OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. Comparison with an arbitrary aspherical presentation

Theorem 3.1: Finite quotient compactness and the obstruction to a two-dimensional ordinary closure-finite weak-topology (CW) classifying space for the fixed Artin height kernel

Presentation comparison forces small transport rigidity.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The comparison concerns transport around null words in a Cayley graph, with flatness prescribed on a finite basis of its cycle module.

Let Γ\Gamma be residually finite, let SS be a finite alphabet, and let v:S→Γv:S\to\Gamma assign group values to its letters. Distinct letters remain distinct even when their values coincide. The word evaluation ev⁡v:F(S)→Γ\operatorname{ev}_v:F(S)\to\Gamma is the homomorphism from the free group sending ss to v(s)v(s); a null word is an element of its kernel.✦ The generator edge (g,s)(g,s) runs from gg to gv(s)gv(s).

Put Λ=ℤ[Γ]\Lambda=\mathbb Z[\Gamma], acting on the left. The based edge chain module C1(v)C_1(v) is the free abelian group on these edges, with boundary in C0=ΛC_0=\Lambda and cycle module Z1(v)Z_1(v) defined by (1): C1(v)=ℤ(Γ×S)=⨁s∈SΛes,∂1(ges)=gv(s)−g,Z1(v)=ker⁡∂1.\begin{aligned} C_1(v)&=\mathbb Z^{(\Gamma\times S)} =\bigoplus_{s\in S}\Lambda e_s,\\ \partial_1(ge_s)&=gv(s)-g, & Z_1(v)&=\ker\partial_1. \end{aligned}(1) For a word w∈F(S)w\in F(S), its signed based edge chain [w]g[w]_g is the sum of its positively traversed edges minus the edges traversed in reverse, starting at gg.✦ The relator boundary map ∂r\partial_r for a family r=(ri)i∈Rr=(r_i)_{i\in R} of words is the homomorphism in (2): ∂r:Λ(R)→C1(v),∂r(gei)=[ri]g.\partial_r:\Lambda^{(R)}\longrightarrow C_1(v), \qquad \partial_r(ge_i)=[r_i]_g.(2)✦ A boundary basis z=(zd)d∈Dz=(z_d)_{d\in D} for vv, indexed by a finite set DD, is a family of null words for which ∂z:Λ(D)→Z1(v)\partial_z:\Lambda^{(D)}\to Z_1(v) is an isomorphism.

A genuine presentation (a0,r0)(a_0,r_0) of Γ\Gamma is a pair consisting of a generator map a0:A→Γa_0:A\to\Gamma with surjective evaluation and a family of null relators r0=(r0,j)j∈R0r_0=(r_{0,j})_{j\in R_0} satisfying (3), where the brackets denote normal closure in F(A)F(A): ker⁡ev⁡a0=⟨⟨r0,j:j∈R0⟩⟩.\ker\operatorname{ev}_{a_0} =\langle\!\langle r_{0,j}:j\in R_0\rangle\!\rangle.(3)

For a group UU, an edge labeling aa of the generator edges of Γ\Gamma is a function a:Γ×S→Ua:\Gamma\times S\to U. The reverse of (g,s)(g,s) receives the inverse of a(g,s)a(g,s), and products follow traversal order. The label lift ã:F(S)→UΓ⋊Γ\widetilde a:F(S)\to U^\Gamma\rtimes\Gamma is the homomorphism determined by (4), where Γ\Gamma acts on functions by right translation.✦ The path transport Hol⁡av(w;g)\operatorname{Hol}^v_a(w;g) of a word w∈F(S)w\in F(S) from a vertex g∈Γg\in\Gamma is the value at gg of the first coordinate of ã(w)\widetilde a(w): ã(s)=(a(⋅,s),v(s)),Hol⁡av(w;g)=(ã(w))1(g).\widetilde a(s)=(a(\,\cdot\,,s),v(s)), \qquad \operatorname{Hol}^v_a(w;g)=\bigl(\widetilde a(w)\bigr)_1(g).(4)

The unit quaternion group H=SU(2)H=\mathrm{SU}(2) consists of the quaternions of norm one.✦ For η>0\eta>0, the set ℒη(v,z)\mathscr L_\eta(v,z) of small flat HH-labelings is defined by (5); the norm is the quaternion chord norm: ℒη(v,z)={a:Γ×S→H:∥a(g,s)−1∥<η(g∈Γ,s∈S),Hol⁡av(zd;g)=1(d∈D,g∈Γ)}.\mathscr L_\eta(v,z)= \left\{ a:\Gamma\times S\to H: \begin{array}{ll} \|a(g,s)-1\|<\eta & (g\in\Gamma,\ s\in S),\\ \operatorname{Hol}^v_a(z_d;g)=1 & (d\in D,\ g\in\Gamma) \end{array} \right\}.(5)

