OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. Two local Coulomb branches

Lemma 3.1 [Two local exact supporting families]: Analytic branch charts with unique contact and separation from the central ball

Exact Coulomb supports near coordinate directions.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let e0,e1,e2e_0,e_1,e_2 be the coordinate unit vectors of ℝ3\mathbb R^3. For k∈{0,1,2}k\in\{0,1,2\}, the local dual problem near (0,ek,−ek)(0,e_k,-e_k) is to find a sum of one-particle potentials below the Coulomb cost and to specify its equality set. The configuration space is (ℝ3)3(\mathbb R^3)^3, with (x,y,z)(x,y,z) denoting the first, second and third particle positions.✦

The inverse distance between two points is 1/|x−y|1/|x-y|, with value +∞+\infty when they coincide.✦ The three-particle Coulomb cost cc is the extended function in (1), with value +∞+\infty at every collision: c(x,y,z)=1|x−y|+1|x−z|+1|y−z|.c(x,y,z)=\frac1{|x-y|}+\frac1{|x-z|}+\frac1{|y-z|}.(1)✦

For local scalar potentials on a real Euclidean space EE, the real Coulomb interaction qq, its Coulomb gradient gg, and the scalar three-particle sum ℓ\ell are defined by (2), using the real reciprocal of zero equal to zero: q(u)=|u|−1,g(u)=−|u|−3u,ℓ(x,y,z)=q(x−y)+q(x−z)+q(y−z).\begin{aligned} q(u)&=|u|^{-1}, & g(u)&=-|u|^{-3}u,\\ \ell(x,y,z)&=q(x-y)+q(x-z)+q(y-z). \end{aligned}(2)

The construction fixes K=20K=20. For a∈Ea\in E, the quadratic potentials u0,vau_0,v_a and the adjusted state potential FaF_a are the real functions in (3); yy is the parameter and (x,z)(x,z) is the state. The joint potential is FaF_a regarded as a function on E×(E×E)E\times(E\times E).✦ u0(x)=52−10|x|2,va(z)=54⟨a,z+a⟩−10|z+a|2,Fa(y;x,z)=ℓ(x,y,z)−u0(x)−va(z).\begin{aligned} u_0(x)&=\frac52-10|x|^2,\\ v_a(z)&=\frac54\langle a,z+a\rangle-10|z+a|^2,\\ F_a(y;x,z)&=\ell(x,y,z)-u_0(x)-v_a(z). \end{aligned}(3)✦ The Coulomb stationarity map Ga:E×(E×E)→E×EG_a:E\times(E\times E)\to E\times E is the map in (4): Ga(y;x,z)=(g(x−y)+g(x−z)+20x,g(z−x)+g(z−y)−54a+20(z+a)).G_a(y;x,z)= \left( g(x-y)+g(x-z)+20x,\; g(z-x)+g(z-y)-\frac54a+20(z+a) \right).(4)✦

Stationary and Supporting Charts

For a stationarity map G:P×(S×S)→S×SG:P\times(S\times S)\to S\times S on a parameter space PP and a state space SS, analytic stationary charts about p∈Pp\in P and s∈S×Ss\in S\times S are maps X,Z:P→SX,Z:P\to S whose restrictions to a common open neighborhood UU of pp are analytic diffeomorphisms onto open images, with (X(p),Z(p))=s(X(p),Z(p))=s, together with an open state neighborhood VV of ss satisfying (5): (X(y),Z(y))∈V(y∈U),G(y;ξ)=0⇔ξ=(X(y),Z(y))(y∈U,ξ∈V).\begin{gathered} (X(y),Z(y))\in V \qquad (y\in U),\\ G(y;\xi)=0\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \xi=(X(y),Z(y)) \qquad (y\in U,\ \xi\in V). \end{gathered}(5)✦

Write BB for an open Euclidean ball. A local exact supporting chart 𝒞\mathcal C for a real potential F:E×(E×E)→ℝF:E\times(E\times E)\to\mathbb R and a stationarity map GG about (p,s)(p,s), with s=(s1,s2)s=(s_1,s_2), consists of analytic stationary charts X,Z:E→EX,Z:E\to E with U=B(p,r)U=B(p,r) and V=B(s1,R)×B(s2,R)V=B(s_1,R)\times B(s_2,R) for positive radii r,Rr,R, together with a real function w:E→ℝw:E\to\mathbb R, analytic on UU, satisfying (6). w(y)=F(y;X(y),Z(y))(y∈E),w(p)=F(p;s),w(y)≤F(y;ξ)(y∈U,ξ∈V),F(y;ξ)=w(y)⇔ξ=(X(y),Z(y))(y∈U,ξ∈V).\begin{aligned} w(y)&=F(y;X(y),Z(y)) &&(y\in E),\\ w(p)&=F(p;s),\\ w(y)&\leq F(y;\xi) &&(y\in U,\ \xi\in V),\\ F(y;\xi)=w(y)&\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \xi=(X(y),Z(y)) &&(y\in U,\ \xi\in V). \end{aligned}(6)✦

