OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Vanishing on products

§4 (proof of Proposition 3, Step 2): freeing the distinguished slot: Mixed-product vanishing yields pure-power vanishing in finite dimension

Freeing the distinguished argument by transfer.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A multilinear form on symmetric powers can be evaluated with a pure power in one argument and repeated products in the others. The first transfer concerns the relation between these values and values sharing a product in every argument.

Let VV be a complex vector space. For n∈ℕn\in\mathbb N, let Finn\mathrm{Fin}\,n denote the set of the first nn natural numbers. For a family v:Finn→Vv:\mathrm{Fin}\,n\to V, the symmetric monomial sn(v)s_n(v) is the product of the images of its vectors under the canonical inclusion ι:V→SymmetricAlgebra⁡(ℂ,V)\iota:V\to\operatorname{SymmetricAlgebra}(\mathbb C,V), and the symmetric power is their linear span: sn(v)=∏j∈Finnι(vj),Sym⁡nV=span⁡ℂ{sn(v):v:Finn→V}.s_n(v)=\prod_{j\in\mathrm{Fin}\,n}\iota(v_j), \qquad \operatorname{Sym}^n V =\operatorname{span}_{\mathbb C}\{s_n(v):v:\mathrm{Fin}\,n\to V\}.(1)✦ The multilinear symmetric product is the map v↦sn(v)v\mapsto s_n(v) in (1), with values in Sym⁡nV\operatorname{Sym}^n V.✦ Symmetric power multiplication is the bilinear map induced by multiplication in the symmetric algebra; write xn=sn(j↦x)x^n=s_n(j\mapsto x).✦

Fix natural numbers r,mr,m, and put a=r+1a=r+1 and b=r+mb=r+m. Let T:(Sym⁡bV)a→ℂT:(\operatorname{Sym}^b V)^a\to\mathbb C be a complex multilinear form, with arguments indexed by Fina\mathrm{Fin}\,a. The distinguished argument of the multilinear form TT is its first argument. For x∈Vx\in V and y:Finm→Vy:\mathrm{Fin}\,m\to V, put Q=∏j∈FinmyjQ=\prod_{j\in\mathrm{Fin}\,m}y_j and P=xrQP=x^rQ. The flattened multilinear form T̃\widetilde T is the form on aba b copies of VV given by T̃((vi,j)(i,j)∈Fina×Finb)=T((∏j∈Finbvi,j)i∈Fina).\widetilde T\bigl((v_{i,j})_{(i,j)\in \mathrm{Fin}\,a\times\mathrm{Fin}\,b}\bigr) =T\left(\left(\prod_{j\in\mathrm{Fin}\,b}v_{i,j} \right)_{i\in\mathrm{Fin}\,a}\right).(2)✦

The Transfer Polynomials

The first transfer blocks form the index set ℬ={X,U}⊔{Yj:j∈Finm}\mathcal B=\{X,U\}\sqcup\{Y_j:j\in\mathrm{Fin}\,m\}.✦ For k∈ℕk\in\mathbb N, the slot labelling ℓk:Fina×Finb→ℬ\ell_k:\mathrm{Fin}\,a\times\mathrm{Fin}\,b\to\mathcal B is ℓk(i,j)={Yj,i=0,j<k,j<m,U,i=0,and (j≥k or j≥m),X,i≠0,j<r,Yj−r,i≠0,r≤j.\ell_k(i,j)= \begin{cases} Y_j,&i=0,\ j<k,\ j<m,\\ U,&i=0,\ \text{and }(j\ge k\text{ or }j\ge m),\\ X,&i\ne0,\ j<r,\\ Y_{j-r},&i\ne0,\ r\le j. \end{cases}(3)✦

For finite sets I,KI,K, a multilinear form L:VI→ℂL:V^I\to\mathbb C, a family e:K→Ve:K\to V and a labelling λ:I→ℬ\lambda:I\to\mathcal B, the associated polynomial 𝒫L,e,λ\mathcal P_{L,e,\lambda} is the polynomial in independent coordinates Zu,jZ_{u,j}, indexed by u∈ℬu\in\mathcal B and j∈Kj\in K, defined by 𝒫L,e,λ=∑f:I→KL((ef(i))i∈I)∏i∈IZλ(i),f(i).\mathcal P_{L,e,\lambda} =\sum_{f:I\to K}L\bigl((e_{f(i)})_{i\in I}\bigr) \prod_{i\in I}Z_{\lambda(i),f(i)}.(4) The first transfer polynomial FkF_k is the polynomial (4) of the flattened form (2) with the labelling (3): Fk=𝒫T̃,e,ℓk∈ℂ[Zu,j:u∈ℬ,j∈K].F_k=\mathcal P_{\widetilde T,e,\ell_k} \in\mathbb C[Z_{u,j}:u\in\mathcal B,\ j\in K].(5)✦