For an extension v:S⊔T→Γv:S\sqcup T\to\Gamma of the generator map on SS, the extra edge projection πT:C1(v)→Λ(T)\pi_T:C_1(v)\to\Lambda^{(T)} is the homomorphism that kills the SS-edges and retains the TT-edges.✦ For relators rr indexed by D⊔RD\sqcup R, the extra relator boundary is the map qq in (6): q=πT∘∂r|R:Λ(R)→Λ(T).q=\pi_T\circ\partial_{r|_R}: \Lambda^{(R)}\longrightarrow\Lambda^{(T)}.(6)✦ Write ι:F(S)→F(S⊔T)\iota:F(S)\to F(S\sqcup T) for the inclusion. For labelings a:Γ×S→Ua:\Gamma\times S\to U and b:Γ×T→Ub:\Gamma\times T\to U, the combined labeling a⊔ba\sqcup b equals aa on the SS-edges and bb on the TT-edges.✦

The Fixed Height Kernel

The fixed presentation has generating letters x,yx,y; its relators and their boundary polygon lengths are given in (7), where |ρϵ||\rho_\epsilon| counts signed letters: ρ0=x2y−5,ρ1=x2(yx−1)3,nϵ=3|ρϵ|(ϵ∈{0,1}).\rho_0=x^2y^{-5}, \qquad \rho_1=x^2(yx^{-1})^3, \qquad n_\epsilon=3|\rho_\epsilon| \quad(\epsilon\in\{0,1\}).(7) The subdivided rose has a common vertex ** and two interior vertices uj,0,uj,1u_{j,0},u_{j,1} for each circle j∈{x,y}j\in\{x,y\}.✦ Its circle edges cj,0,cj,1,cj,2c_{j,0},c_{j,1},c_{j,2} run in order along *→uj,0→uj,1→**\to u_{j,0}\to u_{j,1}\to *, specifying their initial and terminal vertices.

A polygon sector s=(ϵ,i)s=(\epsilon,i), with 0≤i<nϵ0\le i<n_\epsilon, is a triangle in the coned boundary polygon for ρϵ\rho_\epsilon.✦ The next sector of ss is the polygon sector s+=(ϵ,i+1mod⁡nϵ)s^+=(\epsilon,i+1\bmod n_\epsilon).✦ The relator letter of a polygon sector s=(ϵ,i)s=(\epsilon,i) is the letter at position ⌊i/3⌋\lfloor i/3\rfloor in ρϵ\rho_\epsilon.✦ If that letter is j+1j^{+1}, the sector boundary edge is cs=cj,imod⁡3c_s=c_{j,i\bmod3}; for j−1j^{-1} it is cs=cj,2−(imod⁡3)c_s=c_{j,2-(i\bmod3)}.✦ The initial vertex tst_s of a polygon sector ss is the initial vertex of csc_s when the sector relator letter is positive and its terminal vertex when that letter is negative.✦

The presentation complex vertices are the rose vertices together with the two cone vertices qϵq_\epsilon.✦ The edges of the presentation complex are the circle edges and the radial edges bsb_s from qϵq_\epsilon to tst_s.✦ The sector edges of triangle ss are cs,bs,bs+c_s,b_s,b_{s^+}✦, and its sector vertices are the union of their endpoint sets.✦ The presentation complex cells are its vertices, edges and triangles.✦ Proper face incidence between cells of the presentation complex is the relation given by vertex membership in an edge’s endpoint set or a triangle’s vertex set, or edge membership in a triangle’s edge set.✦ The cell incidence graph LL has these cells as vertices and joins two cells when either is a proper face of the other.✦

The Artin height kernel GG of the right-angled Artin group P=ALP=A_L on LL is the kernel of the height homomorphism λ:P→ℤ\lambda:P\to\mathbb Z in (8), with pcp_c denoting the standard generator corresponding to a vertex cc of LL: P=AL,λ:P→ℤ,λ(pc)=1,G=ker⁡λ.P=A_L, \qquad \lambda:P\longrightarrow\mathbb Z,\quad \lambda(p_c)=1, \qquad G=\ker\lambda.(8)✦

For a group Δ\Delta, an ordinary CW classifying space K(Δ,1)K(\Delta,1) of dimension at most nn is a path-connected Hausdorff space XX with a CW structure on all of XX, no cells in dimensions greater than nn, and a point xx with π1(X,x)≅Δ\pi_1(X,x)\cong\Delta, admitting a surjective covering map E→XE\to X from a contractible space EE.✦ There is no restriction on the number of cells.