Write 𝒮E(a)\mathcal S_E(a) for the family of local exact supporting charts for Fa,GaF_a,G_a about (a,(0,−a))(a,(0,-a)). A Coulomb supporting chart 𝒞\mathcal C at a∈ℝ3a\in\mathbb R^3 is a member of 𝒮ℝ3(a)\mathcal S_{\mathbb R^3}(a). For 𝒞∈𝒮E(a)\mathcal C\in\mathcal S_E(a), write X𝒞,Z𝒞X_{\mathcal C},Z_{\mathcal C} for its parameterized charts and r𝒞,R𝒞,w𝒞r_{\mathcal C},R_{\mathcal C},w_{\mathcal C} for its radii and supporting value. For a coordinate direction ak=eka_k=e_k, use vk=vakv_k=v_{a_k} and write Xk,ZkX_k,Z_k for a chosen pair of charts.

The Claim

Theorem 1. In ℝ3\mathbb R^3, for each ak=eka_k=e_k with k∈{0,1,2}k\in\{0,1,2\}, the coordinate families satisfy (7) and admit the separated choices in (8): 𝒮ℝ3(ak)≠⌀.\mathcal S_{\mathbb R^3}(a_k)\ne\varnothing.(7)✦ There is 𝒞k∈𝒮ℝ3(ak) such that|y|≥14,|Zk(y)|≥14(y∈B(ak,r𝒞k)).\begin{gathered} \text{There is }\mathcal C_k\in\mathcal S_{\mathbb R^3}(a_k)\text{ such that}\\ |y|\geq\frac14,\qquad |Z_k(y)|\geq\frac14 \qquad\bigl(y\in B(a_k,r_{\mathcal C_k})\bigr). \end{gathered}(8)✦

Let EE be a real Euclidean space, a∈Ea\in E, and 𝒞∈𝒮E(a)\mathcal C\in\mathcal S_E(a). For |a|=1|a|=1, the supporting value satisfies (9): w𝒞(a)=0.w_{\mathcal C}(a)=0.(9)✦ For y∈B(a,r𝒞)y\in B(a,r_{\mathcal C}), x∈B(0,R𝒞)x\in B(0,R_{\mathcal C}) and z∈B(−a,R𝒞)z\in B(-a,R_{\mathcal C}), the scalar statements (10) and (11) hold: u0(x)+w𝒞(y)+va(z)≤ℓ(x,y,z).u_0(x)+w_{\mathcal C}(y)+v_a(z)\leq\ell(x,y,z).(10)✦ ℓ(x,y,z)=u0(x)+w𝒞(y)+va(z)⇔(x,z)=(X𝒞(y),Z𝒞(y)).\ell(x,y,z)=u_0(x)+w_{\mathcal C}(y)+v_a(z) \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad (x,z)=(X_{\mathcal C}(y),Z_{\mathcal C}(y)).(11)✦ When E=ℝ3E=\mathbb R^3 and x,y,zx,y,z are pairwise distinct, the extended statement (12) holds, where t+=max⁡{t,0}t_+=\max\{t,0\} is viewed in [0,+∞][0,+\infty]: (u0(x)+w𝒞(y)+va(z))+≤c(x,y,z),(u0(x)+w𝒞(y)+va(z))+=c(x,y,z)⇔(x,z)=(X𝒞(y),Z𝒞(y)).\begin{gathered} \bigl(u_0(x)+w_{\mathcal C}(y)+v_a(z)\bigr)_+\leq c(x,y,z),\\ \bigl(u_0(x)+w_{\mathcal C}(y)+v_a(z)\bigr)_+=c(x,y,z) \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad (x,z)=(X_{\mathcal C}(y),Z_{\mathcal C}(y)). \end{gathered}(12)✦

In the paper, the result reads: there are K>0K>0 and, for k=1,2k=1,2, open neighborhoods P0k,Pk+,Pk−P_0^k,P_k^+,P_k^- of 0,ak,−ak0,a_k,-a_k, respectively, and smooth maps Xk,Zk:Pk+→ℝ3X_k,Z_k:P_k^+\to\mathbb R^3, each a diffeomorphism onto its open image, with Xk(ak)=0X_k(a_k)=0 and Zk(ak)=−akZ_k(a_k)=-a_k, and a smooth function wk:Pk+→ℝw_k:P_k^+\to\mathbb R with wk(ak)=0w_k(a_k)=0, such that for the paper’s potentials u0,vku_0,v_k one has c(x,y,z)≥u0(x)+wk(y)+vk(z)c(x,y,z)\geq u_0(x)+w_k(y)+v_k(z) on P0k×Pk+×Pk−P_0^k\times P_k^+\times P_k^-, with equality exactly when (x,z)=(Xk(y),Zk(y))(x,z)=(X_k(y),Z_k(y)).

What Is Checked

The statements are over the real Coulomb state potential FaF_a and stationarity map GaG_a, with local exact supporting charts 𝒞∈𝒮E(a)\mathcal C\in\mathcal S_E(a); the extended certificate concerns pairwise distinct triples in ℝ3\mathbb R^3.