OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท 3. Cutoffs, spines and tree diagrams

Lemma 3.2 [Higher attachments preserve lower cells]: Transfinite composites and threshold generators in cutoff models

Higher attachments preserve lower cells.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let CC be a Grothendieck coherator and let ๐’œ\mathcal A be its category of models. The dimensions of attached disks and the cutoff for unique boundary fillers give two bounds against which to compare the cell maps of a model morphism.

The globe category ๐”พ\mathbb G has one object nn for each nonnegative integer, identity morphisms, and two faces mโ†’nm\to n whenever m<nm<n, distinguished as source and target. Write sn,tn:nโ†’n+1s_n,t_n:n\to n+1 for the adjacent faces. A globular set XX is a family of sets XnX_n, indexed by nonnegative integers nn, with source and target maps satisfying (1).โœฆ A globular presheaf PP is a contravariant set-valued functor on ๐”พ\mathbb G; its underlying globular set has cells P(n)P(n) and source and target maps given by its action on the adjacent faces. A morphism f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y of globular sets is a family of cell maps commuting with source and target.โœฆ A morphism a:Pโ†’Qa:P\to Q of globular presheaves induces a morphism of their underlying globular sets whose map on nn-cells is the component an:P(n)โ†’Q(n)a_n:P(n)\to Q(n). sn,tn:Xn+1โ†’Xn,snsn+1=sntn+1,tnsn+1=tntn+1.s_n,t_n:X_{n+1}\longrightarrow X_n, \qquad s_ns_{n+1}=s_nt_{n+1}, \qquad t_ns_{n+1}=t_nt_{n+1}.(1)

The representable globe ๐”ปn=๐”พ(โˆ’,n)\mathbb D_n=\mathbb G(-,n) has face maps induced by those of ๐”พ\mathbb G. A finite globular sum SS is an iterated gluing of representable globes.โœฆ If its last globe has dimension โ„“\ell, an attachment of an hh-globe glues its source bb-face to the target bb-face of that last globe, as in (2).โœฆ The previous sum and the new globe have their pushout inclusions, and the new globe becomes the last globe. A table of dimensions for a finite globular sum SS is a record of its successive gluings; its realization is SS, and its height is the greatest dimension of its globes. For a table ending in dimension โ„“\ell, the last globe inclusion ๐”ปโ„“โ†’S\mathbb D_\ell\to S is the distinguished inclusion of its last globe into the realization SS. The gluing face inclusion ๐”ปbโ†’S\mathbb D_b\to S is the target bb-face of the last globe followed by its inclusion into SS, for b<โ„“b<\ell. The globe inclusion into finite globular sums sends nn to ๐”ปn\mathbb D_n and each face to the corresponding map of representable globes. Sโ€ฒ=Sโˆ๐”ปb๐”ปh,b<โ„“,b<h,ht⁡(Sโ€ฒ)=max⁡{ht⁡(S),h}.S'=S\amalg_{\mathbb D_b}\mathbb D_h, \qquad b<\ell,\quad b<h, \qquad \operatorname{ht}(S')=\max\{\operatorname{ht}(S),h\}.(2)

A globular theory CC is a category under finite globular sums whose arity functor preserves the elementary pushouts in (2).โœฆ A morphism of globular theories is a functor fixing the arities and preserving their structural maps.โœฆ Two operations u,v:๐”ปnโ†’Su,v:\mathbb D_n\to S in a globular theory CC are parallel when their source and target restrictions agree; in dimension zero there is no condition.โœฆ An admissible pair (u,v)(u,v) in CC is a pair of parallel operations ๐”ปnโ†’S\mathbb D_n\to S with ht⁡(S)โ‰คn+1\operatorname{ht}(S)\le n+1.โœฆ A filler zz of an admissible pair (u,v)(u,v) in CC is an operation with the restrictions in (3).โœฆ The globe inclusion ๐”พโ†’C\mathbb G\to C is the composite of the globe inclusion into finite globular sums with the arity functor of CC. z:๐”ปn+1โ†’S,zโˆ˜sn=u,zโˆ˜tn=v.z:\mathbb D_{n+1}\longrightarrow S, \qquad z\circ s_n=u,\qquad z\circ t_n=v.(3)

A free extension a:Eโ†’Eโ€ฒa:E\to E' of globular theories by a family of admissible pairs is a theory morphism adjoining specified fillers with this universal property: a theory morphism out of the original theory, together with fillers for the images of the pairs, extends uniquely to a morphism carrying the adjoined fillers to the chosen ones.โœฆ A cellular presentation Cโ€ขC_\bullet of CC is a sequence of such free extensions, starting at an initial theory, whose compatible inclusions exhibit CC as its colimit.โœฆ A Grothendieck coherator CC is a globular theory admitting a cellular presentation and a filler for every admissible pair.โœฆ

