OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. A supporting inequality on five components

Lemma 4.2 [A common central ball for all four branches]: Smooth inverse parametrizations preserve contact and place the outer images in prescribed components

Four branches share a central ball.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

In a five-component Coulomb construction, contact triples are first parameterized by points near the first two standard basis vectors e1e_1 and e2e_2 in ℝ3\mathbb R^3. Their outer entries must be expressed in a common central coordinate. The component centers are (b0,b1,b2,b3,b4)=(0,e1,−e1,e2,−e2)(b_0,b_1,b_2,b_3,b_4)=(0,e_1,-e_1,e_2,-e_2); write U0,Uk+,Uk−U_0,U_k^+,U_k^- for open neighborhoods of 0,ek,−ek0,e_k,-e_k, respectively, for k=1,2k=1,2.✦

The configuration space is (ℝ3)3(\mathbb R^3)^3, with points (x,y,z)(x,y,z) and coordinate projections p1,p2,p3p_1,p_2,p_3. The extended Coulomb cost is the sum of the inverse distances, each infinite at coincidence: c(x,y,z)={|x−y|−1+|x−z|−1+|y−z|−1,x,y,z pairwise distinct,+∞,otherwise.c(x,y,z)= \begin{cases} |x-y|^{-1}+|x-z|^{-1}+|y-z|^{-1}, &x,y,z\text{ pairwise distinct},\\ +\infty,&\text{otherwise}. \end{cases}(1)✦ For real local calculations, the scalar interaction qq and Coulomb gradient gg are defined by q(w)=|w|−1,g(w)=−w|w|3(w≠0),q(0)=0,g(0)=0.q(w)=|w|^{-1},\qquad g(w)=-\frac{w}{|w|^3}\quad(w\ne0), \qquad q(0)=0,\quad g(0)=0.(2)

Supporting Charts

For a direction a∈ℝ3a\in\mathbb R^3, the adjusted Coulomb state potential Fa(y;x,z)F_a(y;x,z) is a real function of parameter yy and state (x,z)(x,z), also regarded jointly as a function of (y,x,z)(y,x,z). Using (2) and the fixed quadratic coefficient K=20K=20, it and the Coulomb stationarity map GaG_a are defined by $$\begin{aligned} \phi_0(x)&=\frac52-10|x|^2, &\phi_a^-(z)&=\frac54\langle a,z+a\rangle-10|z+a|^2,\\ F_a(y;x,z)&=q(x-y)+q(x-z)+q(z-y)-\phi_0(x)-\phi_a^-(z),\\ G_a(y;x,z)&=\bigl(g(x-y)+g(x-z)+20x,\\ &\hspace{35mm}g(z-x)+g(z-y)-\tfrac54a+20(z+a)\bigr). \end{aligned}$$(3)

Let P,SP,S be real normed spaces. Analytic stationary charts X,ZX,Z for a map G:P×(S×S)→S×SG:P\times(S\times S)\to S\times S at a parameter p∈Pp\in P and state s∈S×Ss\in S\times S are homeomorphisms between open subsets of PP and SS, with a common source DD containing pp, (X(p),Z(p))=s(X(p),Z(p))=s, and analytic maps and inverses on their respective domains. Their chart states belong to an open state neighborhood VV of ss and satisfy G(y;z)=0⇔z=(X(y),Z(y)),y∈D,z∈V.G(y;z)=0\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad z=(X(y),Z(y)), \qquad y\in D,\quad z\in V.(4) On a real Euclidean space EE, a local exact supporting chart (X,Z,v)(X,Z,v) for a scalar potential F:E×(E×E)→ℝF:E\times(E\times E)\to\mathbb R and stationarity map G:E×(E×E)→E×EG:E\times(E\times E)\to E\times E at a parameter p∈Ep\in E and state s∈E×Es\in E\times E consists of analytic stationary charts X,ZX,Z for GG at pp and ss, with D=B(p,r)D=B(p,r) and V=B(s,δ)V=B(s,\delta) for r,δ>0r,\delta>0, together with a real-valued supporting function vv, analytic on DD, satisfying v(y)=F(y;X(y),Z(y))for every parameter y,v(p)=F(p;s),v(y)≤F(y;z)(y∈D,z∈V),F(y;z)=v(y)⇔z=(X(y),Z(y))(y∈D,z∈V).\begin{aligned} v(y)&=F(y;X(y),Z(y))\quad\text{for every parameter }y,\\ v(p)&=F(p;s),\\ v(y)&\le F(y;z)\quad(y\in D,\ z\in V),\\ F(y;z)=v(y)&\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad z=(X(y),Z(y)) \quad(y\in D,\ z\in V). \end{aligned}(5)✦ For k=1,2k=1,2, a Coulomb supporting chart CkC_k is a local exact supporting chart for F=FekF=F_{e_k} and G=GekG=G_{e_k} from (3) at p=ekp=e_k and s=(0,−ek)s=(0,-e_k), satisfying (4) and (5).✦ Denote their maps by Xk,ZkX_k,Z_k, their common sources by DkD_k, and their supporting values by vkv_k.

