OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §8. Integral generators and the dimension squeeze

Section 8: normalization, independence and spanning: Integral normalization, injective Ihara evaluations and continuous componentwise completion maps

Normalized generators and graded freeness.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The homogeneous Drinfeld solutions carry the Ihara bracket. The generation question asks for one free generator in each weight 3,5,7,…3,5,7,\ldots, and for an identification that extends to products of homogeneous pieces.

For a commutative ring SS and an alphabet α\alpha, write 𝔏S(α)\mathfrak L_S(\alpha) for the ordinary free Lie algebra on α\alpha✦, and 𝒜S(α)=S⟨α⟩\mathcal A_S(\alpha)=S\langle\alpha\rangle for the free associative algebra, whose basis consists of words.✦ The generator attached to a letter is its one-letter monomial.✦ The universal associative embedding ι:𝔏S(α)→𝒜S(α)\iota:\mathfrak L_S(\alpha)\to\mathcal A_S(\alpha) sends each free Lie generator to that monomial.✦ Associative evaluation extends an assignment of letters to an algebra homomorphism✦; alphabet renaming is the evaluation that sends each letter to its image under an alphabet map.✦ Put L=𝔏ℚ(x,y)L=\mathfrak L_{\mathbb Q}(x,y).✦ Lie polynomial substitution p(a,b)p(a,b) sends xx to aa and yy to bb.✦

The infinitesimal braid algebra 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4 is the quotient of the rational free Lie algebra on the unordered chords cijc_{ij}, 0≤i<j≤30\leq i<j\leq3, by the Lie ideal generated by the relations in (1).✦ Set cji=cijc_{ji}=c_{ij} and cii=0c_{ii}=0✦, and denote their quotient images by tijt_{ij}.✦ [cij,ckl]=0(i,j,k,l pairwise distinct),[cij,cik+cjk]=0(i,j,k pairwise distinct).[c_{ij},c_{kl}]=0\quad(i,j,k,l\text{ pairwise distinct}),\qquad [c_{ij},c_{ik}+c_{jk}]=0\quad(i,j,k\text{ pairwise distinct}).(1) Over SS, the braid algebra 𝔱4(S)\mathfrak t_4(S) is the quotient of the free Lie algebra on ordered pairs (i,j)(i,j) by the diagonal generators, the differences cij−cjic_{ij}-c_{ji}, the brackets for disjoint endpoint pairs, and the three-strand relations in (1)✦; its chord generators are again denoted by tijt_{ij}.

The antisymmetry operator αS\alpha_S, cyclic operator γS\gamma_S, special identity operator δS\delta_S, and pentagon operator PSP_S are the linear maps with domain 𝔏S(x,y)\mathfrak L_S(x,y) given in (2); the target of PSP_S is 𝔱4(S)\mathfrak t_4(S), with 𝔱4\mathfrak t_4 used over ℚ\mathbb Q. αS(p)=p+p(y,x),γS(p)=p+p(y,−x−y)+p(−x−y,x),δS(p)=[x,p(y,x)]+[−x−y,p(y,−x−y)],PS(p)=p(t01,t12+t13)+p(t02+t12,t23)−p(t12,t23)−p(t01+t02,t13+t23)−p(t01,t12).\begin{aligned} \alpha_S(p)&=p+p(y,x),\\ \gamma_S(p)&=p+p(y,-x-y)+p(-x-y,x),\\ \delta_S(p)&=[x,p(y,x)]+[-x-y,p(y,-x-y)],\\ P_S(p)&=p(t_{01},t_{12}+t_{13})+p(t_{02}+t_{12},t_{23}) -p(t_{12},t_{23})\\ &\hspace{1em}-p(t_{01}+t_{02},t_{13}+t_{23})-p(t_{01},t_{12}). \end{aligned}(2) A Drinfeld solution pp in LL is a Lie polynomial annihilated by αℚ\alpha_{\mathbb Q}, γℚ\gamma_{\mathbb Q} and PℚP_{\mathbb Q}.✦ The solution space WW and its homogeneous part WnW_n are the subspaces in (3), where LnL_n is the component with both letters of weight one. Put K=𝔽2K=\mathbb F_2 and give 𝔏K(x,y)\mathfrak L_K(x,y) the same grading. The reduced solution space W¯n\overline W_n uses the special identity operator. W=ker⁡αℚ∩ker⁡γℚ∩ker⁡Pℚ,Wn=W∩Ln,W¯n=𝔏K,n(x,y)∩ker⁡αK∩ker⁡δK∩ker⁡PK.\begin{aligned} W&=\ker\alpha_{\mathbb Q}\cap\ker\gamma_{\mathbb Q} \cap\ker P_{\mathbb Q},& W_n&=W\cap L_n,\\ \overline W_n&=\mathfrak L_{K,n}(x,y)\cap\ker\alpha_K \cap\ker\delta_K\cap\ker P_K. \end{aligned}(3)