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC sending elementary globular sums to pullbacks, as in (4).โœฆ A model morphism f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y is a natural transformation. Restriction to the globes gives the underlying globular set of XX; write XnX_n for its nn-cells and fn:Xnโ†’Ynf_n:X_n\to Y_n for the induced cell maps. X(Sโ€ฒ)โ‰…X(S)ร—X(๐”ปb)X(๐”ปh).X(S')\cong X(S)\mathbin{\times}_{X(\mathbb D_b)}X(\mathbb D_h).(4)

The free model hSh_S on a shape SS is the representable presheaf C(โˆ’,S)C(-,S).โœฆ The free disk Dn=h๐”ปnD_n=h_{\mathbb D_n} is the free model on ๐”ปn\mathbb D_n, and its disk Yoneda correspondence is (5). ๐’œ(Dn,X)โ‰…Xn.\mathcal A(D_n,X)\cong X_n.(5)โœฆ

Attachments and Cutoffs

Two cells x,yโˆˆXnx,y\in X_n of a model XX are parallel when they have the same source and target if n>0n>0; all zero-dimensional cells are parallel.โœฆ The set BnXB_nX of nn-boundaries and the boundary map โˆ‚n\partial_n are given by (6), with โˆ‚0\partial_0 the unique map to the singleton. A morphism f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y induces a boundary map BnfB_nf by applying ff to both members of a parallel pair.โœฆ B0X={*},Bn+1X={(x,y)โˆˆXn2โˆฃxโˆฅy},โˆ‚n+1(x)=(snx,tnx).B_0X=\{*\},\qquad B_{n+1}X=\{(x,y)\in X_n^2\mid x\parallel y\}, \qquad \partial_{n+1}(x)=(s_nx,t_nx).(6)

The canonical boundary model โˆ‚Dn\partial D_n represents BnB_n, naturally in XX. Brackets denote the cell or boundary represented by a disk or boundary map. The boundary inclusion In:โˆ‚Dnโ†’DnI_n:\partial D_n\to D_n is the map representing the boundary operation in (7).โœฆ The source inclusion Jn:Dnโ†’Dn+1J_n:D_n\to D_{n+1} is the map of free models induced by sns_n.โœฆ In:โˆ‚Dnโ†’Dn,๐’œ(โˆ‚Dn,X)โ‰…BnX,[aโˆ˜In]=โˆ‚n[a](a:Dnโ†’X).I_n:\partial D_n\longrightarrow D_n, \qquad \mathcal A(\partial D_n,X)\cong B_nX, \qquad [a\circ I_n]=\partial_n[a]\quad(a:D_n\to X).(7)โœฆ

A boundary attachment i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y is a morphism freely adjoining a family of cells cฮฑโˆˆYdฮฑc_\alpha\in Y_{d_\alpha} along boundaries ฮฒฮฑโˆˆBdฮฑX\beta_\alpha\in B_{d_\alpha}X, indexed by a set KK.โœฆ Its boundary condition and universal property are (8), where ZZ is any model and the displayed bijection sends hh to (hโˆ˜i,(hdฮฑ(cฮฑ))ฮฑ)(h\circ i,(h_{d_\alpha}(c_\alpha))_\alpha). โˆ‚dฮฑcฮฑ=(Bdฮฑi)(ฮฒฮฑ),๐’œ(Y,Z)โ‰…{(g,(zฮฑ)ฮฑ)|g:Xโ†’Z,zฮฑโˆˆZdฮฑ,โˆ‚dฮฑzฮฑ=(Bdฮฑg)(ฮฒฮฑ)}.\begin{gathered} \partial_{d_\alpha}c_\alpha=(B_{d_\alpha}i)(\beta_\alpha),\\ \mathcal A(Y,Z)\cong \left\{(g,(z_\alpha)_\alpha)\ \middle|\ \begin{gathered} g:X\to Z,\quad z_\alpha\in Z_{d_\alpha},\\ \partial_{d_\alpha}z_\alpha=(B_{d_\alpha}g)(\beta_\alpha) \end{gathered}\right\}. \end{gathered}(8)

For a nonnegative integer qq, a model XX is coskeletal at cutoff qq when every boundary above qq has a unique filler, as in (9).โœฆ Write ๐’œq\mathcal A_q for the full subcategory of these models.โœฆ โˆ‚j:Xjโ†’BjXis bijective for every j>q.\partial_j:X_j\longrightarrow B_jX\ \text{is bijective for every }j>q.(9)