For a homeomorphism TT between open sets, let D(T)D(T) and I(T)I(T) be its source and image. The central inverse Y=X−1Y=X^{-1} and reparametrized outer branch W=Z∘X−1W=Z\circ X^{-1} are homeomorphisms between open sets with sources D(Y)=I(X),D(W)={x∈I(X):X−1(x)∈D(Z)}.D(Y)=I(X),\qquad D(W)=\{x\in I(X):X^{-1}(x)\in D(Z)\}.(6) For two chart pairs, the four central outer branches from (6) are the ordered family (H1,H2,H3,H4)=(Y1,W1,Y2,W2),Yk=Xk−1,Wk=Zk∘Xk−1.(H_1,H_2,H_3,H_4)=(Y_1,W_1,Y_2,W_2), \qquad Y_k=X_k^{-1},\quad W_k=Z_k\circ X_k^{-1}.(7)✦

For the Coulomb charts, the symmetric branch contact set 𝒮\mathcal S consists of all coordinate permutations of the parameterized contact triples: 𝒮=⋃k=12{σ(Xk(y),y,Zk(y)):y∈Dk,σ∈S3},\mathcal S= \bigcup_{k=1}^2 \{\sigma(X_k(y),y,Z_k(y)):y\in D_k,\ \sigma\in S_3\},(8)✦ where S3S_3 is the group of permutations of three coordinates.

The five local potentials, in the component order already fixed, are (ϕ0,ϕ1,ϕ2,ϕ3,ϕ4)=(ϕ0,v1,ϕe1−,v2,ϕe2−).(\phi_0,\phi_1,\phi_2,\phi_3,\phi_4) =(\phi_0,v_1,\phi_{e_1}^-,v_2,\phi_{e_2}^-).(9)✦

Transport Conclusions

The density measure μ=ρdx\mu=\rho\,dx of a real function ρ\rho on ℝ3\mathbb R^3 is the Borel measure on ℝ3\mathbb R^3 defined by dμ=max⁡{ρ,0}dxd\mu=\max\{\rho,0\}\,dx.✦ A smooth compact probability density ρ\rho on ℝ3\mathbb R^3 is a nonnegative real function with integral one for which both ρ\rho and ρ\sqrt\rho are smooth and compactly supported.✦

A three-marginal self-coupling π\pi of μ\mu is a probability measure on (ℝ3)3(\mathbb R^3)^3 satisfying (pi)#π=μ(p_i)_\#\pi=\mu for i=1,2,3i=1,2,3; denote the set of these couplings by Π3(μ)\Pi_3(\mu).✦ A measure-preserving map T:ℝ3→ℝ3T:\mathbb R^3\to\mathbb R^3 for μ\mu is a measurable map with T#μ=μT_\#\mu=\mu.✦ Using the extended cost (1), the Kantorovich value, Monge graph cost and Monge infimum are E*(μ)=infπ∈Π3(μ)∫cdπ,Jμ(T2,T3)=∫c(x,T2(x),T3(x))dμ(x),M*(μ)=inf(T2)#μ=(T3)#μ=μJμ(T2,T3),\begin{aligned} E_*(\mu)&=\inf_{\pi\in\Pi_3(\mu)}\int c\,d\pi,\\ J_\mu(T_2,T_3)&=\int c(x,T_2(x),T_3(x))\,d\mu(x),\\ M_*(\mu)&=\inf_{(T_2)_\#\mu=(T_3)_\#\mu=\mu} J_\mu(T_2,T_3), \end{aligned}(10) where the last infimum is over measurable maps. Kantorovich attainment means that a coupling realizes the first infimum in (10)✦; Monge nonattainment means Jμ(T2,T3)>E*(μ)J_\mu(T_2,T_3)>E_*(\mu) for every pair of measure-preserving maps.✦

