sigma Y\to Y sends a:Rฯƒ(S)โ†’Ya:R_\sigma(S)\to Y to the SS-tuple corresponding to aeฮต,Sa e_{\varepsilon,S} under (3) and Yoneda.โœฆ The reflected cylinder endpoint pฮต:PฯƒYโ†’Yp_\varepsilon:P_\sigma Y\to Y is the adjoint of the full endpoint.โœฆ

Cutoff path data for YY from degree nn are a model Pโˆˆ๐’œqP\in\mathcal A_q with two maps p0,p1:Pโ†’Yp_0,p_1:P\to Y in โ„q,0โ‹”\mathcal I_{q,0}^{\pitchfork} such that (p0,p1):Pโ†’Yร—Y(p_0,p_1):P\to Y\times Y lifts every JkqJ_k^q with kโ‰ฅnk\ge n.โœฆ Denote the collection of these data by Path⁡q,n(Y)\operatorname{Path}_{q,n}(Y).

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let CC be a globular coherator and let nโ‰คqn\le q be natural numbers. Suppose that E(q,n+1)\mathrm E(q,n+1) holds. There is a cylinder interpretation ฯƒ:Cโ†’๐’ฏn\sigma:C\to\mathcal T_n with the splitting identity (10). ฯ€โˆ˜ฯƒ=1C.\pi\circ\sigma=1_C.(10)โœฆ For every Yโˆˆ๐’œqY\in\mathcal A_q, its full and reflected cylinder endpoints have the lifting properties (11) and (12), respectively. pห†ฮต:Pห†ฯƒYโ†’Y lifts j-boundaries(jโ‰ฅ0,ฮต=0,1).\widehat p_\varepsilon:\widehat P_\sigma Y\to Y \text{ lifts }j\text{-boundaries} \qquad(j\ge0,\ \varepsilon=0,1).(11)โœฆ pฮตโˆˆโ„q,0โ‹”(ฮต=0,1).p_\varepsilon\in\mathcal I_{q,0}^{\pitchfork} \qquad(\varepsilon=0,1).(12)โœฆ Let kโ‰ฅnk\ge n, let tโˆˆ(PฯƒY)kt\in(P_\sigma Y)_k, and let u0,u1โˆˆYk+1u_0,u_1\in Y_{k+1} satisfy pฮต(t)=s(uฮต)p_\varepsilon(t)=s(u_\varepsilon). There is a cell โ„“โˆˆ(PฯƒY)k+1\ell\in(P_\sigma Y)_{k+1} with the joint source lifting identities (13). s(โ„“)=t,pฮต(โ„“)=uฮต(ฮต=0,1).s(\ell)=t,\qquad p_\varepsilon(\ell)=u_\varepsilon \quad(\varepsilon=0,1).(13)โœฆ The cylinder path datum is (14). ๐’Ÿฯƒ(Y):=(PฯƒY,p0,p1)โˆˆPath⁡q,n(Y).\mathcal D_\sigma(Y):=(P_\sigma Y,p_0,p_1) \in\operatorname{Path}_{q,n}(Y).(14)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: for fixed 0โ‰คn<q0\le n<q, assuming E(q,j)\mathrm E(q,j) for every n<jโ‰คqn<j\le q, the globular set with jj-cells Hom⁡๐’œq(Pj,Y)\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal A_q}(P_j,Y) for jโ‰คqj\le q and unique fillers above qq admits every operation of CC, giving a functor P:๐’œqโ†’๐’œqP:\mathcal A_q\to\mathcal A_q and natural model morphisms p0,p1:PYโ†’Yp_0,p_1:PY\to Y, each lifting every IjqI_j^q, while (p0,p1)(p_0,p_1) lifts JnqJ_n^q.

What Is Checked

The statement is over a globular coherator CC, natural numbers nโ‰คqn\le q, the expansion-contraction principle E(q,n+1)\mathrm E(q,n+1), and an arbitrary Yโˆˆ๐’œqY\in\mathcal A_q.

The coskeletal reflection unit is bijective on cells in dimensions at most qq. The category ๐’œq\mathcal A_q has all small limits and colimits, and the reflected representable functor FqF_q preserves elementary globular sums.โœฆ The cutoff disk cell bijections Hom⁡๐’œq(Djq,Y)โ‰…Yj\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal A_q}(D_j^q,Y)\cong Y_j commute with source and target; cutoff disk evaluation and coevaluation are the corresponding inverse globular maps between the disk nerve and the underlying globular set.