For a Lie algebra MM over SS, its first-order Lie jets are pairs (a,u)(a,u) of base point and velocity, with bracket [(a,u),(b,v)]=([a,b],[a,v]−[b,u])[(a,u),(b,v)]=([a,b],[a,v]-[b,u]).✦ The jet lift of a generator assignment ff sends a free generator aa to (a,f(a))(a,f(a)); its velocity is the free derivation extension of ff. In LL, the tangent substitution determined by pp sends xx to (x,0)(x,0) and yy to (y,[y,p])(y,[y,p]).✦ Its velocity at qq is Dp(q)D_p(q), and the Ihara bracket is (4). Dp(x)=0,Dp(y)=[y,p],{p,q}=Dp(q)−Dq(p)+[p,q].D_p(x)=0,\qquad D_p(y)=[y,p],\qquad \{p,q\}=D_p(q)-D_q(p)+[p,q].(4) Over SS, the Ihara Lie algebra is the derivation graph {(p,Dp):p∈𝔏S(x,y)}\{(p,D_p):p\in\mathfrak L_S(x,y)\} in the semidirect product of 𝔏S(x,y)\mathfrak L_S(x,y) with its derivation Lie algebra. Projection to pp is a linear isomorphism.✦ For an assignment vv of free generators to 𝔏S(x,y)\mathfrak L_S(x,y), the universal Lie lift sends a generator aa to (va,Dva)(v_a,D_{v_a}); projection gives its Ihara evaluation EvE_v, which evaluates ordinary bracketed words using (4).

Weights and Normalization

A bracketed word is a letter or the bracket of two bracketed words.✦ The evaluation of a bracketed word is the Lie polynomial obtained by replacing its letters with free generators and its brackets with ordinary Lie brackets.✦ The underlying word of a bracketed word is the associative word listing its letters from left to right.✦ For letter weights ww, the weight of either word is the sum of its letter weights; a bracket adds weights. The homogeneous Lie component 𝔏S,w,n(α)\mathfrak L_{S,w,n}(\alpha) is the span of the evaluations of bracketed words of weight nn.✦ The odd free Lie algebra FF, its components FnF_n, and the number dnd_n are defined in (5). F=𝔏ℚ(σ3,σ5,σ7,…),w(σ2k+3)=2k+3,Fn=𝔏ℚ,w,n,dn=dim⁡ℚFn.F=\mathfrak L_{\mathbb Q}(\sigma_3,\sigma_5,\sigma_7,\ldots),\qquad w(\sigma_{2k+3})=2k+3,\qquad F_n=\mathfrak L_{\mathbb Q,w,n},\qquad d_n=\dim_{\mathbb Q}F_n.(5) Write F¯n=𝔏K,w,n\overline F_n=\mathfrak L_{K,w,n} for the corresponding ordinary free Lie component over KK.

