OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · 2. Globular models and the weak-equivalence test

§2 (setting): globular sets, shapes and Definition 2.1 [The coherator convention]: Globular arities and admissible parallel pairs with the Ara-Henry dimension bound

Coherators from sequential free extensions.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Globular operations have disks as domains and finite globular pasting shapes as arities. The admissibility condition constrains the dimensions of the shapes on which boundary operations may be prescribed.

The globe category 𝔾\mathbb G has an object nn for each natural number, its identity maps, and two face maps σm,n,τm,n:m→n\sigma_{m,n},\tau_{m,n}:m\to n whenever m<nm<n. A globular presheaf is a functor 𝔾op→Set\mathbb G^{\mathrm{op}}\to\mathrm{Set}.✦ The representable disk is Dn=𝔾(−,n)D_n=\mathbb G(-,n); the same face notation denotes the induced maps between representable disks. Write Jn=σn,n+1J_n=\sigma_{n,n+1} for the source inclusion and τn,n+1\tau_{n,n+1} for the target inclusion.

The Definition

Definition 1 (Globular arities, theories and coherators). A globular set XX is a sequence of sets with source and target maps satisfying the globular identities in (1): X=(Xn,sn,tn)n≥0,sn,tn:Xn+1→Xn,sn∘sn+1=sn∘tn+1,tn∘sn+1=tn∘tn+1.\begin{gathered} X=(X_n,s_n,t_n)_{n\geq 0},\qquad s_n,t_n:X_{n+1}\longrightarrow X_n,\\ s_n\circ s_{n+1}=s_n\circ t_{n+1},\qquad t_n\circ s_{n+1}=t_n\circ t_{n+1}. \end{gathered}(1)✦

A table of dimensions TT ending in dimension ℓ\ell is a finite expression in the recursively generated family 𝒯ℓ\mathcal T_\ell of (2); [n][n] denotes a single globe, and T*bhT\ast_b h denotes attachment of an hh-globe along a bb-face of the last globe of TT: [n]∈𝒯n(n≥0),T∈𝒯ℓ,b<ℓ,b<h⇒T*bh∈𝒯h.[n]\in\mathcal T_n\quad(n\geq 0),\qquad T\in\mathcal T_\ell,\ b<\ell,\ b<h \quad\Longrightarrow\quad T\ast_b h\in\mathcal T_h.(2)✦

A globular arity SS is a finite globular sum specified by a table together with its last dimension, as in (3): 𝒮=∐ℓ≥0𝒯ℓ,S=(ℓ,T).\mathcal S=\coprod_{\ell\geq 0}\mathcal T_\ell,\qquad S=(\ell,T).(3)✦ The globe arity (n,[n])(n,[n]) is denoted DnD_n.✦ The realization |S|=|T||S|=|T| is a globular presheaf with last globe inclusion λT:Dℓ→|T|\lambda_T:D_\ell\to|T| and height ht⁡(S)=ht⁡(T)\operatorname{ht}(S)=\operatorname{ht}(T), defined by (4), where ihi_h denotes the pushout inclusion of the newly attached globe: |[n]|=Dn,λ[n]=1Dn,ht⁡([n])=n,|T*bh|=|T|∐DbDh,λT*bh=ih,ht⁡(T*bh)=max⁡{ht⁡(T),h}.\begin{aligned} |[n]|&=D_n,&\lambda_{[n]}&=1_{D_n},&\operatorname{ht}([n])&=n,\\ |T\ast_b h|&=|T|\amalg_{D_b}D_h,& \lambda_{T\ast_b h}&=i_h,& \operatorname{ht}(T\ast_b h)&=\max\{\operatorname{ht}(T),h\}. \end{aligned}(4) Here the pushout uses the seam λT∘τb,ℓ:Db→|T|\lambda_T\circ\tau_{b,\ell}:D_b\to|T| and the source face σb,h:Db→Dh\sigma_{b,h}:D_b\to D_h. For S=(ℓ,T)S=(\ell,T), write S*bhS\ast_b h for the arity with table T*bhT\ast_b h and last dimension hh; its inclusions are iS:S→S*bhi_S:S\to S\ast_b h and ih:Dh→S*bhi_h:D_h\to S\ast_b h. Maps of arities are maps of their globular presheaf realizations; this gives the category 𝒮\mathcal S, with the disk faces as its face maps. For a globular arity SS whose last globe has dimension ℓ\ell, the attached arity S*bhS\ast_b h, with b<ℓb<\ell and b<hb<h, is the finite globular sum obtained by gluing the source bb-face of a new hh-globe to the target bb-face of the last globe of SS.

