The Setting
A returning neck passage enters at one boundary and leaves through that boundary again. The question is the sign of its normal index for a small positive neck parameter .
Use coordinates on and the axial and transverse splitting . For transverse vectors and a real matrix , the matrix bilinear pairing, its quadratic form, and the transverse squared norm have the conventions (1)
The Neck and Its Endpoint Frames
Let be the standard smooth transition from zero to one. The one-sided cutoff and its integral , together with the shear transition and collar transition , are the functions (2) In terms of (2), the diagonal coefficients , shear , and cometric are defined by (3) The entries in the matrix in (3) are evaluated at .
The endpoint frame matrix gives the right endpoint cometric. For the frame choice and inward endpoint height , the coordinate cometric and its inverse metric matrix are (4) Primes on the matrices in (4) denote differentiation with respect to inward height.
The collar denominator is .✦ The terminal decay rate , logarithmic decay , and warping function are defined by (5)
On , a smooth family of symmetric positive definite bilinear forms with bounded unit balls defines the Riemannian metric .✦ A smooth moving linear frame is a smooth family of linear automorphisms of the coordinate space. The metric associated with a smooth moving linear frame on is the pullback of the Cartesian bilinear form by .✦ The triangular frame , for smooth nonvanishing and smooth , defines the cylinder metric (6) For , the normalized neck metric is the cylinder metric (6) with , from (5), and .✦
The right collar coordinate map is the affine map whose linear part is the isomorphism (7) For a Riemannian metric and a smooth map with invertible differential, the pullback metric is the metric with inner product . The endpoint-framed neck metrics, using (7), are (8)✦
The Index and Returning Data
For a smooth Riemannian metric on a three-manifold and a curve , the velocity is .✦ A field along is smooth on a time set if its coordinates are smooth on for every atlas chart .✦
In a chart, let be the standard basis vectors, the metric matrix, and the coordinate derivative. With , the Christoffel symbols and curvature components are (9) The connection operator and curvature operator are the operators with components and , respectively, with the coefficients of (9). The covariant derivative of a field along a curve is the tangent vector at whose coordinates are .✦ A geodesic on a time set in a Riemannian manifold is a smooth curve on with vanishing covariant acceleration in every chart.✦ For a field along , the curvature term at time is the tangent vector at .
For fields along a curve in a Riemannian manifold with metric , the intrinsic index density is the scalar function and the intrinsic index is its integral given by (10): (10) The metric and vectors in (10) are evaluated at .
For transverse matrices and split vectors , let be the split metric and let be the neck Christoffel operator, with axial derivative , given by (11) The split coordinate curvature tensor formed from (11) is (12)✦ The normal index density is the scalar function of split vectors given by (13), with and curvature (12): (13)✦
Fix an endpoint frame , momentum , height and height velocity . The momentum potential , reduced force , and velocity at fixed momentum are (14) For paths in the split tangent space, the returning density is (13) with the matrices evaluated along and with from (14).✦ The normal index of a split field on a passage of duration is the integral in (15): (15)
The Turning Parameters
For a real coefficient , the turning constants and the mixed coefficient bound are (16) For real coefficients , the turning smallness range is the set in (17), using the constants of (16): (17)✦
For an endpoint frame , coefficient and neck parameter , the full cometric bounds are the condition on that the following inequalities hold for every and : (18)
The Claim
Theorem 1. There are constants and such that every , in each endpoint frame , satisfies (19)✦
For the deep returning estimate, fix a frame , momentum , and . Assume the comparison and concavity bounds of (18). Let be the first tangential basis vector, and assume also that and for every . Let and let be smooth at every time of , with , and there. Suppose , for , and . For every split field smooth at every time of , with arbitrary endpoint values, the normal index (15) satisfies (20)✦
In the shallow estimate, fix a frame , and . Let be smooth at every time in and have height in throughout that interval. For every field , the intrinsic index for (8) satisfies (21)✦
Fix , and a frame for the turning estimate, with and . Let and let be open with . Let be a geodesic for on , and let be a smooth field along it on . Suppose has unit speed on and constant transverse momentum there, where . Assume , , for , and at some . Suppose either or vanishes on a neighborhood of . Then (22)✦
In the paper, the result reads: for every sufficiently small positive , every returning geodesic passage of the constructed neck has for every smooth field along the closed passage with unrestricted endpoint values, with one choice of valid at both boundaries for all unit-speed returning geodesics.
What Is Checked
The deep-return statement (20) is over the split normal density and smooth solutions of the fixed-momentum height equations; the uniform parameter statement (19) is over the two constructed coordinate cometrics. The intrinsic statements (21) and (22) are over the smooth endpoint-framed metrics, their covariant derivatives and curvature, with the stated interval and endpoint conditions.
For smooth radius functions that never vanish and smooth shear, the triangular frame varies smoothly with the point.✦ Pulling back the Cartesian bilinear form through a smooth moving frame gives a smooth bilinear field✦. The pullback bilinear field of a Riemannian metric by a smooth map is a smooth section.✦