OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 ยท 3. Cutoffs, spines and tree diagrams

ยง3 (setting): cutoff models and the induction hypothesis: Reflected disk inclusions define cofibrancy and the expansion-contraction predicate

Boundary lifting in cutoff model categories.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Source attachments in globular models are studied through boundary lifting and the preservation of fillers. A cutoff separates low-dimensional cell data from the dimensions in which cells are determined by their boundaries.

The globe category ๐”พ\mathbb G has one object gjg_j in each natural dimension jj, identities, and two face maps gmโ†’gjg_m\to g_j whenever m<jm<j. Write ฯƒj,ฯ„j:gjโ†’gj+1\sigma_j,\tau_j:g_j\to g_{j+1} for its source and target inclusions. A globular presheaf XX on ๐”พ\mathbb G is a contravariant set-valued functor whose underlying globular set has cells Xj=X(gj)X_j=X(g_j) and source and target maps given by its actions on ฯƒj\sigma_j and ฯ„j\tau_j. The representable globular disk dj=๐”พ(โˆ’,gj)d_j=\mathbb G(-,g_j) has face maps induced by Yoneda. A morphism f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y of globular sets is a family of maps fj:Xjโ†’Yjf_j:X_j\to Y_j commuting with source and target.

A shape SS is a finite globular sum described by a table of dimensions with a distinguished last globe.โœฆ Such a table starts with one globe and successively attaches a globe of dimension hh along its source bb-face to the target bb-face of the previous last globe of dimension โ„“\ell, with b<โ„“b<\ell and b<hb<h.โœฆ The realization of a shape SS is the iterated pushout of representable disks prescribed by its table of dimensions, with the inclusion of the distinguished last globe. The dimension of SS is the greatest dimension of its globes.โœฆ For an attachment, the gluing face inclusion is the target face followed by the last globe inclusion; the previous shape and the new globe enter the attached shape by the two pushout inclusions.

A globular theory CC is a category under the category of globular arities, the finite globular sums, with an arity functor ฮน\iota from that category to CC that is the identity on objects and preserves the elementary gluing pushouts.โœฆ The globe inclusion into CC is the composite of the Yoneda inclusion of globes into shapes with ฮน\iota.โœฆ A morphism F:Cโ†’Cโ€ฒF:C\to Cโ€ฒ of globular theories is a functor that fixes arities and preserves their structural maps, as well as identities and composition of operations.โœฆ

Two operations u,v:gjโ†’Su,v:g_j\to S in a globular theory CC are parallel when their source and target restrictions agree, with no condition in dimension zero.โœฆ An admissible pair is a parallel pair u,v:gjโ†’Su,v:g_j\to S with dim⁡Sโ‰คj+1\dim S\le j+1.โœฆ A filler z:gj+1โ†’Sz:g_{j+1}\to S for an admissible pair u,v:gjโ†’Su,v:g_j\to S in a globular theory is an operation whose restrictions are uu and vv; along a theory morphism, the restrictions instead equal their images.โœฆ A free extension by fillers for a family of admissible pairs in a globular theory CC is a theory morphism F:Cโ†’Cโ€ฒF:C\to Cโ€ฒ adjoining specified fillers, universally among theory morphisms with a choice of fillers for the images of those pairs.โœฆ

A cellular presentation of a globular theory CC is a sequence starting with an initial theory, whose successive maps are free extensions by fillers for specified families of admissible pairs, with compatible maps to CC exhibiting CC as their colimit.โœฆ A Grothendieck coherator CC is a globular theory admitting such a cellular presentation and a filler for every admissible pair in CC.โœฆ

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC that sends elementary globular sums to pullbacks.โœฆ Write Mod(C)\mathrm{Mod}(C) for the category of models. Restriction along the globe inclusion gives the underlying globular set, with jj-cells XjX_j and source and target maps s,t:Xj+1โ†’Xjs,t:X_{j+1}\to X_j satisfying ss=stss=st and ts=ttts=tt.โœฆ A morphism f:Xโ†’Yf:X\to Y induces the dimensionwise maps fjf_j of this restriction, commuting with source and target.โœฆ