For a condition 𝒫\mathcal P on words, its prescribed word span is the span of the monomials satisfying 𝒫\mathcal P, and its word support projection retains exactly those monomials. The associative homogeneous projection πw,nass\pi^{\mathrm{ass}}_{w,n} retains the words of weight nn.✦ The filtration 𝒜w≥r\mathcal A^{\geq r}_w is the word span of weights at least rr.✦ The Lie homogeneous projection πw,nLie\pi^{\mathrm{Lie}}_{w,n} on 𝔏S(α)\mathfrak L_S(\alpha) is the linear map sending a Lie polynomial pp to its homogeneous component whose associative image is πw,nass(ιp)\pi^{\mathrm{ass}}_{w,n}(\iota p).✦

The quadratic alphabet consists of the letters A,C,BA,C,B.✦ Its associative substitution QQ and its Lie evaluation UU are given in (6). Q:𝒜K(A,C,B)→𝒜K(x,y),A↦x2,C↦[x,y],B↦y,U=Q∘ι:𝔏K(A,C,B)→𝒜K(x,y).\begin{gathered} Q:\mathcal A_K(A,C,B)\longrightarrow\mathcal A_K(x,y),\qquad A\longmapsto x^2,\quad C\longmapsto[x,y],\quad B\longmapsto y,\\ U=Q\circ\iota:\mathfrak L_K(A,C,B)\longrightarrow\mathcal A_K(x,y). \end{gathered}(6) The letters have weights 2,2,12,2,1. The BB-count on words in the quadratic alphabet is the sum of the letter weights that give BB weight one and A,CA,C weight zero. This count differs from ordinary yy-depth: CC has depth one and BB-count zero. The AA-deletion map εA:𝔏K(A,C,B)→𝔏K(c,b)\varepsilon_A:\mathfrak L_K(A,C,B)\to\mathfrak L_K(c,b) sends AA to zero, CC to cc and BB to bb, where c,bc,b name the surviving C,BC,B letters.✦ The leading Lie projection at count rr is ℓr=εA∘πB,rLie\ell_r=\varepsilon_A\circ\pi^{\mathrm{Lie}}_{B,r}.✦

For an alphabet α\alpha, adjoining a distinguished letter XX gives the free Lie algebra on X,YaX,Y_a for a∈αa\in\alpha.✦ For an alphabet α\alpha, the iterated commutator substitution is the algebra homomorphism from the free associative algebra on pairs (r,a)(r,a), with r≥0r\geq0 and a∈αa\in\alpha, to the free associative algebra on X,YaX,Y_a, sending the generator indexed by (r,a)(r,a) to ι((ad⁡X)rYa)\iota((\operatorname{ad}X)^rY_a).✦ For α={*}\alpha=\{*\}, the binary alphabet identification is the bijection sending xx to XX and yy to Y*Y_*.✦ Renaming by its inverse gives the binary commutator substitution, which sends the generator uru_r of the commutator tensor algebra K⟨ur:r≥0⟩K\langle u_r:r\geq0\rangle to (ad⁡x)ry(\operatorname{ad}x)^ry.✦ Its generators are indexed by ℕ×{*}\mathbb N\times\{*\}.✦ The positive-index inclusion from K⟨zk:k≥0⟩K\langle z_k:k\geq0\rangle into the commutator tensor algebra sends each source generator zkz_k to uk+1u_{k+1}.✦ Composing with binary commutator substitution, with the target letters named c,bc,b, gives the positive commutator substitution in (7).✦ The iterated commutator (ad⁡X)rYa(\operatorname{ad}X)^rY_a in the free Lie algebra on X,YaX,Y_a is obtained by applying the ordinary adjoint action of XX to YaY_a exactly rr times.✦ Θ:K⟨zk:k≥0⟩→K⟨c,b⟩,Θ(zk)=(ad⁡c)k+1b.\Theta:K\langle z_k:k\geq0\rangle\longrightarrow K\langle c,b\rangle, \qquad \Theta(z_k)=(\operatorname{ad}c)^{k+1}b.(7)✦