A category EE under globular arities is a category whose objects are the shapes, with an identity-on-objects functor ιE:𝒮→E\iota_E:\mathcal S\to E.✦ A globular theory EE is a category under globular arities whose arity functor ιE\iota_E preserves every attachment pushout, as expressed by the canonical isomorphism in (5): ιE(S)∐ιE(Db)ιE(Dh)→[ιE(iS),ιE(ih)]≅ιE(S*bh)(b<ℓ,b<h).\iota_E(S)\amalg_{\iota_E(D_b)}\iota_E(D_h) \xrightarrow[\ [\iota_E(i_S),\iota_E(i_h)]\ ]{\ \cong\ } \iota_E(S\ast_b h) \qquad(b<\ell,\ b<h).(5)✦ A morphism of globular theories F:E→E′F:E\to E' is an identity-on-objects functor satisfying F∘ιE=ιE′F\circ\iota_E=\iota_{E'}; composition and identities are those of functors.

Two operations f,g∈E(Dn,S)f,g\in E(D_n,S) are parallel, written f∥gf\parallel g, when n=0n=0 or, for n>0n>0, when they have the common boundary specified by (6): f∘ιE(Jn−1)=g∘ιE(Jn−1),f∘ιE(τn−1,n)=g∘ιE(τn−1,n).f\circ\iota_E(J_{n-1})=g\circ\iota_E(J_{n-1}),\qquad f\circ\iota_E(\tau_{n-1,n})=g\circ\iota_E(\tau_{n-1,n}).(6)✦ An admissible parallel pair p=(n,S,f,g)p=(n,S,f,g) in EE is a parallel pair of operations satisfying the Ara-Henry dimension bound in (7): Adm⁡(E)={(n,S,f,g)∣n≥0,S∈𝒮,f,g∈E(Dn,S),f∥g,ht⁡(S)≤n+1}.\operatorname{Adm}(E)= \bigl\{(n,S,f,g)\mid n\geq 0,\ S\in\mathcal S,\ f,g\in E(D_n,S),\ f\parallel g,\ \operatorname{ht}(S)\leq n+1\bigr\}.(7)✦

For a theory morphism F:E→E′F:E\to E' and p=(n,S,f,g)∈Adm⁡(E)p=(n,S,f,g)\in\operatorname{Adm}(E), a filler zz for pp along FF is an operation in the set Fill⁡F(p)\operatorname{Fill}_F(p) of (8): Fill⁡F(p)={z∈E′(Dn+1,S)∣z∘ιE′(Jn)=F(f),z∘ιE′(τn,n+1)=F(g)}.\operatorname{Fill}_F(p)= \bigl\{z\in E'(D_{n+1},S)\mid z\circ\iota_{E'}(J_n)=F(f),\ z\circ\iota_{E'}(\tau_{n,n+1})=F(g)\bigr\}.(8)✦

Let GG be a set, let pg=(ng,Sg,fg,gg)p_g=(n_g,S_g,f_g,g_g) be admissible pairs in EE, and choose operations zg∈E′(Dng+1,Sg)z_g\in E'(D_{n_g+1},S_g). A free extension F:E→E′F:E\to E' of a globular theory EE by chosen fillers zgz_g for admissible pairs pgp_g indexed by a set GG is a theory morphism for which (9) holds for every globular theory HH and morphism A:E→HA:E\to H: zg∈Fill⁡F(pg)(g∈G),{B:E′→H∣B∘F=A}→B↦(B(zg))g∈G∼∏g∈GFill⁡A(pg).\begin{gathered} z_g\in\operatorname{Fill}_F(p_g)\quad(g\in G),\\ \{B:E'\to H\mid B\circ F=A\} \xrightarrow[\ B\mapsto(B(z_g))_{g\in G}\ ]{\ \sim\ } \prod_{g\in G}\operatorname{Fill}_A(p_g). \end{gathered}(9)✦

A cellular presentation of a globular theory CC is a sequence of globular theories CrC_r and morphisms ur:Cr→Cr+1u_r:C_r\to C_{r+1}, with sets of generators GrG_r, admissible pairs pr,gp_{r,g} in CrC_r, chosen operations zr,gz_{r,g} in Cr+1C_{r+1}, and inclusions κr:Cr→C\kappa_r:C_r\to C satisfying (10): C0→u0C1→u1C2→⋯,C0 is initial,ur is the free extension by (pr,g,zr,g)g∈Gr,κr+1∘ur=κr,(κr:Cr→C)r≥0 is a colimit cocone.\begin{gathered} C_0\xrightarrow{u_0}C_1\xrightarrow{u_1}C_2\longrightarrow\cdots, \qquad C_0\text{ is initial},\\ u_r\text{ is the free extension by }(p_{r,g},z_{r,g})_{g\in G_r},\\ \kappa_{r+1}\circ u_r=\kappa_r,\qquad (\kappa_r:C_r\to C)_{r\geq 0}\text{ is a colimit cocone}. \end{gathered}(10)✦

A Grothendieck coherator CC is a globular theory satisfying (11): C admits a cellular presentation,Fill⁡1C(p)≠⌀for every p∈Adm⁡(C).\begin{gathered} C\text{ admits a cellular presentation},\\ \operatorname{Fill}_{1_C}(p)\ne\varnothing \qquad\text{for every }p\in\operatorname{Adm}(C). \end{gathered}(11)✦

What Is Checked

The definition is stated over the finite globular-sum arities of (3) and globular theories whose arity functors preserve their attachment pushouts as in (5).