OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · 2. Globular models and the weak-equivalence test

Lemma 2.7 [Lifting tests]: Reflected disk inclusions in coskeletal models and the source of an identity cell

Comparing source and boundary lifting tests.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The lifting tests for globular models compare extension with a prescribed source with extension with a prescribed boundary. The library states the comparison for globular sets and for reflected disk inclusions in categories of coskeletal models.

The globe category 𝔾\mathbb G has the natural numbers as objects, an identity in each dimension, and two face maps from mm to jj when m<jm<j. Its adjacent source and target maps are denoted by σj,τj:j→j+1\sigma_j,\tau_j:j\to j+1. A globular presheaf is a functor 𝔾op→Set\mathbb G^{\mathrm{op}}\to\mathrm{Set}.✦ The representable disk dj=𝔾(−,j)d_j=\mathbb G(-,j) has face inclusions induced by those of 𝔾\mathbb G.

A finite globular sum SS is a pasting shape specified by a table of dimensions with a distinguished last globe.✦ Starting from one globe, a table adjoins an hh-globe by gluing its source bb-face to the target bb-face of the preceding last globe, where bb is smaller than both last dimensions.✦ The realization |S||S| is the corresponding iterated pushout of representable disks, with its last globe inclusion; the height of SS is the greatest dimension occurring. An elementary attachment of a new globe to a preceding shape is a gluing with inclusions of the preceding shape and the new globe.

A globular theory CC is a category with finite globular sums as objects and an arity functor from shapes that fixes objects and sends elementary globular gluings to pushouts.✦ A morphism of globular theories is a functor fixing arities and preserving their structural maps.✦ Two operations from the jj-globe to a shape SS are parallel when their source and target restrictions agree; in dimension zero every pair is parallel.✦ An admissible pair of operations from the jj-globe to a shape SS is a pair of parallel operations with height⁡(S)≤j+1\operatorname{height}(S)\le j+1.✦ Given a morphism F:C→DF:C\to D of globular theories and an admissible pair (a,b)(a,b) of operations from the jj-globe to a shape SS in CC, a filler of the pair is an operation zz from the (j+1)(j+1)-globe to SS in DD whose source and target restrictions are F(a)F(a) and F(b)F(b), respectively.

A free extension by fillers is a theory morphism adjoining specified fillers for a family of admissible pairs, universal among theory morphisms supplied with fillers for that family.✦ A cellular presentation of CC is a sequence of such free extensions starting at an initial theory, with compatible maps to CC exhibiting it as their colimit.✦ A coherator is a globular theory admitting a cellular presentation in which every admissible pair has a filler.✦

A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC sending elementary globular sums to pullbacks; model morphisms are natural transformations. The free model on a shape SS is the representable C(−,S)C(-,S), and the free jj-disk DjD_j is the free model on the jj-globe. Evaluation of an operation a:S→Ta:S\to T is the map X(a):X(T)→X(S)X(a):X(T)\to X(S).✦ Restriction along the globe inclusion into shapes and then into CC gives the underlying globular set of XX; restriction of a model morphism gives its underlying globular map.

Cells and Lifting

A globular set XX is a family of cell sets XjX_j with source and target maps s,t:Xj+1→Xjs,t:X_{j+1}\to X_j satisfying the identities in (1).✦ The underlying globular set of a globular presheaf PP has jj-cells P(j)P(j), with source and target maps given by its action on σj\sigma_j and τj\tau_j.✦ s(s(x))=s(t(x)),t(s(x))=t(t(x))(x∈Xj+2).s(s(x))=s(t(x)),\qquad t(s(x))=t(t(x))\qquad(x\in X_{j+2}).(1) Two positive-dimensional cells are parallel if they have the same source and target; all zero-dimensional cells are parallel.✦ The boundary set BjXB_jX and boundary map ∂j:Xj→BjX\partial_j:X_j\to B_jX are defined by (2). B0X={*},∂0(x)=*,Bj+1X={(u,v)∈Xj×Xj∣u∥v},∂j+1(x)=(s(x),t(x)).\begin{aligned} B_0X&=\{*\}, & \partial_0(x)&=*,\\ B_{j+1}X&=\{(u,v)\in X_j\times X_j\mid u\parallel v\}, &\partial_{j+1}(x)&=(s(x),t(x)). \end{aligned}(2) A globular set XX has fillers for every boundary if each of its boundary maps ∂j\partial_j is surjective.

A globular map f:X→Yf:X\to Y is a family of maps fj:Xj→Yjf_j:X_j\to Y_j commuting with source and target.✦ The boundary map BjfB_jf induced by a globular map f:X→Yf:X\to Y is the unique map in dimension zero and applies fjf_j to both entries of a boundary in dimension j+1j+1.✦ A globular map f:X→Yf:X\to Y has source lifting in dimension jj if, for x∈Xjx\in X_j and y∈Yj+1y\in Y_{j+1} with s(y)=fj(x)s(y)=f_j(x), there is a cell z∈Xj+1z\in X_{j+1} with s(z)=xs(z)=x and fj+1(z)=yf_{j+1}(z)=y.✦ A natural transformation α:P⇒Q\alpha:P\Rightarrow Q between globular presheaves induces the globular map whose component in dimension jj is αj:P(j)→Q(j)\alpha_j:P(j)\to Q(j).