Two cells x,yx,y of a model XX of CC are parallel when they have the same source and target; all zero-dimensional cells are parallel.โœฆ The boundary sets and boundary maps are given by (1), where ** denotes the unique zero-dimensional boundary. B0(X)={*},b0X(x)=*,Bj+1(X)={(x,y)โˆˆXj2โˆฃx and y are parallel},bj+1X(z)=(s(z),t(z)).\begin{aligned} B_0(X)&=\{*\}, & b_0^X(x)&=*,\\ B_{j+1}(X)&=\{(x,y)\in X_j^2\mid x\text{ and }y\text{ are parallel}\}, & b_{j+1}^X(z)&=(s(z),t(z)). \end{aligned}(1) The induced map Bj(f)B_j(f) fixes the unique boundary in dimension zero and applies fjโˆ’1f_{j-1} to both members of a positive-dimensional boundary.โœฆ A model XX of CC has fillers for every boundary, written ๐–ฅ๐—‚๐—…๐—…(X)\mathsf{Fill}(X), when the maps bjXb_j^X are surjective in every dimension.โœฆ

The free model on a shape SS is the representable presheaf C(โˆ’,S)C(-,S).โœฆ The free disk Dj=C(โˆ’,gj)D_j=C(-,g_j) represents jj-cells by the Yoneda correspondence.โœฆ The boundary โˆ‚Dj\partial D_j of the free disk DjD_j is the model of the canonical boundary representation of BjB_j.โœฆ These representations give the natural bijections in (2). Mod(C)(Dj,X)โ‰…Xj,Mod(C)(โˆ‚Dj,X)โ‰…Bj(X).\mathrm{Mod}(C)(D_j,X)\cong X_j, \qquad \mathrm{Mod}(C)(\partial D_j,X)\cong B_j(X).(2) The boundary inclusion Ij:โˆ‚Djโ†’DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j is the map whose restriction on represented maps corresponds to bjXb_j^X under (2).โœฆ The source inclusion Jj:Djโ†’Dj+1J_j:D_j\to D_{j+1} is induced by ฯƒj\sigma_j through the arity functor and Yoneda.โœฆ

For a class ๐’ฆ\mathcal K of morphisms, write ๐’ฆโ–ซ\mathcal K^{\square} for the maps with the right lifting property against every member of ๐’ฆ\mathcal K, and โ–ซ๐’ฆ{}^{\square}\mathcal K for the maps with the left lifting property against every member of ๐’ฆ\mathcal K. A cellular model XX of CC is a model with a transfinite presentation by boundary attachments.

