OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. Geodesic passages and the index form

Lemma 4.1 [Tangential invariance]: Along a unit geodesic, without an endpoint condition on the added scalar function

Tangential additions preserve the normal index density.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A tangential addition to a vector field along a unit-speed neck geodesic changes both its value and its ordinary derivative. The normal index density is a function of these two vectors and the geodesic tangent at a single time.

A transverse matrix CC is a real 2×22\times2 matrix acting on the transverse vector space ℝ2\mathbb R^2.✦ A split tangent vector UU is a pair (Ut,U‾)∈ℝ×ℝ2(U^t,\bar U)\in\mathbb R\times\mathbb R^2, with axial component UtU^t and transverse component U‾\bar U.✦

Fix symmetric transverse matrices P,Q,A,BP,Q,A,B with Q=P−1Q=P^{-1}, where PP is the cometric matrix and QQ is the metric matrix. The matrix bilinear pairing ⟨⋅,⋅⟩C\langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle_C of a transverse matrix CC is the scalar-valued function of transverse vectors x,yx,y given by (1). ⟨x,y⟩C=x𝖳Cy.\langle x,y\rangle_C=x^{\mathsf T}Cy.(1)✦ The split neck metric gQg_Q is the bilinear form on split tangent vectors U,VU,V defined by (2). gQ(U,V)=UtVt+⟨U‾,V‾⟩Q.g_Q(U,V)=U^tV^t+\langle\bar U,\bar V\rangle_Q.(2)✦

The neck Christoffel operator Γ\Gamma is the bilinear map on split tangent vectors, with values in the split tangent space, defined by (3). Γ(U,V)=(−12⟨U‾,V‾⟩A,12(UtPAV‾+VtPAU‾)).\Gamma(U,V)= \left(-\frac12\langle\bar U,\bar V\rangle_A, \frac12\bigl(U^tPA\bar V+V^tPA\bar U\bigr)\right).(3)✦ The axial Christoffel derivative Γ1\Gamma_1 of the neck Christoffel operator Γ\Gamma is the bilinear map on split tangent vectors defined by (4). Γ1(U,V)=(−12⟨U‾,V‾⟩B,12(Ut(PB−PAPA)V‾+Vt(PB−PAPA)U‾)).\Gamma_1(U,V)= \left(-\frac12\langle\bar U,\bar V\rangle_B, \frac12\bigl(U^t(PB-PAPA)\bar V+V^t(PB-PAPA)\bar U\bigr)\right).(4)✦ The coordinate curvature tensor RR is the trilinear map on split tangent vectors U,V,WU,V,W specified by (5). R(U,V)W=UtΓ1(V,W)−VtΓ1(U,W)+Γ(U,Γ(V,W))−Γ(V,Γ(U,W)).\begin{split} R(U,V)W={}&U^t\Gamma_1(V,W)-V^t\Gamma_1(U,W)\\ &+\Gamma\bigl(U,\Gamma(V,W)\bigr) -\Gamma\bigl(V,\Gamma(U,W)\bigr). \end{split}(5)✦

For a tangent TT, a field value VV, and an ordinary derivative DD, the normal index density 𝒩(T,V,D)\mathcal N(T,V,D) is the scalar defined by (6). 𝒩(T,V,D)=gQ(D+Γ(T,V),D+Γ(T,V))−gQ(V,R(V,T)T)−gQ(D+Γ(T,V),T)2.\begin{split} \mathcal N(T,V,D)={}&g_Q\bigl(D+\Gamma(T,V),D+\Gamma(T,V)\bigr)\\ &-g_Q\bigl(V,R(V,T)T\bigr) -g_Q\bigl(D+\Gamma(T,V),T\bigr)^2. \end{split}(6)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let T,V,DT,V,D be split tangent vectors with gQ(T,T)=1g_Q(T,T)=1, and let a,ba,b be real numbers. Then 𝒩(T,V+aT,D+bT−aΓ(T,T))=𝒩(T,V,D).\mathcal N\bigl(T,V+aT,D+bT-a\Gamma(T,T)\bigr) =\mathcal N(T,V,D).(7)✦ Let V,T:ℝ→ℝ×ℝ2V,T\colon\mathbb R\to\mathbb R\times\mathbb R^2 and h:ℝ→ℝh\colon\mathbb R\to\mathbb R be differentiable at a geodesic time ss. Assume gQ(T(s),T(s))=1g_Q(T(s),T(s))=1 and T′(s)=−Γ(T(s),T(s))T'(s)=-\Gamma(T(s),T(s)), and write D=V′(s)D=V'(s). Then 𝒩(T(s),V(s)+h(s)T(s),(V+hT)′(s))=𝒩(T(s),V(s),D).\mathcal N\bigl(T(s),V(s)+h(s)T(s),(V+hT)'(s)\bigr) =\mathcal N\bigl(T(s),V(s),D\bigr).(8)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a field VV along a unit geodesic with tangent TT in a Riemannian manifold with metric gg, set q=g(V,T)q=g(V,T) and V⟂=V−qTV^\perp=V-qT; the normal-index integrand of VV is the index integrand of V⟂V^\perp, and, for every smooth real function hh, the normal index on a time interval JJ satisfies IJ⟂(V+hT)=IJ⟂(V)I_J^\perp(V+hT)=I_J^\perp(V) whenever both fields have the finite integrals required in its definition, with pointwise invariance and no condition on hh at finite endpoints.

What Is Checked

The claims (7) and (8) are stated over the split neck metric and coordinate curvature tensor associated with symmetric real matrices P,Q,A,BP,Q,A,B satisfying QP=Id⁡2QP=\operatorname{Id}_2, where Id⁡2\operatorname{Id}_2 is the identity matrix, and at a unit tangent; the second also assumes differentiability of the field, tangent, and scalar function at ss, with T′(s)=−Γ(T(s),T(s))T'(s)=-\Gamma(T(s),T(s)).