A Coulomb counterexample density ρ\rho on ℝ3\mathbb R^3 is a smooth compact probability density whose measure μ=ρdx\mu=\rho\,dx is a probability measure with finite E*(μ)E_*(\mu), Kantorovich attainment and Monge nonattainment.✦ Finite-cost Monge approximation for μ\mu means that, for every ε>0\varepsilon>0, there are measure-preserving maps with Jμ(T2,T3)<∞J_\mu(T_2,T_3)<\infty and Jμ(T2,T3)≤E*(μ)+εJ_\mu(T_2,T_3)\le E_*(\mu)+\varepsilon.✦ Write ℱ(ρ)\mathcal F(\rho) for the full Coulomb conclusion: ρ\rho is a Coulomb counterexample density, M*(μ)=E*(μ)M_*(\mu)=E_*(\mu), and finite-cost Monge approximation holds.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let Xi,ZiX_i,Z_i be a finite family of homeomorphisms between open subsets of a metric space, and let aia_i belong to both sources, with Xi(ai)=x0X_i(a_i)=x_0 for every ii. Let Pi,QiP_i,Q_i be open neighborhoods of ai,Zi(ai)a_i,Z_i(a_i), respectively, and let UU be an open neighborhood of x0x_0. For the inverse compositions defined in (6), there is a common central ball: r>0,B(x0,r)⊂U,B(x0,r)⊂D(Wi),Yi(B(x0,r))⊂Pi,Wi(B(x0,r))⊂Qifor every i.\begin{gathered} r>0,\qquad B(x_0,r)\subset U,\\ B(x_0,r)\subset D(W_i),\quad Y_i(B(x_0,r))\subset P_i,\quad W_i(B(x_0,r))\subset Q_i \quad\text{for every }i. \end{gathered}(11)✦

For two chart pairs on a real normed space and a differentiability order nn, suppose each Xk−1X_k^{-1} is CnC^n on I(Xk)I(X_k) and each ZkZ_k is CnC^n on D(Zk)D(Z_k). The four branches (7) satisfy Hj∈Cn(D(Hj)),j=1,2,3,4.H_j\in C^n(D(H_j)),\qquad j=1,2,3,4.(12)✦ If instead each XkX_k is CnC^n on D(Xk)D(X_k) and each Zk−1Z_k^{-1} is CnC^n on I(Zk)I(Z_k), then Hj−1∈Cn(I(Hj)),j=1,2,3,4.H_j^{-1}\in C^n(I(H_j)),\qquad j=1,2,3,4.(13)✦

Let X,ZX,Z be homeomorphisms between open subsets of a common space, and let 𝒞\mathcal C be a predicate on triples such that 𝒞(X(y),y,Z(y))\mathcal C(X(y),y,Z(y)) holds for every y∈D(X)y\in D(X). Contact is preserved on the source of the outer composition: 𝒞(x,Y(x),W(x)),x∈D(W).\mathcal C(x,Y(x),W(x)),\qquad x\in D(W).(14)✦

For the Coulomb supporting charts C1,C2C_1,C_2, assume that DkD_k and Zk(Dk)Z_k(D_k) avoid B(0,1/4)B(0,1/4) for k=1,2k=1,2. Let R>0R>0 make the five balls Vi=B(bi,R)V_i=B(b_i,R) pairwise disjoint. Let u:ℝ3→ℝu:\mathbb R^3\to\mathbb R be measurable, with |u|≤M|u|\le M for some M≥0M\ge0, and agree with ϕi\phi_i from (9) on ViV_i. For a real number tt, write t+=max⁡{t,0}t_+=\max\{t,0\}, viewed as a nonnegative extended real. Assume that for every x,y,z∈⋃iVix,y,z\in\bigcup_iV_i, (u(x)+u(y)+u(z))+≤c(x,y,z)(u(x)+u(y)+u(z))_+\le c(x,y,z), and that equality implies (x,y,z)∈𝒮(x,y,z)\in\mathcal S, with 𝒮\mathcal S as in (8). Then there exists ρ:ℝ3→ℝ such that ℱ(ρ).\text{there exists }\rho:\mathbb R^3\to\mathbb R \text{ such that }\mathcal F(\rho).(15)✦

In the paper, the result reads: there is a positive-radius open ball BB about zero contained in U0U_0 such that Yk=(Xk|Uk+)−1|BY_k=(X_k|_{U_k^+})^{-1}|_B and Wk=Zk∘YkW_k=Z_k\circ Y_k are well-defined diffeomorphisms onto open images contained in Uk+U_k^+ and Uk−U_k^-, respectively, for k=1,2k=1,2, every (x,Yk(x),Wk(x))(x,Y_k(x),W_k(x)) with x∈Bx\in B is an equality triple for the certificate, and B,Y1(B),W1(B),Y2(B),W2(B)B,Y_1(B),W_1(B),Y_2(B),W_2(B) are pairwise disjoint.

What Is Checked

The assertions (11), (12), (13) and (14) concern finite families of homeomorphisms between open sets and their inverse compositions, while (15) is stated over exact Coulomb supporting charts and a bounded measurable certificate on five disjoint component balls.