OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · 2. Globular models and the weak-equivalence test

§2 (setting): Definition 2.6 [Contractibility]: The zero-dimensional condition and the extension criteria for free disks and their coskeletal reflections

Filling boundaries before and after cutoff.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A map from a globular boundary to a model prescribes the boundary of a cell. The extension problem asks for a map from the corresponding disk, including when the prescribed boundary is empty in dimension zero.

The globe category has one object in each dimension j∈ℕj\in\mathbb N, its identity, and two face maps from dimension ii to dimension jj whenever i<ji<j. The adjacent faces are the source and target inclusions. A globular presheaf is a contravariant set-valued functor on this category.✦ For a globular presheaf PP, its underlying globular set GG has jj-cells Gj=P(j)G_j=P(j) and source and target maps sj,tj:Gj+1→Gjs_j,t_j:G_{j+1}\to G_j given by the action of PP on the adjacent source and target inclusions, satisfying (1). sjsj+1=sjtj+1,tjsj+1=tjtj+1.s_j s_{j+1}=s_j t_{j+1},\qquad t_j s_{j+1}=t_j t_{j+1}.(1) A morphism of globular sets is a family of maps commuting with source and target; a natural transformation of globular presheaves induces such a morphism by its components at the globes. The representable globe y(j)y(j) is the Yoneda presheaf of the dimension-jj object, with face maps induced by Yoneda.

A shape SS is a finite globular sum specified by a table of dimensions with a distinguished last globe.✦ The realization of a shape SS is the iterated pushout of representable globes described by its table of dimensions.✦ If the last globe has dimension ℓ\ell, an attachment of a globe of dimension hh along dimension bb requires b<ℓb<\ell and b<hb<h: its source bb-face is glued to the target bb-face of the last globe. The gluing face is this target face followed by the last globe inclusion; the previous shape and the new globe enter through the two pushout inclusions, and the latter is the new last globe inclusion. The height ht⁡(S)\operatorname{ht}(S) of a shape SS is the greatest globe dimension in its table of dimensions.✦

A globular theory CC is a category with these shapes as objects and an arity functor from shapes that fixes objects and preserves the elementary globular pushouts.✦ A model XX of CC is a presheaf on CC that takes these pushouts to pullbacks.✦ Write Mod⁡(C)\operatorname{Mod}(C) for its category of models and UXUX for the globular set obtained by restriction along the globe inclusion into shapes and then into CC. A model morphism induces the corresponding globular map by restriction.✦ The free model F(S)F(S) on a shape is the representable C(−,S)C(-,S); the free jj-disk is Dj=F(y(j))D_j=F(y(j)).

Boundaries and Reflection

Two cells a,b∈Gja,b\in G_j of a globular set GG are parallel, written a∥Gba\parallel_G b, unconditionally when j=0j=0, and in positive dimensions when their sources agree and their targets agree.✦ A joining cell h∈Gj+1h\in G_{j+1} for cells a,b∈Gja,b\in G_j of a globular set GG is a cell with sj(h)=as_j(h)=a and tj(h)=bt_j(h)=b.✦ The sets Bj(G)B_j(G) of boundaries and the boundary maps βj\beta_j are defined by (2). B0(G)={*},β0:G0→{*},Bj+1(G)={(a,b)∈Gj×Gj:a∥Gb},βj+1(h)=(sj(h),tj(h)).\begin{gathered} B_0(G)=\{*\},\qquad \beta_0:G_0\longrightarrow\{*\},\\ B_{j+1}(G)=\{(a,b)\in G_j\times G_j:a\parallel_G b\},\qquad \beta_{j+1}(h)=(s_j(h),t_j(h)). \end{gathered}(2) A globular map f:G→Hf:G\to H induces a map on boundaries that sends ** to ** and applies ff to both cells in every positive-dimensional boundary.✦

The canonical boundary representation consists of a model ∂Dj\partial D_j and an inclusion Ij:∂Dj→DjI_j:\partial D_j\to D_j, starting with the empty zero-dimensional boundary and proceeding by the successor boundary construction.✦ Its representing bijection and the disk Yoneda bijection are (3), naturally in the model XX. Mod⁡(C)(∂Dj,X)≅Bj(UX),Mod⁡(C)(Dj,X)≅(UX)j.\operatorname{Mod}(C)(\partial D_j,X)\cong B_j(UX),\qquad \operatorname{Mod}(C)(D_j,X)\cong (UX)_j.(3) Under (3), restriction along IjI_j corresponds to βj\beta_j; the disk bijection evaluates a map on the identity of the globe arity.

