OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. An obstruction to deterministic selection

Lemma 2.1 [No preserving deterministic branch selector]: Smaller outer weights and disjoint images for finite nonzero reference measures

An obstruction to measure-preserving branch selection.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A deterministic transport can be constrained to send each point of a central set along one of finitely many prescribed branches. The measure to be preserved assigns a central weight to the reference measure and an outer weight to each of its branch images.

Let EE be a nonempty measurable space and II a finite index set. For a measure ν\nu on EE, maps Hi:E→EH_i:E\to E, and weights a,bi∈[0,∞]a,b_i\in[0,\infty], the weighted splitting measure μ\mu is the measure given by (1). μ=aν+∑i∈Ibi(Hi)#ν.\mu=a\nu+\sum_{i\in I}b_i(H_i)_\#\nu.(1) A local homeomorphic branch Hi:Ui→ViH_i:U_i\to V_i is a homeomorphism between open subsets of a topological space EE. When ν\nu is concentrated on a measurable set B⊂UiB\subset U_i, the pushforward (Hi)#ν(H_i)_\#\nu uses ν\nu on that domain.

Let HH denote the family of branches HiH_i, indexed by II. A preserving deterministic branch selector T:E→ET:E\to E for μ\mu along HH on a measurable set B⊂EB\subset E is a measurable map that preserves μ\mu and chooses a branch at ν\nu-almost every point of BB. Denote the set of these maps by 𝒮ν,B(μ;H)={T:E→E:T is measurable,T#μ=μ,T(x)∈{Hi(x):i∈I} for ν-almost every x∈B}.\begin{split} \mathcal S_{\nu,B}(\mu;H)=\bigl\{T:E\to E:\;&T\text{ is measurable},\quad T_\#\mu=\mu,\\ &T(x)\in\{H_i(x):i\in I\} \text{ for }\nu\text{-almost every }x\in B\bigr\}. \end{split}(2) The central set and the outer images are disjoint when B∩Hi(B)=⌀(i∈I),Hi(B)∩Hj(B)=⌀(i≠j).B\cap H_i(B)=\varnothing\quad(i\in I),\qquad H_i(B)\cap H_j(B)=\varnothing\quad(i\ne j).(3)

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ν\nu be a finite nonzero measure concentrated on a measurable set BB, and assume (3).

Suppose EE is a topological space with its Borel sigma-algebra, ν\nu is a probability measure, and H1,…,H4H_1,\ldots,H_4 are local homeomorphic branches whose open domains contain BB. Then 𝒮ν,B(13ν+16∑i=14(Hi)#ν;H)=⌀.\mathcal S_{\nu,B}\left( \frac13\nu+\frac16\sum_{i=1}^{4}(H_i)_\#\nu;H\right)=\varnothing.(4)✦

More generally, suppose EE is a topological space with its Borel sigma-algebra, HiH_i are local homeomorphic branches whose open domains contain BB, and c,d∈[0,∞]c,d\in[0,\infty] satisfy d<cd<c. Then 𝒮ν,B(cν+d∑i∈I(Hi)#ν;H)=⌀.\mathcal S_{\nu,B}\left(c\nu+d\sum_{i\in I}(H_i)_\#\nu;H\right) =\varnothing.(5)✦

Suppose instead that the diagonal of E×EE\times E is measurable, each map Hi:E→EH_i:E\to E is measurable and injective on BB, and Hi(S)H_i(S) is measurable for every measurable subset SS of BB. For c,d∈[0,∞]c,d\in[0,\infty] with d<cd<c, 𝒮ν,B(cν+d∑i∈I(Hi)#ν;H)=⌀.\mathcal S_{\nu,B}\left(c\nu+d\sum_{i\in I}(H_i)_\#\nu;H\right) =\varnothing.(6)✦

Let μ,ν\mu,\nu be arbitrary measures on a measurable space EE, and let T:E→ET:E\to E be measurable with T#μ=μT_\#\mu=\mu. Let S⊂ES\subset E and let A⊂EA\subset E be measurable. Suppose S⊂T−1(A)S\subset T^{-1}(A), μ(S)=cν(S)\mu(S)=c\nu(S) and μ(A)=dν(S)\mu(A)=d\nu(S), where c,d∈[0,∞]c,d\in[0,\infty] satisfy d<cd<c. If ν(S)<∞\nu(S)<\infty, then ν(S)=0.\nu(S)=0.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for an integer d≥2d\ge2, an open set B⊂ℝdB\subset\mathbb R^d, a Borel probability measure ν\nu with ν(B)=1\nu(B)=1, and homeomorphisms H1,…,H4:B→ℝdH_1,\ldots,H_4:B\to\mathbb R^d onto open images such that B,H1(B),…,H4(B)B,H_1(B),\ldots,H_4(B) are pairwise disjoint, the measure μ=ν/3+(1/6)∑i=14(Hi)#ν\mu=\nu/3+(1/6)\sum_{i=1}^{4}(H_i)_\#\nu admits no Borel map T:ℝd→ℝdT:\mathbb R^d\to\mathbb R^d with T#μ=μT_\#\mu=\mu and T(x)∈{H1(x),…,H4(x)}T(x)\in\{H_1(x),\ldots,H_4(x)\} for ν\nu-almost every x∈Bx\in B.

What Is Checked

The selector statements (4), (5) and (6) concern the sets (2) for weighted mixtures (1) of finite nonzero reference measures under local homeomorphic branches or injective measurable branches with measurable images of measurable subsets, while (7) concerns arbitrary measures, a measurable preserving map, and a set of finite reference mass.