OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Near-extremal rectangles and two energy estimates

Near-extremal rectangles, added sheets and selected derivative fields: For (A,B)(A, B) in KK, grids of level-jj period blocks where a sheet’s derivative columns are nearly constant, with squared norms near (A,B)(A, B)

Near-extremal grid rectangles and sheets added at an unused level.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The ambient space is the Hilbert space ℓ2\ell^2 of square-summable real sequences.✦ The base plane ℝ2\mathbb{R}^2 carries the sup distance max⁡(|x−x′|,|y−y′|)\max(|x - x'|, |y - y'|) and sits in ℓ2\ell^2 through the base vector of p=(x,y)p = (x, y), the sequence with entries xx and yy at the indices 00 and 11 and zero elsewhere.✦ The other indices correspond one to one to the pairs (j,i)(j, i) of a level j≥0j \ge 0 and a color i≥0i \ge 0, and ej,ie_{j,i} is the unit vector at the index of (j,i)(j, i), orthogonal to the base plane and to every other ej′,i′e_{j',i'}.

Level jj has the scale rj=1000−(j+1)r_j = 1000^{-(j+1)}. Let the unpairing bijection ℕ→ℕ×ℕ\mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{N} \times \mathbb{N} send jj to a pair (m,k)(m, k) and mm to a pair (a,b)(a, b); the number of colors at level jj is Nj=a+1N_j = a + 1 and the width factor is Wj=b+1W_j = b + 1, both positive integers. The horizontal strips of level jj are the sets qrj<y<(q+1)rjq r_j < y < (q+1) r_j and the vertical strips of level jj the sets qWjrj<x<(q+1)Wjrjq W_j r_j < x < (q+1) W_j r_j, for q∈ℤq \in \mathbb{Z}; the strip of index qq has color qmod⁡Njq \bmod N_j.✦ The set Uj,iU_{j,i} of points allowed color ii at level jj is the union of the strips of color ii of both kinds.✦

A displacement tuple is a finitely supported sequence w=(wj)j≥0w = (w_j)_{j \ge 0} in which each wjw_j is 00 or a vector rjej,ir_j e_{j,i}✦; it is admissible at a point pp of the base plane when i<Nji < N_j and p∈Uj,ip \in U_{j,i} at every level jj with wj=rjej,iw_j = r_j e_{j,i}.✦ The point (p,w)(p, w) is the vector p+∑jwjp + \sum_j w_j of ℓ2\ell^2, with pp read as its base vector✦, and the constructed set is S={(p,w):p∈ℝ2,w a displacement tuple admissible at p}⊂ℓ2.S = \{(p, w) : p \in \mathbb{R}^2,\ w \text{ a displacement tuple admissible at } p\} \subset \ell^2.(1)✦ The sheet domain Ωw\Omega_w of a tuple ww is the open set of base points pp at which ww is admissible.✦

Let EE be a finite-dimensional real normed space and f:S→Ef \colon S \to E a DD-Lipschitz map. The sheet of ff at a tuple ww is the map Fw:ℝ2→EF_w \colon \mathbb{R}^2 \to E with Fw(p)=f(p,w)F_w(p) = f(p, w) on Ωw\Omega_w and Fw=0F_w = 0 off Ωw\Omega_w.✦ The derivative columns of a map G:ℝ2→EG \colon \mathbb{R}^2 \to E are its partial derivatives Gx(p)=DG(p)(1,0)G_x(p) = DG(p)(1, 0) and Gy(p)=DG(p)(0,1)G_y(p) = DG(p)(0, 1)✦ at the points pp where GG is differentiable, and 00 at the other points; for a sheet FwF_w they are taken on Ωw\Omega_w and set to 00 off it.✦