A morphism of globular theories is a functor fixing the arities and their structural maps.✦ Two operations a,b:y(j)→Sa,b:y(j)\to S in a globular theory CC are parallel when their restrictions along both adjacent faces agree for j>0j>0; all such pairs are parallel when j=0j=0.✦ An admissible pair a,b:y(j)→Sa,b:y(j)\to S in a globular theory CC is a pair of parallel operations with ht⁡(S)≤j+1\operatorname{ht}(S)\le j+1.✦ A filler z:y(j+1)→Sz:y(j+1)\to S for a pair of operations a,b:y(j)→Sa,b:y(j)\to S in a globular theory CC is an operation whose source and target restrictions are aa and bb.✦ Along a theory morphism, the same condition uses the images of aa and bb. A theory morphism f:C→Df:C\to D is a free extension by fillers for a family of admissible pairs in CC when it adjoins specified fillers for their images in DD and has the following universal property: every theory morphism a:C→Ea:C\to E, together with fillers for the image pairs in EE, extends uniquely to a theory morphism D→ED\to E carrying the specified fillers to the chosen fillers.✦

A cellular presentation of a globular theory CC is a sequence of theories starting at an initial theory, with each successor a free extension by fillers for a family of admissible pairs, and with compatible inclusions exhibiting CC as its colimit.✦ A coherator CC is a globular theory that admits a cellular presentation and has a filler for every admissible pair.✦

For a natural cutoff qq, a model XX of a globular theory CC is qq-coskeletal when every boundary in dimension j>qj>q has a unique filler.✦ For a globular theory CC and a natural cutoff qq, let AqA_q be the full subcategory of Mod⁡(C)\operatorname{Mod}(C) consisting of qq-coskeletal models.✦ When CC is a coherator, the coskeletal reflection is a functor Rq:Mod⁡(C)→AqR_q:\operatorname{Mod}(C)\to A_q with unit ηX:X→RqX\eta_X:X\to R_qX, characterized by the bijection (4) for Y∈AqY\in A_q. Aq(RqX,Y)→≅Mod⁡(C)(X,Y),ℓ↦ℓ∘ηX.A_q(R_qX,Y)\xrightarrow{\ \cong\ }\operatorname{Mod}(C)(X,Y), \qquad \ell\longmapsto\ell\circ\eta_X.(4) The reflected disks and boundary inclusions are the images RqDjR_qD_j, Rq∂DjR_q\partial D_j, and RqIjR_qI_j under this functor.

The Claim

Definition 1 (Boundary fillers). A globular set GG has boundary fillers, written Fill⁡(G)\operatorname{Fill}(G), when (5) holds. Fill⁡(G)⇔G0≠⌀andβj+1:Gj+1→Bj+1(G) is surjective for every j∈ℕ.\operatorname{Fill}(G)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad G_0\ne\varnothing\quad\text{and}\quad \beta_{j+1}:G_{j+1}\to B_{j+1}(G) \text{ is surjective for every }j\in\mathbb N.(5)✦ For a globular set GG with boundary fillers and parallel cells a,b∈Gja,b\in G_j, the joining assertion is (6). ∃h∈Gj+1,sj(h)=a,tj(h)=b.\exists h\in G_{j+1},\qquad s_j(h)=a,\quad t_j(h)=b.(6)✦ For a model XX of any globular theory CC, the disk extension criterion is (7). Fill⁡(UX)⇔{for every j∈ℕ and f:∂Dj→X,there is g:Dj→X with g∘Ij=f.\operatorname{Fill}(UX)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \left\{ \begin{gathered} \text{for every }j\in\mathbb N\text{ and }f:\partial D_j\to X,\\ \text{there is }g:D_j\to X\text{ with }g\circ I_j=f. \end{gathered} \right.(7)✦ The reflected criterion for a coherator CC, a natural cutoff qq, and X∈AqX\in A_q is (8). Fill⁡(UX)⇔{for every j∈ℕ and f:Rq∂Dj→X,there is g:RqDj→X with g∘RqIj=f.\operatorname{Fill}(UX)\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \left\{ \begin{gathered} \text{for every }j\in\mathbb N\text{ and }f:R_q\partial D_j\to X,\\ \text{there is }g:R_qD_j\to X\text{ with }g\circ R_qI_j=f. \end{gathered} \right.(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: a model XX is contractible if its map X→1X\to1 to the terminal model is a weak equivalence; equivalently, (UX)0≠⌀(UX)_0\ne\varnothing and every parallel pair of cells has a joining cell, or X→1X\to1 has the right lifting property against every IjI_j.

What Is Checked

The statements range over globular sets and models of arbitrary globular theories; the cutoff statement assumes that CC is a coherator, that qq is a natural number, and that XX is a qq-coskeletal model of CC.

The reflection existence statement supplies a coskeletal reflection whose unit is bijective on jj-cells for j≤qj\le q.✦ The bijections (4) respect postcomposition by morphisms in AqA_q.✦