The canonical boundary object ∂Dj\partial D_j of a globular theory CC is a model with an inclusion Ij:∂Dj→DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j representing cell boundaries. The natural correspondences in (3) identify restriction along IjI_j with ∂j\partial_j. Hom⁡(Dj,X)≅Xj,Hom⁡(∂Dj,X)≅BjX.\operatorname{Hom}(D_j,X)\cong X_j,\qquad \operatorname{Hom}(\partial D_j,X)\cong B_jX.(3) The canonical boundary representations start with the empty boundary in dimension zero and continue by the successor boundary construction.✦ The source inclusion Jj:Dj→Dj+1J_j:D_j\to D_{j+1} is induced by the source face through the Yoneda embedding.✦ For a class 𝒦\mathcal K of maps, 𝒦-inj\mathcal K\text{-inj} denotes the maps having the right lifting property against every member of 𝒦\mathcal K; write ℐ={Ij∣j≥0}\mathcal I=\{I_j\mid j\ge0\} and 𝒥={Jj∣j≥0}\mathcal J=\{J_j\mid j\ge0\}. The disk correspondence in (3) sends a map to its value on the identity of the jj-globe.

When CC is a coherator, its identity boundary pair in dimension jj consists of two identity operations on the jj-globe.✦ For a coherator CC, the identity operation uju_j from the (j+1)(j+1)-globe to the jj-globe is a chosen filler of the pair of identity operations on the jj-globe.✦ The identity cell 1x1_x of an x∈Xjx\in X_j is the cell X(uj)(x)∈Xj+1X(u_j)(x)\in X_{j+1}.✦

Coskeletal Models

For a cutoff dimension qq, a model XX is qq-coskeletal if every boundary in dimension j>qj>q has a unique filler.✦ The category AqA_q of qq-coskeletal models of CC is the full subcategory of the category of models of CC whose objects are the qq-coskeletal models.✦ For a coherator CC, write Mod⁡(C)\operatorname{Mod}(C) for its category of models. The chosen coskeletal reflection functor Rq:Mod⁡(C)→AqR_q:\operatorname{Mod}(C)\to A_q has unit ηX:X→RqX\eta_X:X\to R_qX and the bijection in (4), given by composition with ηX\eta_X. Hom⁡Aq(RqX,Y)≅Hom⁡Mod⁡(C)(X,Y)(Y∈Aq).\operatorname{Hom}_{A_q}(R_qX,Y) \cong \operatorname{Hom}_{\operatorname{Mod}(C)}(X,Y) \qquad(Y\in A_q).(4) The reflected free disks and boundaries are RqDjR_qD_j and Rq∂DjR_q\partial D_j; the reflected inclusions are RqIjR_qI_j and RqJjR_qJ_j. For a lower dimension bound rr, the generating boundary and source classes in AqA_q are the families in (5). ℐq,r={RqIj∣j≥r},𝒥q,r={RqJj∣j≥r}.\mathcal I_{q,r}=\{R_qI_j\mid j\ge r\},\qquad \mathcal J_{q,r}=\{R_qJ_j\mid j\ge r\}.(5)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let f:X→Yf:X\to Y be a globular map between globular sets having fillers for every boundary, and suppose ff has source lifting in dimension jj. For a boundary b∈BjXb\in B_jX and a cell y∈Yjy\in Y_j with ∂j(y)=Bjf(b)\partial_j(y)=B_jf(b), there is a lift as in (6). ∃x∈Xj,(∂j(x),fj(x))=(b,y).\exists x\in X_j,\qquad (\partial_j(x),f_j(x))=(b,y).(6)✦ Let CC be a coherator, let q,r≥0q,r\ge0, and let p:X→Yp:X\to Y be a morphism in AqA_q whose underlying globular sets have fillers for every boundary. If p∈𝒥q,r-injp\in\mathcal J_{q,r}\text{-inj}, it satisfies (7). p∈ℐq,r-inj.p\in\mathcal I_{q,r}\text{-inj}.(7)✦ For any globular theory CC, let p:X→Yp:X\to Y be a model morphism having the right lifting property against IjI_j and Ij+1I_{j+1}. It has the property in (8). p∈{Jj}-inj.p\in\{J_j\}\text{-inj}.(8)✦ For a coherator CC and a model XX, every cell x∈Xjx\in X_j satisfies (9). s(1x)=x.s(1_x)=x.(9)✦

In the paper, writing WW for the class of weak equivalences, the result reads: a weak equivalence with the right lifting property against JjJ_j has the right lifting property against IjI_j; ℐ-inj=W∩𝒥-inj\mathcal I\text{-inj}=W\cap\mathcal J\text{-inj}; and every model’s map to the terminal model belongs to 𝒥-inj\mathcal J\text{-inj}.

What Is Checked

The cellwise statement is over globular maps with source lifting and boundary fillers on both sides; the reflected statement is over morphisms in AqA_q with the same filler hypotheses and the generating classes above a dimension bound. The adjacent boundary test is over models of an arbitrary globular theory, whereas the identity cell statement uses a coherator.

The unit of the coskeletal reflection is bijective on jj-cells for j≤qj\le q.✦ The reflection bijection commutes with postcomposition by morphisms in AqA_q.✦