A quadratic representative of h∈𝔏K(x,y)h\in\mathfrak L_K(x,y) is an element r∈𝔏K(A,C,B)r\in\mathfrak L_K(A,C,B) with U(r)=ι(h)U(r)=\iota(h). A quadratic representative r∈𝔏K(A,C,B)r\in\mathfrak L_K(A,C,B) of h∈𝔏K(x,y)h\in\mathfrak L_K(x,y) is normalized at index kk when it satisfies (8). ι(r)∈𝒜B≥1,ι(ℓ1r)=Θ(zk).\iota(r)\in\mathcal A^{\geq1}_B, \qquad \iota(\ell_1r)=\Theta(z_k).(8) A normalized reduced family gg is a family of values gk∈𝔏K(x,y)g_k\in\mathfrak L_K(x,y) with an active set of indices and quadratic representatives rkr_k, such that the representatives at active indices satisfy (8) and EgE_g sends every F¯n\overline F_n into W¯n\overline W_n.✦ The normalized evaluation of a normalized reduced family gg in weight nn is the linear map e¯g,n=Eg|F¯n:F¯n→W¯n\overline e_{g,n}=E_g|_{\overline F_n}:\overline F_n\to\overline W_n.✦

A solution Lie subalgebra VV is a rational linear subspace of WW closed under the Ihara bracket.✦ For a solution Lie subalgebra VV of WW, its degree nn values form the subspace Vn=V∩LnV_n=V\cap L_n of WnW_n.✦ A solution Lie subalgebra VV of WW has odd depth-one nonvanishing when, for every k≥0k\geq0, there is p∈V2k+3p\in V_{2k+3} whose associative coefficient at the depth-one word x2k+2yx^{2k+2}y is nonzero.✦

Integral base change is the Lie homomorphism 𝔏ℤ(α)→𝔏S(α)\mathfrak L_{\mathbb Z}(\alpha)\to\mathfrak L_S(\alpha) sending each integral generator to the corresponding generator over SS.✦ An integral odd family in VV is a sequence fk∈𝔏ℤ(x,y)f_k\in\mathfrak L_{\mathbb Z}(x,y) homogeneous of weight 2k+32k+3, whose rational images lie in VV.✦ Write fS,kf_{S,k} for its images over SS.✦ A normalized integral generator fk∈𝔏ℤ(x,y)f_k\in\mathfrak L_{\mathbb Z}(x,y) at index kk is an element homogeneous of weight 2k+32k+3 whose rational image lies in VV and whose image over KK has a quadratic representative normalized at kk; denote the set of these generators by Gk(V)G_k(V).✦

The generated Ihara Lie algebra VfV^f is the image of EfℚE_{f_{\mathbb Q}}.✦ The rational generator evaluation into the weight-nn part VnfV^f_n of VfV^f and the graded evaluation of homogeneous rational values vk∈L2k+3v_k\in L_{2k+3} are the maps in (9); the latter is defined when Ev(Fn)⊆WnE_v(F_n)\subseteq W_n for every nn. ef,n:Fn→Vnf,a↦Efℚ(a),ev,n:Fn→Wn,a↦Ev(a).e_{f,n}:F_n\longrightarrow V^f_n,\quad a\longmapsto E_{f_{\mathbb Q}}(a), \qquad e_{v,n}:F_n\longrightarrow W_n,\quad a\longmapsto E_v(a).(9)

A rational linear isomorphism e:F→We:F\to W preserves grading when e(a)∈Lne(a)\in L_n holds exactly when a∈Fna\in F_n.✦ The completed map and inverse of a grading-preserving rational linear isomorphism e:F→We:F\to W act componentwise as in (10); the products carry the product of the discrete topologies on their homogeneous pieces. Fˆ=∏n≥0Fn,Wˆ=∏n≥0Wn,eˆ:Fˆ→Wˆ,(eˆ(a))n=e(an),eˆ−1:Wˆ→Fˆ,(eˆ−1(b))n=e−1(bn).\begin{gathered} \widehat F=\prod_{n\geq0}F_n,\qquad \widehat W=\prod_{n\geq0}W_n,\\ \widehat e:\widehat F\longrightarrow\widehat W, \quad(\widehat e(a))_n=e(a_n),\qquad \widehat e^{-1}:\widehat W\longrightarrow\widehat F, \quad(\widehat e^{-1}(b))_n=e^{-1}(b_n). \end{gathered}(10) The completed bracket in weight nn is the finite convolution over 0≤i≤n0\leq i\leq n of the brackets in weights ii and n−in-i.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let VV be a solution Lie subalgebra with odd depth-one nonvanishing. Then Gk(V)≠⌀(k≥0).G_k(V)\ne\varnothing\qquad(k\geq0).(11)✦ Let gg be a normalized reduced family with every index active. For n>1n>1, e¯g,n:F¯n→W¯nis injective.\overline e_{g,n}:\overline F_n\longrightarrow\overline W_n \quad\text{is injective}.(12)✦ For an integral family ff chosen from (11) and for n>2n>2, ef,n:Fn→Vnfis injective.e_{f,n}:F_n\longrightarrow V^f_n\quad\text{is injective}.(13)✦

