OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Deletion operators and injectivity of the leading projection

Proposition 4.1 [The deletion representation]: Zero deletion curvature gives commuting operators over any commutative coefficient ring

The integral deletion table satisfies flat relations.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The deletion representation concerns endomorphisms of a free associative algebra indexed by type B3B_3 hyperplanes and relations associated with their rank-two flats.

For a commutative ring SS and an alphabet α\alpha, the free associative algebra AS(α)A_S(\alpha) is the monoid algebra of the free monoid α*\alpha^* of finite words, as in (1). AS(α)=S[α*].A_S(\alpha)=S[\alpha^*].(1)✦ Write m(s)m(s) for the monomial of a word ss and i(a)i(a) for the image of a letter a∈αa\in\alpha. Let ε\varepsilon be the empty word, and for a word s∈α*s\in\alpha^* and a letter r∈αr\in\alpha, let hr(s)h_r(s) be the first letter of ss, or rr when s=εs=\varepsilon.

For a weight ν:α×α→S\nu:\alpha\times\alpha\to S and endpoints l,r∈αl,r\in\alpha, the word deletion rule dl,rνd^\nu_{l,r} is the function from finite words to AS(α)A_S(\alpha) defined recursively by (2); here asas denotes the letter aa followed by the word ss. dl,rν(ε)=0,dl,rν(as)=(ν(a,hr(s))−ν(l,a))m(s)+i(a)da,rν(s).\begin{aligned} d^\nu_{l,r}(\varepsilon)&=0,\\ d^\nu_{l,r}(as) &=\bigl(\nu(a,h_r(s))-\nu(l,a)\bigr)m(s) +i(a)d^\nu_{a,r}(s). \end{aligned}(2)✦ The deletion operator Tl,rνT^\nu_{l,r} is the SS-linear endomorphism of AS(α)A_S(\alpha) specified on word monomials by (3). Tl,rν(m(s))=dl,rν(s).T^\nu_{l,r}(m(s))=d^\nu_{l,r}(s).(3)✦ The bracket of endomorphisms is the commutator [U,V]=U∘V−V∘U[U,V]=U\circ V-V\circ U.

The deletion curvature 𝒦ν,μ:α4→S\mathcal K_{\nu,\mu}:\alpha^4\to S of weights ν,μ:α×α→S\nu,\mu:\alpha\times\alpha\to S is the function in (4). 𝒦ν,μ(l;a,b,c)=(ν(a,b)−ν(l,a))(μ(b,c)−μ(l,b))+(ν(b,c)−ν(a,b))(μ(a,c)−μ(l,a))−(μ(a,b)−μ(l,a))(ν(b,c)−ν(l,b))−(μ(b,c)−μ(a,b))(ν(a,c)−ν(l,a)).\begin{aligned} \mathcal K_{\nu,\mu}(l;a,b,c) ={}&(\nu(a,b)-\nu(l,a))(\mu(b,c)-\mu(l,b))\\ &+(\nu(b,c)-\nu(a,b))(\mu(a,c)-\mu(l,a))\\ &-(\mu(a,b)-\mu(l,a))(\nu(b,c)-\nu(l,b))\\ &-(\mu(b,c)-\mu(a,b))(\nu(a,c)-\nu(l,a)). \end{aligned}(4)✦