The Claim

Definition 1. Fix a Grothendieck coherator CC and a natural cutoff qq. A qq-coskeletal model XX is a model satisfying (3). X is q-coskeletalโ‡”bjX:Xjโ†’Bj(X) is bijective for every j>q.X\text{ is }q\text{-coskeletal} \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad b_j^X:X_j\longrightarrow B_j(X)\text{ is bijective for every }j>q.(3)โœฆ The cutoff category ๐’œq\mathcal A_q is the full subcategory in (4). ๐’œq=Mod(C){XโˆฃX is q-coskeletal}.\mathcal A_q=\mathrm{Mod}(C)_{\{X\mid X\text{ is }q\text{-coskeletal}\}}.(4)โœฆ Write Rq:Mod(C)โ†’๐’œqR_q:\mathrm{Mod}(C)\to\mathcal A_q for the chosen coskeletal reflection functor and ฮทX:Xโ†’RqX\eta_X:X\to R_qX for its unit. The reflected disks and boundary inclusions, together with the reflected source inclusions, are those of (5). Dj(q)=RqDj,โˆ‚Dj(q)=Rqโˆ‚Dj,Ij(q)=RqIj:โˆ‚Dj(q)โ†’Dj(q),Jj(q)=RqJj:Dj(q)โ†’Dj+1(q).\begin{aligned} D_j^{(q)}&=R_qD_j,& \partial D_j^{(q)}&=R_q\partial D_j,\\ I_j^{(q)}&=R_qI_j:\partial D_j^{(q)}\to D_j^{(q)},& J_j^{(q)}&=R_qJ_j:D_j^{(q)}\to D_{j+1}^{(q)}. \end{aligned}(5) For a natural lower bound rr, the generating boundary class โ„q,r\mathcal I_{q,r} and the generating source class ๐’ฅq,r\mathcal J_{q,r} are defined by (6) and (7), respectively. โ„q,r={Ij(q)โˆฃjโ‰ฅr}.\mathcal I_{q,r}=\{I_j^{(q)}\mid j\ge r\}.(6)โœฆ ๐’ฅq,r={Jj(q)โˆฃjโ‰ฅr}.\mathcal J_{q,r}=\{J_j^{(q)}\mid j\ge r\}.(7)โœฆ A cofibrant object XX of ๐’œq\mathcal A_q is an object satisfying (8), where p*p_* denotes postcomposition and P,QP,Q range over ๐’œq\mathcal A_q. Cof⁡(X)โ‡”for every (p:Pโ†’Q)โˆˆโ„q,0โ–ซ,p*:๐’œq(X,P)โ†’๐’œq(X,Q) is surjective.\begin{aligned} \operatorname{Cof}(X)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad &\text{for every }(p:P\to Q)\in\mathcal I_{q,0}^{\square},\\ &p_*:\mathcal A_q(X,P)\longrightarrow\mathcal A_q(X,Q) \text{ is surjective}. \end{aligned}(8)โœฆ The expansion-contraction predicate ๐–ค๐–ข(q,r)\mathsf{EC}(q,r) is the assertion (9) for every morphism i:Xโ†’Yi:X\to Y in ๐’œq\mathcal A_q. ๐–ค๐–ข(q,r):iโˆˆโ–ซ(๐’ฅq,rโ–ซ)Cof⁡(X)๐–ฅ๐—‚๐—…๐—…(X)}โ‡’๐–ฅ๐—‚๐—…๐—…(Y).\mathsf{EC}(q,r):\qquad \left. \begin{gathered} i\in{}^{\square}(\mathcal J_{q,r}^{\square})\\ \operatorname{Cof}(X)\\ \mathsf{Fill}(X) \end{gathered} \right\} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \mathsf{Fill}(Y).(9)โœฆ

Theorem 1. Let CC be a Grothendieck coherator and let qq be a natural cutoff. For every small category BB and every diagram F:Bโ†’๐’œqF:B\to\mathcal A_q, the colimit in (10) and the limit in (11) exist. colimbโˆˆBF(b) exists in ๐’œq.\operatorname*{colim}_{b\in B}F(b)\text{ exists in }\mathcal A_q.(10)โœฆ limbโˆˆBF(b) exists in ๐’œq.\operatorname*{lim}_{b\in B}F(b)\text{ exists in }\mathcal A_q.(11)โœฆ

In the paper, the result reads: a model is qq-coskeletal when every boundary of dimension j>qj>q has a unique filler, ๐’œq\mathcal A_q is their full subcategory, and, for 0โ‰คnโ‰คq0\le n\le q, E(q,n)E(q,n) says that pushing out JnJ_n along any cell of any cellular object in ๐’œq\mathcal A_q gives a weak equivalence; at a step 0โ‰คn<q0\le n<q, one assumes E(q,j)E(q,j) for every n<jโ‰คqn<j\le q, and an upper attachment has index >n>n.

What Is Checked

The setting is stated for a Grothendieck coherator CC, with arbitrary natural cutoff qq and lower bound rr, using the reflected inclusions in (5).

For every model XX, a coskeletal reflection and its unit exist; the unit has the properties in (12), with YY ranging over ๐’œq\mathcal A_q. (ฮทX)j:Xjโ†’(RqX)jis bijective for jโ‰คq,๐’œq(RqX,Y)โ†’โ‰…Mod(C)(X,Y),hโ†ฆhโˆ˜ฮทX.\begin{aligned} (\eta_X)_j &: X_j\longrightarrow (R_qX)_j &&\text{is bijective for }j\le q,\\ \mathcal A_q(R_qX,Y)&\xrightarrow{\ \cong\ } \mathrm{Mod}(C)(X,Y), &&h\longmapsto h\circ\eta_X. \end{aligned}(12)โœฆ The hom-set correspondence in (12) is natural in YY under postcomposition.โœฆ