The Claim

Theorem 1. (i) Suppose ev⁡v\operatorname{ev}_v is surjective and zz is a boundary basis. Suppose also that Γ\Gamma has a genuine presentation (a0,r0)(a_0,r_0) for which ∂r0:Λ(R0)→Z1(a0)\partial_{r_0}:\Lambda^{(R_0)}\to Z_1(a_0) is an isomorphism. Then there is η>0 such thatHol⁡av(w;g)=1(a∈ℒη(v,z),w∈ker⁡ev⁡v,g∈Γ).\begin{gathered} \text{there is }\eta>0\text{ such that}\\ \operatorname{Hol}^v_a(w;g)=1 \quad \bigl(a\in\mathscr L_\eta(v,z),\ w\in\ker\operatorname{ev}_v,\ g\in\Gamma\bigr). \end{gathered}(9)✦

(ii) Let v:S⊔T→Γv:S\sqcup T\to\Gamma send every letter of TT to 11, and put ν=v|S\nu=v|_S. Let zd∈F(S)z_d\in F(S) be null for ν\nu, and let rj∈F(S⊔T)r_j\in F(S\sqcup T), indexed by D⊔RD\sqcup R, be null for vv. Suppose ker⁡ev⁡v\ker\operatorname{ev}_v is normally generated by the rjr_j, ∂r\partial_r is injective, [ι(zd)]1=[rd]1[\iota(z_d)]_1=[r_d]_1 for every d∈Dd\in D, and the extra relator boundary qq is an isomorphism of abelian groups. Then there is η>0 such thatHol⁡aν(w;g)=1(a∈ℒη(ν,z),w∈ker⁡ev⁡ν,g∈Γ).\begin{gathered} \text{there is }\eta>0\text{ such that}\\ \operatorname{Hol}^{\nu}_a(w;g)=1 \quad \bigl(a\in\mathscr L_\eta(\nu,z),\ w\in\ker\operatorname{ev}_{\nu},\ g\in\Gamma\bigr). \end{gathered}(10)✦

(iii) Let UU be a compact topological group and let v:S⊔T→Γv:S\sqcup T\to\Gamma be any generator map. Let II index words wi∈F(S⊔T)w_i\in F(S\sqcup T), starting vertices gi∈Γg_i\in\Gamma, and closed subsets Ki⊆UK_i\subseteq U. Let 𝒜⊆U\mathcal A\subseteq U contain 11, and let a:Γ×S→Ua:\Gamma\times S\to U take values in 𝒜\mathcal A. Suppose that for every normal subgroup NN of finite index, every finite J⊆IJ\subseteq I, and every labeling aN:(Γ/N)×S→𝒜a_N:(\Gamma/N)\times S\to\mathcal A, there is a labeling bN:(Γ/N)×T→Ub_N:(\Gamma/N)\times T\to U whose combined transport, for the generator values induced by vv in Γ/N\Gamma/N, lies in KiK_i on wiw_i at every starting vertex whenever i∈Ji\in J. Then ∃b:Γ×T→U,Hol⁡a⊔bv(wi;gi)∈Ki(i∈I).\exists b:\Gamma\times T\to U,\qquad \operatorname{Hol}^{v}_{a\sqcup b}(w_i;g_i)\in K_i \quad(i\in I).(11)✦

(iv) For the fixed Artin height kernel, G admits no ordinary CW classifying space of dimension at most 2.G\text{ admits no ordinary CW classifying space of dimension at most }2.(12)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if a residually finite group Γ\Gamma has a finite generating alphabet SS, a finite indexed family of null words (zd)d∈D(z_d)_{d\in D} for which ed↦[zd]1e_d\mapsto[z_d]_1 is an isomorphism Λ(D)→ker⁡∂1\Lambda^{(D)}\to\ker\partial_1, and a K(Γ,1)K(\Gamma,1) of dimension at most two, then some η>0\eta>0 makes every oriented generator-edge HH-labeling with inverse labels on reversals, chord distance less than η\eta from 11, and trivial transport on every translate of every zdz_d, have trivial product on every closed edge path.

What Is Checked

The rigidity statements (9) and (10) use the relator boundary maps and ordered unit quaternion path products, while finite quotient compactness (11) uses compact topological groups with closed target sets and (12) uses ordinary CW classifying spaces of the fixed height kernel GG.