The Setting
The question is whether a common marginal on can have an optimal Coulomb coupling without an optimal transport given by two maps. A triple configuration is a point of ✦; its coordinate projections are ✦, ✦ and ✦. The inverse distance is , with value at .✦ The extended Coulomb cost in (1) takes value at every collision; away from collisions, the same reciprocal sum also defines a real scalar cost. (1)✦
For a probability measure on , a three-marginal self-coupling of is a probability measure on whose three coordinate pushforwards equal .✦ For a probability measure on , is the set of its three-marginal self-couplings. A measure-preserving map for is a measurable map with .✦ The Kantorovich infimum , the Monge transport cost , and the Monge infimum are defined in (2), where the last infimum is over measure-preserving pairs. (2) Kantorovich attainment means that a coupling realizes .✦ Monge nonattainment means that every measure-preserving pair has cost strictly above .✦ Finite-cost Monge approximation means that, for each , a measure-preserving pair has finite cost at most .✦
The density measure of a real function is , where ; for nonnegative densities it is denoted .✦ A smooth compact probability density is a nonnegative function such that both and are smooth and compactly supported, with .✦ A Coulomb counterexample density on is a smooth compact probability density whose measure is a probability measure with finite Kantorovich value, Kantorovich attainment and Monge nonattainment.✦ A density on satisfies the full Coulomb conclusion when it is a Coulomb counterexample density and its measure satisfies and admits finite-cost Monge approximation.✦
Branches and Certificates
For maps , the parametrized triple graph is the map from to defined by .✦ Given a probability measure and four measurable branches , define the five-component marginal and the cyclic branch coupling by (3) and (4). (3)✦ (4)✦
For local homeomorphisms of a space , with , their common central parametrization consists of the inverse branch and the reparametrized outer branch , defined on the points where the successive maps in (5) are defined. (5) For a central set and branches , the component regions are .✦
A bounded real certificate on a measurable set is a measurable function , bounded by on for some , satisfying (6). The contact relation of a bounded real certificate is the relation on triples defined by the equality condition in (7); the positive part is regarded as a nonnegative extended real. (6) (7)
The Claim
Theorem 1. For every probability measure and measurable branches , the marginal and cyclic coupling of (3) and (4) satisfy (8). (8)✦ Suppose is concentrated on , each , and is a bounded real certificate on . Assume and for -almost every . Then (9) holds. (9)✦
For the local homeomorphisms in (5), suppose is a permutation of , where , belongs to the source of , and both and lie outside . Then (10) holds. (10)✦
Let be a probability measure, , and suppose for -almost every . Let be a relation on triples and a relation on pairs. Assume every optimal coupling is concentrated on , and with implies . Suppose no measure-preserving map for satisfies for -almost every . Then (11) holds. (11)✦
Suppose the hypotheses for (9) hold, is measurable, and for a smooth compact probability density . Assume the branches are injective on and send every measurable subset of to a measurable set. Suppose the five component regions are pairwise disjoint, and every contact triple satisfies . Then (12) holds. (12)✦
Let with , where is its center. Suppose four local homeomorphisms have sources containing , are smooth on their sources, and have smooth inverses on their targets. Assume their five component regions are pairwise disjoint and contained in a measurable set . Let be a bounded real certificate on , with both branch triples in contact for every . Suppose every contact triple in has its second entry among the four branches at its first entry. Then (13) holds. (13)✦
In the paper, the result reads: choosing either branch uniformly and permuting the entries of , with distributed as , gives a coupling with all marginals and by saturation of the certificate; every optimal coupling is concentrated on the contact set, and an optimal graph plan would force for -almost every central , contradicting Lemma 2.1, which excludes a measure-preserving map with this selection property.
What Is Checked
The assertions are stated over probability measures and measurable branches, arbitrary contact and selection relations, and smooth local homeomorphisms on a positive-radius ball, with the certificate, disjointness and selection hypotheses specified in the theorem.