Denote by ℱ(W)\mathcal F(W) the graded freeness assertion: there exists a grading-preserving rational linear isomorphism e:F→We:F\to W satisfying (14), whose completed maps satisfy (17), (18), (19) and (20).✦ e([a,b])={e(a),e(b)}(a,b∈F),e(∑i=0n[ai,bn−i])=∑i=0n{(eˆ(a))i,(eˆ(b))n−i}(a,b∈Fˆ,n≥0).\begin{aligned} e([a,b])&=\{e(a),e(b)\}&& (a,b\in F),\\ e\!\left(\sum_{i=0}^n[a_i,b_{n-i}]\right) &=\sum_{i=0}^n\{(\widehat e(a))_i,(\widehat e(b))_{n-i}\} &&(a,b\in\widehat F,\ n\geq0). \end{aligned}(14) For the solution Lie subalgebra VV above, the odd-value freeness assertion is ℱ(W).\mathcal F(W).(15)✦ The graded-value freeness assertion is ℱ(W).\mathcal F(W).(16)✦

For every grading-preserving rational linear isomorphism e:F→We:F\to W, eˆ−1∘eˆ=id⁡Fˆ.\widehat e^{-1}\circ\widehat e=\operatorname{id}_{\widehat F}.(17)✦ eˆ∘eˆ−1=id⁡Wˆ.\widehat e\circ\widehat e^{-1}=\operatorname{id}_{\widehat W}.(18)✦ eˆ:Fˆ→Wˆis continuous.\widehat e:\widehat F\longrightarrow\widehat W\quad\text{is continuous}.(19)✦ eˆ−1:Wˆ→Fˆis continuous.\widehat e^{-1}:\widehat W\longrightarrow\widehat F \quad\text{is continuous}.(20)✦

In the paper, the result reads: over R=ℤ(2)R=\mathbb Z_{(2)}, integral generators of weight 2j+12j+1, j≥1j\geq1, can be chosen with count-one projected reductions (ad⁡C)jB(\operatorname{ad}C)^jB; leading Ihara brackets identify their reduced Lie words with ordinary odd-generator words, and the dimension squeeze gives Vn=WnV_n=W_n of dimension dnd_n in every weight, yielding freeness, generation and the componentwise completed isomorphism.

What Is Checked

The integral and reduced assertions (11), (12), (13) and (15) are stated over integral free Lie algebras, their rational images in a solution Lie subalgebra VV, and their reductions over 𝔽2\mathbb F_2; (16) is the graded-value freeness assertion for WW, while (17), (18), (19) and (20) apply to every grading-preserving rational linear isomorphism F→WF\to W.

The generated Ihara Lie algebra VfV^f is contained in WW. The generated Ihara Lie algebra VfV^f is contained in the original solution Lie subalgebra VV.

πw,nLie(p)∈𝔏S,w,n(α),ι(πw,nLie(p))=πw,nass(ιp).\pi^{\mathrm{Lie}}_{w,n}(p)\in\mathfrak L_{S,w,n}(\alpha),\qquad \iota\bigl(\pi^{\mathrm{Lie}}_{w,n}(p)\bigr) =\pi^{\mathrm{ass}}_{w,n}(\iota p).(21)