The Integral Table

The deletion alphabet Λ\Lambda and the family ℋ\mathcal H of type B3B_3 hyperplanes are the sets in (5); the aia_i are coordinate hyperplanes and the pij,mijp_{ij},m_{ij} are diagonal hyperplanes. Λ={o,e,p,w},ℋ={a1,a2,a3,p12,m12,p13,m13,p23,m23}.\begin{aligned} \Lambda&=\{o,e,p,w\},\\ \mathcal H&=\{a_1,a_2,a_3,p_{12},m_{12},p_{13},m_{13},p_{23},m_{23}\}. \end{aligned}(5) For H∈ℋH\in\mathcal H, the integral deletion weight νH:Λ×Λ→ℤ\nu_H:\Lambda\times\Lambda\to\mathbb Z is the symmetric function whose nonzero values on unordered pairs are listed in (6); every unlisted value is zero. {a,b}(H,νH(a,b)){o,p}(p23,1),(m23,−1){o,w}(p12,1),(m12,−1){e,p}(a3,1),(m23,−1){e,w}(a1,1),(m12,−1){p,w}(a2,1),(p13,1),(m12,−1),(m23,−1)\begin{array}{c|l} \{a,b\}&(H,\nu_H(a,b))\\ \hline \{o,p\}&(p_{23},1),\ (m_{23},-1)\\ \{o,w\}&(p_{12},1),\ (m_{12},-1)\\ \{e,p\}&(a_3,1),\ (m_{23},-1)\\ \{e,w\}&(a_1,1),\ (m_{12},-1)\\ \{p,w\}&(a_2,1),\ (p_{13},1),\ (m_{12},-1),\ (m_{23},-1) \end{array}(6)✦ For endpoints l,r∈Λl,r\in\Lambda, write TH(l,r)=Tl,rνHT_H(l,r)=T^{\nu_H}_{l,r} for the corresponding endomorphism of Aℤ(Λ)A_{\mathbb Z}(\Lambda).

The rank-two flats FiF_i, indexed by i=0,…,12i=0,\ldots,12, are the lists of hyperplanes in (7). F0=(a1,a2,p12,m12),F7=(a1,p23),F1=(a1,a3,p13,m13),F8=(a1,m23),F2=(a2,a3,p23,m23),F9=(a2,p13),F3=(p12,p13,p23),F10=(a2,m13),F4=(p12,m13,m23),F11=(a3,p12),F5=(m12,p13,m23),F12=(a3,m12),F6=(m12,m13,p23).\begin{aligned} F_0&=(a_1,a_2,p_{12},m_{12}), &F_7&=(a_1,p_{23}),\\ F_1&=(a_1,a_3,p_{13},m_{13}), &F_8&=(a_1,m_{23}),\\ F_2&=(a_2,a_3,p_{23},m_{23}), &F_9&=(a_2,p_{13}),\\ F_3&=(p_{12},p_{13},p_{23}), &F_{10}&=(a_2,m_{13}),\\ F_4&=(p_{12},m_{13},m_{23}), &F_{11}&=(a_3,p_{12}),\\ F_5&=(m_{12},p_{13},m_{23}), &F_{12}&=(a_3,m_{12}),\\ F_6&=(m_{12},m_{13},p_{23}). && \end{aligned}(7)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let SS be a commutative ring, α\alpha an alphabet and ν,μ:α×α→S\nu,\mu:\alpha\times\alpha\to S weights. Suppose that 𝒦ν,μ(l;a,b,c)\mathcal K_{\nu,\mu}(l;a,b,c) vanishes for every l,a,b,c∈αl,a,b,c\in\alpha. Then (8) holds for any endpoints l,r∈αl,r\in\alpha: [Tl,rμ,Tl,rν]=0.[T^\mu_{l,r},T^\nu_{l,r}]=0.(8)✦ For the integral weights of (6), let i∈{0,…,12}i\in\{0,\ldots,12\}, H∈FiH\in F_i and l,r∈Λl,r\in\Lambda. The flat relation is (9): [TH(l,r),∑G∈FiTG(l,r)]=0.\left[T_H(l,r),\sum_{G\in F_i}T_G(l,r)\right]=0.(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for the Lie algebra 𝔥ℤ\mathfrak h_{\mathbb Z} with generators tHt_H and its module ENE_N, the assignment tH↦THt_H\mapsto T_H represents this Lie algebra on this module, with [TH0,∑H⊃XTH]=0[T_{H_0},\sum_{H\supset X}T_H]=0 for every codimension-two flat XX and every hyperplane H0H_0 containing XX, and extends to the ordinary enveloping algebra over ℤ\mathbb Z and after reduction over the coefficient field 𝔽\mathbb F.

What Is Checked

Relation (8) is stated for arbitrary alphabets and commutative coefficient rings under the zero-curvature hypothesis; relation (9) is stated over Aℤ(Λ)A_{\mathbb Z}(\Lambda) at arbitrary endpoints for the integral weights in (6) and the flats in (7).