For a block u∈ℬu\in\mathcal B, the block indicator weight wuw_u is the function on the coordinates of (5) that assigns degree one to coordinates in that block and degree zero to all other coordinates: wu(v,j)={1,v=u,0,v≠u.w_u(v,j)=\begin{cases}1,&v=u,\\0,&v\ne u.\end{cases}(6) A polynomial FF in the ring of (5) is block-homogeneous of degree dd in a block u∈ℬu\in\mathcal B when every monomial of FF with nonzero coefficient has weighted degree dd for (6). For k<mk<m, the block derivative on the polynomial ring of (5) is DYk,U=∑j∈KZYk,j∂∂ZU,j.D_{Y_k,U}=\sum_{j\in K}Z_{Y_k,j}\frac{\partial}{\partial Z_{U,j}}.(7) Here UU is the source block and YkY_k the destination block; the other independent blocks are spectators for (7).

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let r,m∈ℕr,m\in\mathbb N, let VV be a complex vector space, let T:(Sym⁡r+mV)r+1→ℂT:(\operatorname{Sym}^{r+m}V)^{r+1}\to\mathbb C be multilinear, and let e:K→Ve:K\to V be a family indexed by a finite set. For k∈ℕk\in\mathbb N and u∈ℬu\in\mathcal B, Fk is block homogeneous in u of degree #{(i,j)∈Fina×Finb:ℓk(i,j)=u}.F_k\text{ is block homogeneous in }u\text{ of degree } \#\{(i,j)\in\mathrm{Fin}\,a\times\mathrm{Fin}\,b:\ell_k(i,j)=u\}.(8)✦ For k<mk<m, DYk,UFk=(b−k)Fk+1.D_{Y_k,U}F_k=(b-k)F_{k+1}.(9)✦ For natural numbers b′,r′,ib',r',i satisfying 1≤i≤b′−r′1\le i\le b'-r', r′<b′−i+1.r'<b'-i+1.(10)✦ Under the hypothesis Fm=0F_m=0, F0=0.F_0=0.(11)✦ Suppose T(trQ,P,…,P)=0T(t^rQ,P,\ldots,P)=0 for every x,t∈Vx,t\in V and y:Finm→Vy:\mathrm{Fin}\,m\to V. Then Fm=0.F_m=0.(12)✦ Under the stated hypothesis on T(trQ,P,…,P)T(t^rQ,P,\ldots,P), if VV is finite-dimensional, then for every x,t∈Vx,t\in V and y:Finm→Vy:\mathrm{Fin}\,m\to V, T(tb,P,…,P)=0.T(t^b,P,\ldots,P)=0.(13)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for r=a−1r=a-1 and m=b−rm=b-r, fixed xx, Q=∏j∈FinmyjQ=\prod_{j\in\mathrm{Fin}\,m}y_j and independent blocks t,(yj)j∈Finmt,(y_j)_{j\in\mathrm{Fin}\,m}, the polynomial Hx=T(xrQ,…,xrQ,tb)H_x=T(x^rQ,\ldots,x^rQ,t^b) satisfies Dyk−1,t⋯Dy0,tHx=b!(b−k)!T(xrQ,…,xrQ,tb−k∏j<kyj)D_{y_{k-1},t}\cdots D_{y_0,t}H_x =\frac{b!}{(b-k)!}T(x^rQ,\ldots,x^rQ,t^{b-k}\prod_{j<k}y_j) for 0≤k≤m0\le k\le m, its endpoint k=mk=m vanishes by the mixed-product vanishing assertion of Step 1, and before the ii-th derivative the source degree is b−i+1b-i+1 and the new destination degree is rr, so each derivative is injective and Hx=0H_x=0.

What Is Checked

The transfer (13) is stated over finite-dimensional complex vector spaces and arbitrary natural r,mr,m, including zero, with TT an arbitrary multilinear form; the polynomial statements (8), (9), (12) and (11) use finite coordinate families in an arbitrary complex vector space, and (10) is an inequality of natural numbers under its stated bounds. For p,q∈ℕp,q\in\mathbb N, z∈Sym⁡pVz\in\operatorname{Sym}^pV and w∈Sym⁡qVw\in\operatorname{Sym}^qV, symmetric power multiplication satisfies (14), with the product taken in the symmetric algebra: zw∈Sym⁡p+qV.zw\in\operatorname{Sym}^{p+q}V.(14)✦