The coskeletal reflection Rq:๐’œโ†’๐’œqR_q:\mathcal A\to\mathcal A_q is the left adjoint to the inclusion, with unit ฮทX:Xโ†’RqX\eta_X:X\to R_qX. For Yโˆˆ๐’œqY\in\mathcal A_q, its adjunction bijection ฮฆX,Y\Phi_{X,Y} is (10).โœฆ ฮฆX,Y:๐’œq(RqX,Y)โ†’โ‰…๐’œ(X,Y),hโ†ฆhโˆ˜ฮทX.\Phi_{X,Y}:\mathcal A_q(R_qX,Y)\xrightarrow{\ \cong\ }\mathcal A(X,Y), \qquad h\longmapsto h\circ\eta_X.(10)โœฆ

The reflected disks and boundaries are RqDjR_qD_j and Rq(โˆ‚Dj)R_q(\partial D_j); their reflected inclusions are RqIjR_qI_j and RqJjR_qJ_j. The boundary and source generating classes โ„q,r\mathcal I_{q,r} and ๐’ฅq,r\mathcal J_{q,r} in ๐’œq\mathcal A_q, with lower dimension bound rr, consist of the reflected boundary and source inclusions in (11). โ„q,r={RqIjโˆฃjโ‰ฅr},๐’ฅq,r={RqJjโˆฃjโ‰ฅr}.\mathcal I_{q,r}=\{R_qI_j\mid j\ge r\}, \qquad \mathcal J_{q,r}=\{R_qJ_j\mid j\ge r\}.(11)

For a class ๐’ฆ\mathcal K of maps, ๐’ฆโ–ซ\mathcal K^\square is the class having the right lifting property against ๐’ฆ\mathcal K, and โ–ซ๐’ฆ\,{}^\square\mathcal K is the class having the left lifting property against ๐’ฆ\mathcal K. The class cof⁡(๐’ฆ)\operatorname{cof}(\mathcal K) of cofibrations generated by a class ๐’ฆ\mathcal K of maps consists of the maps having the left lifting property against ๐’ฆโ–ซ\mathcal K^\square, as in (12). cof⁡(๐’ฆ)=โ–ซ(๐’ฆโ–ซ).\operatorname{cof}(\mathcal K)={}^\square(\mathcal K^\square).(12)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let CC be a Grothendieck coherator.

Let i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y be a boundary attachment with dฮฑ>qd_\alpha>q for every ฮฑโˆˆK\alpha\in K. For jโ‰คqj\le q, ij:Xjโ†’Yjis bijective.i_j:X_j\longrightarrow Y_j\quad\text{is bijective}.(13)โœฆ

Suppose f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y is a transfinite composite represented by a continuous well-ordered diagram FF with least stage XX and colimit YY. Suppose every nonterminal successor map of FF is bijective in each degree at most qq. Then fk:Xkโ†’Ykis bijective for kโ‰คq.f_k:X_k\longrightarrow Y_k\quad\text{is bijective for }k\le q.(14)โœฆ

Consider the pushout i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y of JnJ_n along a map a:Dnโ†’Xa:D_n\to X. For k<nk<n, ik:Xkโ†’Ykis bijective.i_k:X_k\longrightarrow Y_k\quad\text{is bijective}.(15)โœฆ

Suppose X,Yโˆˆ๐’œqX,Y\in\mathcal A_q and i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y belongs to cof⁡(โ„q,r)\operatorname{cof}(\mathcal I_{q,r}), with kโ‰คqk\le q and k<rk<r. Then ik:Xkโ†’Ykis bijective.i_k:X_k\longrightarrow Y_k\quad\text{is bijective}.(16)โœฆ

For every q,rq,r, cof⁡(๐’ฅq,r)โІcof⁡(โ„q,r).\operatorname{cof}(\mathcal J_{q,r}) \subseteq\operatorname{cof}(\mathcal I_{q,r}).(17)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: for kโ‰ฅ0k\ge0, a relative cellular extension using only IjI_j with j>kj>k is bijective on cells in all degrees at most kk in ๐’œ\mathcal A; the same holds in ๐’œq\mathcal A_q when k<qk<q, and consequently for relative extensions using only JjJ_j with j>kj>k, with generators in ๐’œq\mathcal A_q understood as their reflections.

What Is Checked

The statements (13), (14) and (15) are over models of a coherator; (16) and (17) are over the full subcategory ๐’œq\mathcal A_q and its reflected generating maps.

For every model XX, the reflection unit has the component property (18). The adjunction bijection of (10) is natural in coskeletal models, as in (19), for h:RqXโ†’Yh:R_qX\to Y and g:Yโ†’Yโ€ฒg:Y\to Y' in ๐’œq\mathcal A_q.โœฆ ฮทX,n:Xnโ†’(RqX)nis bijective for nโ‰คq.\eta_{X,n}:X_n\longrightarrow(R_qX)_n\quad\text{is bijective for }n\le q.(18) ฮฆX,Yโ€ฒ(gโˆ˜h)=gโˆ˜ฮฆX,Y(h).\Phi_{X,Y'}(g\circ h)=g\circ\Phi_{X,Y}(h).(19)โœฆ