A good point of the sheet FwF_w is a point p=(x,y)p = (x, y) of Ωw\Omega_w at which FwF_w is differentiable and which is a Lebesgue point, in square mean, of both columns G=(Fw)xG = (F_w)_x and G=(Fw)yG = (F_w)_y: limρ→0+14ρ2∫[x−ρ,x+ρ]×[y−ρ,y+ρ]∥G(p′)−G(p)∥2dp′=0,\lim_{\rho \to 0^+} \frac{1}{4\rho^2} \int_{[x - \rho, x + \rho] \times [y - \rho, y + \rho]} \|G(p') - G(p)\|^2 \, dp' = 0,(2)✦ the square being the closed ball of radius ρ\rho about pp. The squared derivative pair of ff at ww and pp is (∥(Fw)x(p)∥2,∥(Fw)y(p)∥2)(\|(F_w)_x(p)\|^2, \|(F_w)_y(p)\|^2)✦, and K⊂ℝ2K \subset \mathbb{R}^2 is the closure of the set of these pairs at good points: K={(∥(Fw)x(p)∥2,∥(Fw)y(p)∥2):w a tuple,p a good point of Fw}¯.K = \overline{\bigl\{(\|(F_w)_x(p)\|^2, \|(F_w)_y(p)\|^2) : w \text{ a tuple},\ p \text{ a good point of } F_w\bigr\}}.(3)✦

Take a pair (A,B)(A, B) of KK and a tolerance t>0t > 0. The first question is whether some sheet of ff, on a rectangle made of whole periods of the coloring of a level jj that its tuple ww leaves unused, that is, with wj=0w_j = 0, has derivative columns nearly constant in square mean, at values whose squared norms fall short of AA and BB by at most tt. The second is what happens when the tuple is then displaced at level jj in each of the NjN_j colors: how far the new sheets move, and where the squared norms of their derivative columns lie.

Global Sheets, Rectangles and Period Blocks

The global sheet F‾w\bar{F}_w of ff at a tuple ww is a Lipschitz map from ℝ2\mathbb{R}^2 to EE that agrees with FwF_w on Ωw\Omega_w, fixed once for each ww.✦

A rectangle Q=[a,b]×[c,d]Q = [a, b] \times [c, d] in the plane is the product of two closed segments with a<ba < b and c<dc < d.✦ Its side lengths are Lx=b−aL_x = b - a and Ly=d−cL_y = d - c✦. The mean ⟨h⟩Q\langle h \rangle_Q of a function hh over QQ is the integral of hh against the uniform probability on QQ: ⟨h⟩Q=1LxLy∫ab∫cdh(x,y)dydx.\langle h \rangle_Q = \frac{1}{L_x L_y} \int_a^b \int_c^d h(x, y) \, dy \, dx.(4)✦

At level jj, the horizontal period Px=NjWjrjP_x = N_j W_j r_j is the width of NjN_j consecutive vertical strips✦, and the vertical period Py=NjrjP_y = N_j r_j is the height of NjN_j consecutive horizontal strips.✦ A grid of period blocks of level jj is a rectangle Q=[kPx,(k+m)Px]×[lPy,(l+n)Py]Q = [k P_x, (k + m) P_x] \times [l P_y, (l + n) P_y](5)✦ with integers k,lk, l and positive integers m,nm, n, made of m×nm \times n blocks of size Px×PyP_x \times P_y.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let NN and WW be positive integers, ww a tuple and ε>0\varepsilon > 0. There is a level jj with Nj=N,Wj=W,wj=0,rj<ε.N_j = N, \qquad W_j = W, \qquad w_j = 0, \qquad r_j < \varepsilon.(6)✦

Theorem 2. Let ww be a tuple, pp a good point of the sheet FwF_w of ff, and ε>0\varepsilon > 0. There is a rectangle Q⊂ΩwQ \subset \Omega_w on which the derivative columns of the global sheet F‾w\bar{F}_w satisfy ⟨∥(F‾w)x−(Fw)x(p)∥2⟩Q<ε,⟨∥(F‾w)y−(Fw)y(p)∥2⟩Q<ε.\bigl\langle \|(\bar{F}_w)_x - (F_w)_x(p)\|^2 \bigr\rangle_Q < \varepsilon, \qquad \bigl\langle \|(\bar{F}_w)_y - (F_w)_y(p)\|^2 \bigr\rangle_Q < \varepsilon.(7)✦

Theorem 3. Let NN and WW be positive integers, (A,B)(A, B) a pair of KK and t>0t > 0. There are a tuple ww, a level jj with Nj=NN_j = N, Wj=WW_j = W and wj=0w_j = 0, a grid Q⊂ΩwQ \subset \Omega_w of period blocks of level jj, and vectors u,v∈Eu, v \in E such that, with F=F‾wF = \bar{F}_w, ∥u∥≤2D,∥v∥≤2D,A−∥u∥2≤t,B−∥v∥2≤t,⟨∥Fx−u∥2⟩Q≤t2,⟨∥Fy−v∥2⟩Q≤t2,rjLx≤t,rjLy≤t.\begin{gathered} \|u\| \le 2D, \qquad \|v\| \le 2D, \qquad A - \|u\|^2 \le t, \qquad B - \|v\|^2 \le t, \\ \bigl\langle \|F_x - u\|^2 \bigr\rangle_Q \le t^2, \qquad \bigl\langle \|F_y - v\|^2 \bigr\rangle_Q \le t^2, \qquad \frac{r_j}{L_x} \le t, \qquad \frac{r_j}{L_y} \le t. \end{gathered}(8)✦

Definition 1. Let ww be a tuple, jj a level and, for a color i<Nji < N_j, wj,iw^{j,i} the tuple that agrees with ww off level jj and has entry rjej,ir_j e_{j,i} at level jj. The added sheets of ff at ww and jj are the global sheets Fi=F‾wj,i,i=0,1,…,Nj−1.F_i = \bar{F}_{w^{j,i}}, \qquad i = 0, 1, \dots, N_j - 1.(9)✦ For p=(x,y)p = (x, y), let cH(p)=⌊y/rj⌋mod⁡Njc_H(p) = \lfloor y / r_j \rfloor \bmod N_j and cV(p)=⌊x/(Wjrj)⌋mod⁡Njc_V(p) = \lfloor x / (W_j r_j) \rfloor \bmod N_j be the colors of the horizontal and the vertical strip of level jj through pp.✦ The selected derivative columns are GHx(p)=(FcH(p))x(p),GHy(p)=(FcH(p))y(p),GVx(p)=(FcV(p))x(p),GVy(p)=(FcV(p))y(p).\begin{gathered} G_H^x(p) = (F_{c_H(p)})_x(p), \qquad G_H^y(p) = (F_{c_H(p)})_y(p), \\ G_V^x(p) = (F_{c_V(p)})_x(p), \qquad G_V^y(p) = (F_{c_V(p)})_y(p). \end{gathered}(10)

Theorem 4. Let ww be a tuple, jj a level with wj=0w_j = 0, F=F‾wF = \bar{F}_w and FiF_i the added sheets at ww and jj. For every color i<Nji < N_j and every point p∈Ωw∩Uj,ip \in \Omega_w \cap U_{j,i}, ∥Fi(p)−F(p)∥≤Drj.\|F_i(p) - F(p)\| \le D r_j.(11)✦

Theorem 5. Let ww be a tuple, jj a level with wj=0w_j = 0, and Q⊂ΩwQ \subset \Omega_w a rectangle. For almost every point pp of QQ, (∥GHx(p)∥2,∥GHy(p)∥2)∈K,\bigl(\|G_H^x(p)\|^2, \|G_H^y(p)\|^2\bigr) \in K,(12)✦ and for almost every point pp of QQ, (∥GVx(p)∥2,∥GVy(p)∥2)∈K.\bigl(\|G_V^x(p)\|^2, \|G_V^y(p)\|^2\bigr) \in K.(13)✦

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over the set S⊂ℓ2S \subset \ell^2 with its levels, scales, colors, width factors and colored strips, and over a DD-Lipschitz map ff from SS to a finite-dimensional real normed space EE, with its sheets and their derivative columns, the good points, the set KK, the global sheets, the means over rectangles, the grids of period blocks, the added sheets and the selected columns. Beyond the claims, the library proves that the periods PxP_x and PyP_y are positive.